News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @12:49PM (#14402818)
He beat the more well-known inventor Thomas Edison by 20 years, though his accomplishments were only recognized over the last decade.

Just another example of how being first or early, even in groundbreaking things, means you will probably not find success.

Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by accountyaccount on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @12:59PM (#14402908)
As strange as it seems, all the French inventor cared about was seeing what sound looked like.

>Just another example of how being first or early, even in groundbreaking things, means you will probably not find success.

Well no, in this case the inventor of sound recording just had an entirely different goal.

Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by sixothree on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @01:36PM (#14403240)
And neither he nor anyone exposed to this idea were able to make the connection to playback ability. I do find that a bit surprising.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by subroutine on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @01:48PM (#14403378)
Apparently Scott first had to convince people that sound came from vibrations.

> Scott proved that vibrations are truly how sounds came to our ears. But Thompson says the scientific community had trouble accepting his breakthrough.

So maybe it's not too surprising.

Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by WalterBright on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @10:16PM (#14407134)
Any violin/piano player already knew that.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by wutbrodo on Wednesday May 24, 2017 @01:08AM (#14407725)
I'm skeptical that they knew that vibrating air was what our ears perceived as sound. If you know a little about the history of science, there are tons of theories that held up for some time that are no less "ridiculous" to our eyes than some special medium moving through air that our ears process as sound. The fact that the _source_ of sound was known to vibrate doesn't exclude this possibility, and _that's_ what violin/piano players knew about (Sources of visible light often give off heat, but saying that light and heat are the same thing is not implied by that).
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by WalterBright on Wednesday May 24, 2017 @01:46AM (#14407836)
See my other reply to this topic, which is directly to your point.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by mikestew on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @01:05PM (#14402972)
Scott's invention made pretty drawings on soot-covered paper. Edison's invention allowed one to play back recorded sound. Just another example of how novelty will not succeed in the face of actually useful inventions.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by logicallee on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @01:09PM (#14403009)
It's the difference between an MVP and an MP. Just because it works, doesn't make it an M-V-P.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by cfmcdonald on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @01:44PM (#14403335)
The phonautograph was a perfectly viable 'product', as a tool for investigating the physical properties of sound.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by logicallee on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @02:02PM (#14403551)
So your confusion underscores my point: viable means that the marketplace wants and does buy it. i.e. it's enough of a product to to make sales and take off. If nobody is buying it (or for free models, using it), it's not an MVP. It's just a working product.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by chc on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @03:11PM (#14404249)
So the V in MVP stands for "true Scotsman"?
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by logicallee on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @04:39PM (#14405112)
Similar. It is a mistake to say, "We made our MVP but nobody wanted it." That's a contradiction in terms. The minimum VIABLE product is the minimum thing that people do want, and are willing to pay for. That's what viable means. What do you think viable means? (Genuinely curious.)
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by chc on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @05:08PM (#14405362)
As I've heard it defined, the "viable" part basically means that you could tell someone with a straight face that this product would be useful to them. It doesn't need to have wide-market appeal, since the point is to start as small as possible and use early feedback to guide the development of the full product.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by logicallee on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @05:13PM (#14405408)
>you could tell someone with a straight face that this product would be useful to them

The title of the article we're reading is literally "no one cared."

Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by Retra on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @07:11PM (#14406245)
And that's literally a rhetorical exaggeration.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by logicallee on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @07:35PM (#14406417)
In my reading, it was not enough to be a viable product, because it did not play back sounds. For this reason, it was not yet marketable; it could not be sold. It was less than the minimum product which could be sold. I think it's pretty clear and I'm kind of shocked that you disagree with me.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by MBCook on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @10:57PM (#14407291)
But the guy wasn't trying to market it, he was trying to investigate something. For his purposes it seems to have worked and been viable.

It's just that his purposes weren't commercial in nature, they were scientific.

Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by logicallee on Wednesday May 24, 2017 @06:11AM (#14408854)
Which is why he didn't expand on it until he got to the MVP stage. Not wanting to make an MVP, because you're a scientist not a salesman, does not mean that what you do make actually already is an MVP. It's a distinction with a difference. I just used it as an example to illustrate the idea.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by cfmcdonald on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @05:06PM (#14405345)
I don't think I'm the one that's confused. The phonautograph was perfectly viable for the purpose for which it was created - to study the physical nature of sound. This is evident because others within the scientific world of the time copied/modified/used the design, in order to do just that, e.g. Alexander Graham Bell.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by logicallee on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @05:12PM (#14405393)
The term MVP is from the context of a go-to-market strategy (i.e. for a startup). It's not a reflection on whether a tool performs its purpose.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by MBCook on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @10:59PM (#14407297)
The guy was doing scientific experimentation, having a go to market strategy wasn't involved at all.

It's a bit like saying a cat playing with the piece of paper is a bad writer because it doesn't have a publishing deal lined up.

Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by ghaff on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @04:51PM (#14405210)
And after his initial work, Edison just sat on it for about 10 years until a competitor started to come along. At which point, he did some more work to make his own product marketable.
Re:At The Dawn Of Recorded Sound, No One Cared by hectorr on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @02:29PM (#14403845)
If you want extrinsic rewards, you need to provide extrinsic value.