News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by ashark on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:37PM (#14426585)
> A tablet (iPad or otherwise) much less so; tablets are very much "consumption" devices, which can consume packaged educational content and videos, but don't help with collaboration.

If you told me I had to make a video or a drawing, collaborative or otherwise, and I could only have an iPad or a laptop (and no special peripherals for either), and nothing else, I'd take the iPad without hesitation.

I might take it if you told me I had to make a song, too, depending on the laptops on offer (the alternative in schools is usually Chromebooks) and what sorts of instruments (if any) I might be permitted to use.

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by JoshTriplett on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:47PM (#14426640)
> If you told me I had to make a video or a drawing, collaborative or otherwise, and I could only have an iPad or a laptop (and no special peripherals for either), and nothing else, I'd take the iPad without hesitation.

A drawing, perhaps, though only if the laptop can't be flipped around to put the touchscreen at a convenient angle. A convertible with a stylus seems ideal for that.

But a video? I'd definitely prefer the laptop.

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by ashark on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:51PM (#14426667)
My experience has been that even fairly high-end laptops have much worse cameras than i-devices, and usually only have a front-facing one, making for some really awkward, shaky, low-quality filming and a lot of difficulty framing shots, manipulating controls while filming, and so on.

[EDIT] which reminds me: for any photography-related project, I'd take the iPad too, obviously. Really anything that's not mostly typing or very suited to the use of a mouse.

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by bluGill on Friday May 26, 2017 @05:22PM (#14427294)
When someone says make a video to me I think taking a bunch of clips with a camera and putting them together into a video. Since I have already assumed a camera all that is left is editing, and I'll take a computer over a tablet for that.

I agree that taking the clips the tablet is better than with any computer.

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by JoshTriplett on Saturday May 27, 2017 @02:17AM (#14429131)
This, yes; I was talking about video editing, not video recording.