News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by sachinag on Thursday June 17, 2010 @07:54PM (#1440834)
This is tangentally related, but I'm going to break my contract with Verizon after buying a Motorola Devour in March. I believe that Motorola and VZW have broken an implied promise to support my Android phone through the update cycle; it shipped with 1.6 and it appears that the powers that be have decided that it's not worthy of the engineering resources to get it up to 2.2, so it'll be at 1.6 forever.

I'm sorry, but a three-month old phone should not be obsolete. If I get a iPhone 4, I have every confidence that Apple will make every effort to ensure that subsequent iOS upgrades work on my phone until there's a legitimate technical reason to exclude it, not some bullshit profit/loss maximization algorithm.

The Android ecosystem will remain fragmented because every single phone+manufacturer+carrier combination requires a decision and engineering resources to upgrade. I could never recommend an Android phone to anyone but the anti-Apple hordes.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by Splines on Thursday June 17, 2010 @08:28PM (#1440892)
> If I get a iPhone 4, I have every confidence that Apple will make every effort to ensure that subsequent iOS upgrades work on my phone until there's a legitimate technical reason to exclude it,...

Kudos to Apple for doing this, by the way. I have an iPhone 3G and really appreciate Apple's efforts in keeping my device up-to-date.

Apple's decision to own the phone from end-to-end (sans AT&T) has proven to provide a high-quality experience to customers. It's telling that the only part of the experience that Apple doesn't own is arguably the largest pain point of the iPhone.

It's too bad that Android/WinMo answer to the OEMs, and not the other way around. If Compaq or Dell dictated upgrade policies for PCs the world would be a very different place.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by nlawalker on Thursday June 17, 2010 @09:37PM (#1441027)
My 3G became dog slow as a dog when I installed the software that was released alongside the 3GS. It has been ever since, through every following upgrade.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by mkramlich on Friday June 18, 2010 @04:11AM (#1441645)
I noticed my 3G seemed to start getting slower, have more frequent "world has come to a stop" pauses right around when the 3GS came out. I wondered a bit if it was a conspiracy of sorts, something intentional Apple did to make the non-3GS models seem even slower than they were. Not sure, of course, or whether a coincidence. But it's interesting to hear at least one other person noticed this.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by allend on Friday June 18, 2010 @04:20AM (#1441659)
It's almost surely your imagination, even if other people have had the same experience. By the way, I have the same experience.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by aston on Thursday June 17, 2010 @08:42PM (#1440914)
Here's a fun factoid: your iPhone 3G (and mine) will totally miss out on iOS4's multi-tasking. If Apple is better than Motorola/Verizon in terms of keeping older hardware up-to-date, it's not by much.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by czhiddy on Thursday June 17, 2010 @08:48PM (#1440930)
I imagine iOS4 multitasking on a 128mb device would be horrible. The OS has grown with every release; there's probably even less memory for apps to work with in 4.0. I think Apple would rather see complaints of not supporting the 3G rather than scathing reviews of how poorly it performs.

No updates for a 3 month old phone is quite a large difference from leaving a hardware-limited feature out of an update to a 2 year old device.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by megablast on Thursday June 17, 2010 @10:06PM (#1441082)
Another interesting point, the new iPhone 4 has 512mb ram, the 3GS and iPad have 256mb. A lot of people think it was strange to put only 256mb in the iPad.

Just wondering what sort of stuff the new iPhone 4 will get that the ipad will not. Hopefully it is just more memory for video related stuff, and will not hold back any new upgrades for the ipad.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by pietrofmaggi on Friday June 18, 2010 @04:51AM (#1441694)
The iPad is an older project, when it started, on single task iPhoneOS 3.2, 256MB of RAM was the "right amount".

Now with iOS4, simil-multitasking and a lot of video to edit, 256MB seems just a bit to tight.

We have to wait and see if the release of the iOS4 for the iPad will bring come new hardware with it.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by masklinn on Friday June 18, 2010 @05:44AM (#1441766)
Yeah but though I expect the iPad project was a closely guarded secret within Apple, iOS 4 likely wasn't, and the iPhone 4 was probably less of a secret than the pad. Why the iPad team didn't get any hints as to the amount of RAM to put in the thing is beyond me, especially as there are already reports of RAM-limitation issues on the pad (e.g. where iPhone 3gs Safari can keep half a dozen tabs around without reloading them all the time, iPad is apparently unable to)
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by SandB0x on Thursday June 17, 2010 @08:51PM (#1440936)
Double-tangentially related. My contract with Vodafone (UK) is up for renewal soon and there's the HTC Wildfire, Nexus One, Desire, Legend, Tattoo listed on the website. Just to be clear, this is attempting to narrow it down to one carrier, one manufacturer, one operating system. How about a clear flagship model and a budget option rather than all this shitty confusion? Then maybe you'll have the engineering resources to keep the two or three models up to date.

This is similar to my laptop rant the other day. It's sad to see companies shooting themselves in the foot.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by orangecat on Thursday June 17, 2010 @10:45PM (#1441157)
Agreed that they're making things way more complicated than they should be. As far as the parent poster, I have no idea why the Devour even exists; it's inferior to the Droid in every way. In your case the Nexus One is clearly the way to go; nothing else is significantly better spec-wise, and being Google's "official" model it's guaranteed to get updates first.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by usaar333 on Thursday June 17, 2010 @11:20PM (#1441220)
In your specific case, the only clear "dumb" redundancies are the wildfire and legend (the differences seem trivial). And yes, I agree, it makes little sense for HTC to be making such similar models.

The Desire is the flagship (to htc), the tattoo is the low-end budget and the legend/wildfire is mid-range.

All of the other models HTC makes seem to be due to deals with carriers/other companies. The Nexus One is a google-branded phone sans sense. The Sprint hero had changes from the regular due to Sprint. The last goes on.

I imagine HTC is somewhat forced into this position. They don't have enough market power, so if a carrier wants something different, they generally have to comply.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by buster on Friday June 18, 2010 @05:06AM (#1441719)
Does "currently evaluated" mean "we won't update"? Not sure how Motorola handled that. Is it just marketing talk or will they just drop the update?

https://supportforums.motorola.com/community/manager/softwar...

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by wvenable on Friday June 18, 2010 @12:29AM (#1441341)
In the same vein, if you get an iPhone 4 you can every confidence that Apple will make every effort to ensure that innovative and competitive software will be rejected or removed from the app store. I'd say that's as much of a problem with iOS platform as older OS versions is with Android. If you want the same iPhone upgrade experience with Android, your best option is to get a Nexus One.

As a WinMo user, I've long accepted that the OEMs are terrible. My solution to this problem is make sure that whatever phone I buy has a strong hacker community around it so that I can unofficially upgrade whenever I wish. With my current phone, I flashed away from the stock ROM within a week and I upgrade every 6 months or so. In fact, I can even run Android on my phone even though it didn't exist when my phone was originally released.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by loewenskind on Friday June 18, 2010 @03:07AM (#1441554)
>In the same vein, if you get an iPhone 4 you can every confidence that Apple will make every effort to ensure that innovative and competitive software will be rejected or removed from the app store.

This is just nonsense. Looks like your one of the "anti-apple hoard" the GGP was talking about. It's pretty well known why the 2%-3% of apps get rejected: using a private API, violating the agreement, violating laws (e.g. ignoring codec copyrights).

Name one single piece of "innovative and competitive software" that was rejected without a good reason.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by ZeroGravitas on Friday June 18, 2010 @03:13AM (#1441566)
Google Voice.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by loewenskind on Friday June 18, 2010 @03:21AM (#1441573)
"TechCrunch suspects, probably correctly, that apps for Google Voice are being rejected at least in part through AT&T's influence, since Google Voice lets you send free text messages and delivers cut-rate international calls on top of making phone numbers even more meaningless making it scary to AT&T in way like Skype VoIP over 3G." [1]

If you're trying to bypass the phone company that is using the phone as a loss leader of course you can expect that app to be rejected. Skype is approved though, afaik. Is that your only example?

[1] http://gizmodo.com/5324268/apple-rejects-official-google-voi...

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by ahk on Friday June 18, 2010 @04:06AM (#1441636)
The fact that Google Voice is actually available in the US on pretty much all Android phones, makes your point moot.

The iPhone does not have one of the most innovative apps for a phone. QED.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by loewenskind on Friday June 18, 2010 @04:26AM (#1441666)
Google voice is one of the most innovative apps? I've never even heard of it before today. Everyone I know uses Skype (which is on the iPhone, right?).
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by ZeroGravitas on Friday June 18, 2010 @05:00AM (#1441706)
It's not a competitor to Skype. That's Google Talk. I don't think it's unfair to say that Google Voice is generally regarded as an amazing innovation in mobile phone arena.

And speaking of Skype, will they be allowed to do video chat on the iPhone 4? Maybe they will, maybe they won't. I wouldn't bet my house on it though.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by andybak on Friday June 18, 2010 @07:25AM (#1441881)
Sorry to say it but if you haven't heard of Google Voice you should probably leave this debate to people who are qualified to comment.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by loewenskind on Friday June 18, 2010 @07:49AM (#1441905)
Well I'm a consumer so I'm automatically qualified to comment. If Google voice were so innovative and amazing it would be something I wish I could get.

For example, I do wish I could have VLC, but it's pretty obvious why I can't. This is the trade off of controlling your channels. Apple can't just say "well, we let this app on and if people want to use it to watch 'illegal' movies, there's nothing we can do about it", since they very well can do something about it. Android, with their open architecture probably can't block things like VLC so they can't be held responsible for people using it.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by wvenable on Friday June 18, 2010 @12:09PM (#1442649)
> If Google voice were so innovative and amazing it would be something I wish I could get.

It is. When I posted my comment, Google voice was the main example I was thinking of (but certainly not the only one). The fact that you don't know about it is part of the problem. It'd easily be on the top of the app store lists if it was available. It just goes to show that because of Apple you don't even know what you're missing.

Your VLC example doesn't make any sense. You can watch whatever illegal movies (and illegal music) on your iPhone all you want using the built in software. You'll never get VLC, not because of anything illegal, but because "it duplicates functionality already existing in the phone". That's it.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by loewenskind on Monday June 21, 2010 @03:04AM (#1448206)
>It is.

Google voice is what? An implementation of VoIP? I wouldn't call that innovative, there are plenty of companies doing VoIP, none of which would ever be allowed on the iPhone because of carrier restrictions.

>You'll never get VLC, not because of anything illegal, but because "it duplicates functionality already existing in the phone". That's it.

Not true. Have you been in the app store? There are tons of apps that just duplicate functionality. There are several browsers and a few streaming video players.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by wvenable on Monday June 21, 2010 @12:52PM (#1449322)
> Google voice is what? An implementation of VoIP?

No, it's not. I could tell you spend the next 15 minutes telling you what it is or you could just look it up yourself on this thing called the Internet. Your purposeful ignorance here is not a good argument tactic.

The reason that Apple rejected Google voice was because of the "duplicate functionality" argument. Other apps don't prove anything except that they aren't threatening to Apple. As soon as an app exists that is, they just pull out one of these excuses and it's gone.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by loewenskind on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @02:28AM (#1451137)
I did look it up before I posted. Voice IP with some functionality to turn your messages to text. Their not the first or only people to do any of these things.

It is a shame that they used "duplicate functionality" as the excuse, they should have just said "this is not acceptable under our AT&T plan".

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by wvenable on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @01:51PM (#1452586)
Of course, if you have another other AT&T phone (Android, WinMo, Blackberry) you have no problem using Google Voice. The only way you can't use it (with a native app) on the AT&T network is if you have an iPhone.

Also, it's not VoIP from the phone like Skype is. It uses your regular voice connection and voice minutes and not the data connection. What it does provide is a portable phone number, free SMS, voice mail transcriptions, and a host of other calling features. It's the kind of innovative application you'd expect when you combine the cloud with smartphone technology. Apple just doesn't want you to have it.

Unfortunately, back to your original comment about why apps are rejected (private apis, etc, etc) is, unfortunately for you, not true. Lets say you want an app to control your PC bittorrent app from your iPhone? -- Forget it, also not allowed. I understand now allowing apps that put strain on the network or use private apis but rejecting innovative apps or app that hurt Steve Jobs sense of morality just rubs me the wrong way. I'd rather have an open platform with a slower upgrade cycle.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by inklesspen on Saturday June 19, 2010 @02:11AM (#1444234)
No, you'll never get VLC because there's no point in it; the phone isn't powerful enough to decode videos in realtime unless (a) you use hardware decryption support or (b) they're the size of a postage stamp. The built-in video player supports all the codecs the hardware supports. I really can't think of any benefit to having VLC on a phone.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by mccon104 on Friday June 18, 2010 @09:50AM (#1442192)
I can't down vote this sort of snark enough... insolence doesn't look good on anyone
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by andybak on Friday June 18, 2010 @10:11AM (#1442247)
I would argue that in a conversation about app store rejection policies and specifically Google Voice that someone informing us that they have never heard of it wasn't doing much more than adding noise.

To anyone who has heard of Google Voice it's pretty clear that it's valid to put it forward as a innovative product. The level to which it's failed to permeated the broader public consciousness doesn't count against it at this stage in it's existence.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by mccon104 on Sunday June 20, 2010 @05:11PM (#1447172)
I'd say your response added just as much noise and introduced a degree of intolerance not necessary to the conversation. Let the non-helpful comments die a silent lonely death, no need to get haughty about it.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by andybak on Tuesday June 22, 2010 @04:03AM (#1451253)
Fair point. I spend too much time at Reddit and sometimes forget which tone is appropriate.

and I'd hate to contribute to making HN another Reddit...

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by c1sc0 on Friday June 18, 2010 @03:32AM (#1441590)
Here's a free app idea: I challenge you to make a chatroulette for iPhone 4's FaceTime. You can use twilio to connect the calls & even charge a little money through in-app purchases. The code should be a one-nighter & then you still have 5 days to get it accepted in the store.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by allend on Friday June 18, 2010 @04:04AM (#1441632)
He said innovative and competitive.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by jasonkester on Friday June 18, 2010 @03:14AM (#1441567)
My solution to this problem is make sure that whatever phone I buy has a strong hacker community around it so that I can unofficially upgrade whenever I wish.

This is awesome. Not because of any of the parent's points, but simply because we're living in a world where telephones have their own communities of hackers. How fast did that happen?

I still have a phone that does little more than make phone calls, and the best hackers in the world when it came out were barely able to get it playing "snake". And it's not a very old phone.

The future rules!

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by bitwize on Friday June 18, 2010 @10:59AM (#1442393)
Telephones have had hackers long before even computers have. In fact, that market is where Jobs and Woz got their start -- selling blue boxes...
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by wvenable on Friday June 18, 2010 @12:04PM (#1442625)
My general rule now is to not buy a tech product if it's not hackable. Even my wrist watch (a Timex Datalink) is running custom software to enhance its interface.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by ahk on Friday June 18, 2010 @01:35AM (#1441441)
Oh come on. Blaming Android for Verizon/Motorola's failings (and your own in not realizing what everyone was saying was _the_ advantage of the Nexus One) as well as rapid technological progress is pathetic.

Do you even remember the stunt Apple pulled a few years ago where they dropped the price of iPhone from $599 to $399? Do you intend to ping pong between Apple and Android whenever they announce such decisions?

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by masklinn on Friday June 18, 2010 @03:03AM (#1441548)
> Blaming Android for Verizon/Motorola's failings (and your own in not realizing what everyone was saying was _the_ advantage of the Nexus One) as well as rapid technological progress is pathetic.

His point is that, unless he buys a N1 maybe, he will never ever have any guarantees that his phone will be kept up to date for even 2 years.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by ahk on Friday June 18, 2010 @04:02AM (#1441630)
Have you/the OP heard of Android's extremely lively mod scene? Cyanogen even supports the ancient G1 to very nearly the latest 2.1 version of android.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by masklinn on Friday June 18, 2010 @05:43AM (#1441763)
Most users are not going to bother with rooting their phones and installing cyanogen.

> Cyanogen even supports the ancient G1 to very nearly the latest 2.1 version of android.

Disingenuous, Cyanogen specifically supports 4 phones: Dream, Magic, N1 and Droid. Notice the distinct lack of Motorola Devour in the list?

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by ahk on Friday June 18, 2010 @12:59PM (#1442862)
I was responding to the parent's point about "only" "N1 maybe", which is obviously false.
Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by loewenskind on Friday June 18, 2010 @03:11AM (#1441560)
Ok, so Apple haters blast Apple for keeping such a tight control and cheer when savior Google comes out with something "open", but when that openness is used by the vendors to do what they want instead of what Google wants it's not Google's fault? Did you ever stop to think that perhaps the reason Apple behaves as it does is to avoid exactly this problem?

You're pointing at something you think should theoretically be better and pointing fingers when it doesn't pan out, meanwhile the "evil" alternative is giving users a great experience.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by ahk on Friday June 18, 2010 @03:57AM (#1441626)
Where am I attacking Apple in my post? I'm actually as much of an Apple fanboy as anyone else who stands in line at the Apple store waiting for hours for their product releases. And I've done that myself once.

But just because I love Apple products, it doesn't mean I cannot also defend Android when someone blames it for something thats not its fault. I love Google and Android for what they do too.

And yes, the openness leading to such situations is not Google/Android's fault. Just as much as an authorized gun salesman making a legal sale is not at fault when someone then uses their guns to go postal.

Also, the OP getting so worked up comparing support for a little known model of cellphone to Apple's flagship product is funny if not foolish.

Re:'First to Do It' vs. 'First to Do It Right' by loewenskind on Friday June 18, 2010 @04:15AM (#1441653)
I didn't mean you specifically were attacking Apple. What I meant, and what my point was, is that Apple is attacked for keeping control of it's platform, but now we see what happens when one doesn't.

Your gun analogy doesn't fit. Google doesn't control their distributor so the product they make may never see the light of day. It's not about someone using Google's free offering to injure someone, but rather taking it, making their own (inferior) creation and passing that off as Android.

I welcome competition in the space to be sure, but people screaming about Apple keeping control of their product (would you expect anything else from Steve Jobs?) are missing the point IMO.