News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by muninn_ on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @09:11AM (#14400829)
> having a United States that doesn't seem like a country you can count on

In what way? A Russian attack on Germany or a NATO ally is something the US would definitely go to war over. I know it's popular now to freak out because Trump is president, but nothing has changed in this regard.

Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by matt4077 on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @09:21AM (#14400908)
Words have meaning, and there's no denying that Trump has, quite literally, questioned the US' commitment to the common defence doctrine. It's not like there's some court of law somewhere that would make Latvia whole again if Trump decided not to fulfil the US' treaty obligations after the "Latvian association of I-am-just-a-farmer–oh-look-I-found-a-Russian-tank" wins the referendum to join Russia.
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by muninn_ on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @10:42AM (#14401624)
Questioned, but I don't think that means the US is ready to abandon countries like Germany. I think Latvia is an interesting case because, frankly, should the US go to war over Latvia if Russia invaded? I think we would because of the treaty, but idk if the US (absent NATO) should do it. At one point is it worth the risk? That's the thing with Russia. At one point do you say no and go to war with them over a land grab? Germany is a clear case of going to war, same with other Tier 1 US allies, but Latvia?
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by dogma1138 on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @11:25AM (#14402027)
Do you remember how WW2 started, and more importantly what preceded it? ;)
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by muninn_ on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @12:12PM (#14402438)
Sure, but so what?
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by dogma1138 on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @12:52PM (#14402844)
The baltics are effectively czechoslovakia.

You can't decide who to go to war for under NATO, it's all or nothing.

Not to mention that ssignaling to Russia that the US might not intervened under Article 5 is a good way to start WW3.

NATO works because the fate of a the Baltics is equal to the fate of Germany.

The problem is that Europe has enjoyed the umbrella that the US provides under NATO too long without owning to its own obligated defense commitments under the treaty.

I don't understand why people are calling out the Trump administration because of this.

Sec def Gates had much more damning things to say about NATO under Obama and the EU's unwillingness to commit its obligated military spending goes as back as Reagan.

Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by muninn_ on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @01:07PM (#14402989)
I don't really disagree, my larger point was that I question whether the US would go to war over the baltics, but I don't question that they would go to war over Germany. The alliance may fall apart if they didn't go to war over the baltics, but there is no question in my mind that, if instead of attacking the baltic, the Russians attacked Germany that the US would be full-on in Germany's defense.
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by dogma1138 on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @01:44PM (#14403333)
It definitely would because not honoring Article 5 means that the US loses its relevance in its entirety in the region leaving Europe for Russia if nothing else then purely in the geopolitical landscape for the taking.
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by muninn_ on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @02:00PM (#14403525)
No, it doesn't. There's a huge mess associated with Article 5, but not defending Lativa is not the same thing as unwilling to defend Germany, or France, or the UK, etc....
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by dogma1138 on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @03:20PM (#14404313)
If article 5 is invoked and the US doesn't do anything then NATO is gone.

After that US influence in the region is going to be pretty much gone.

EU plotitians are going to be much more open to Russian world views since they will not gamble their security on US internal politics.

The exact same thing happened in the Middle East under the previous administration moving Russia from a loud but mostly sidelined actor to the main stage.

Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by notfromhere on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @12:33PM (#14402660)
if NATO doesn't defend the Baltics the whole alliance falls apart.
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by LyndsySimon on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @09:22AM (#14400917)
It could be argued that the US's (lack of) reaction to Russian occupation of Crimea and its lack of involvement in the situation between Russia and Turkey has eroded the guarantee that NATO is supposed to provide.
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by muninn_ on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @09:56AM (#14401189)
Not much the Us can do about Turkey. Crimea is far more complicated than can be discussed reasonably here.

Germany though, is a whole different ball game. There are different tiers of countries in the view of the US. Countries like Germany, are in the tier of "we will go to war if you declare war against them". Even if Trump is president. He is right to question the alliances, though.

Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by votepaunchy on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @09:56AM (#14401187)
Neither the Ukraine nor Turkey are NATO members and have no bearing on the NATO guarantee.
Re:German Bundeswehr cooperates more closely with European A... by somewhatoff on Tuesday May 23, 2017 @10:05AM (#14401253)
Turkey is very definitely a NATO member, and has been since 1952.