News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by JoshTriplett on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:27PM (#14426530)
A tablet (iPad or otherwise) much less so; tablets are very much "consumption" devices, which can consume packaged educational content and videos, but don't help with collaboration.

However, a two-way interactive device like a laptop or Chromebook? Typing homework instead of writing it? Having collaborative tools available to work with others, both in and out of school? Playing with preliminary programming environments? Trying experiments and visualizations? Yes, that can absolutely help.

Just handing a device to every student will not automatically improve education, though; they're not magic. There need to be lesson plans, adapted materials, tools (e.g. for teachers to collaborate with students and students to collaborate with each other), and not just the same lessons ported to turn in homework on a computer. That takes time and effort, but the result will be students much more adapted to a highly tech-integrated society.

(Disclaimer: the above derives from professional experience and observations, but is not a comment made with my professional hat on; not speaking for anyone else here.)

As for the comments on social media: yes, and that's something many of them will do as adults too. Many people are highly social, and hang out with each other online. Some of what they do will be educational and productive, but having a computer doesn't mean it has to be used entirely for education and productivity. Even just posting online provides practice writing and typing, both of which benefit from practice. Some of their time might be spent on random Internet forum sites arguing with each other, which of course will never be a skill they'll make use of as well-adjusted adults like us. But it'll keep kids inside and thus off your lawn.

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by ashark on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:37PM (#14426585)
> A tablet (iPad or otherwise) much less so; tablets are very much "consumption" devices, which can consume packaged educational content and videos, but don't help with collaboration.

If you told me I had to make a video or a drawing, collaborative or otherwise, and I could only have an iPad or a laptop (and no special peripherals for either), and nothing else, I'd take the iPad without hesitation.

I might take it if you told me I had to make a song, too, depending on the laptops on offer (the alternative in schools is usually Chromebooks) and what sorts of instruments (if any) I might be permitted to use.

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by JoshTriplett on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:47PM (#14426640)
> If you told me I had to make a video or a drawing, collaborative or otherwise, and I could only have an iPad or a laptop (and no special peripherals for either), and nothing else, I'd take the iPad without hesitation.

A drawing, perhaps, though only if the laptop can't be flipped around to put the touchscreen at a convenient angle. A convertible with a stylus seems ideal for that.

But a video? I'd definitely prefer the laptop.

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by ashark on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:51PM (#14426667)
My experience has been that even fairly high-end laptops have much worse cameras than i-devices, and usually only have a front-facing one, making for some really awkward, shaky, low-quality filming and a lot of difficulty framing shots, manipulating controls while filming, and so on.

[EDIT] which reminds me: for any photography-related project, I'd take the iPad too, obviously. Really anything that's not mostly typing or very suited to the use of a mouse.

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by bluGill on Friday May 26, 2017 @05:22PM (#14427294)
When someone says make a video to me I think taking a bunch of clips with a camera and putting them together into a video. Since I have already assumed a camera all that is left is editing, and I'll take a computer over a tablet for that.

I agree that taking the clips the tablet is better than with any computer.

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by JoshTriplett on Saturday May 27, 2017 @02:17AM (#14429131)
This, yes; I was talking about video editing, not video recording.
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by jansho on Friday May 26, 2017 @05:40PM (#14427413)
> Just handing a device to every student will not automatically improve education, though; they're not magic.

This. Blended learning is more of an art; if you are interested in how it can be applied in schools, I highly recommend this MOOC: https://www.coursera.org/learn/blended-learning

Lots of different models, readings and videos, including tours of the more "tech-savvy" schools :)

Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by sp332 on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:32PM (#14426559)
How is a Chromebook less of a consumption device than an iPad?
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by JoshTriplett on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:45PM (#14426623)
It has a real keyboard, and far more collaborative tools.
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by SimbaOnSteroids on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:38PM (#14426589)
Chromebook allows you to type papers etc.
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by sp332 on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:46PM (#14426634)
But Apple Pages is free for iPad, and so are Google Docs and Microsoft Word. And of course you can run all the same webapps as on the Chromebook.
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by Larrikin on Friday May 26, 2017 @05:12PM (#14427225)
I've seen first hand students waste time trying to highlight something correctly or navigate the menu by pecking away at the screen of their iPad, when a mouse would have made their actions much faster and more precise
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by JoshTriplett on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:47PM (#14426642)
You could supply hardware keyboard-cases that prop up the tablet at a usable angle. But otherwise, typing long documents on a tablet is a miserable experience.
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by sp332 on Friday May 26, 2017 @03:50PM (#14426659)
This is more flexible. The iPad can gain a keyboard when you need one, but Chromebooks can't lose their keyboards when they get in the way.
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by nickster on Friday May 26, 2017 @04:31PM (#14426925)
They have convertible chromebooks.
Re:Ask HN: Do computers and tablets really improve education... by btschaegg on Saturday May 27, 2017 @12:27PM (#14430729)
This. As the owner of a full-body aluminium convertible chromebook, I'd concur: The point about "losing the keyboard" doesn't apply per se, if you're talking about the right Chromebook model. The Asus C100P for example makes a good tablet and its laptop-experience has never been matched with any iPad-keyboard I've seen so far.

On the other hand, a Chromebook's problem (for now) regarding the "tablet mode" lies in the ChromeOS GUI: It wasn't designed with touch screens in mind (especially the browser itself) and feels clunkier than other tablet controls. Google are on their way to remedy that through their integration of Android apps though. They're certainly not there yet, but I can imagine that changing in the forseeable future.