News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by viraptor on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @09:27PM (#1437656)
Ok - I haven't been following this event that much so far. Can someone tell me why the simplest solution of limiting the leak effects is not possible - namely building a large tunnel going from the surface to the leak point, making a space where the oil can safely leak, while it's being transported away? Is it the depth? area? size of the flow?
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by brown9-2 on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @10:24PM (#1437742)
The leak is 5000 feet below the surface of the ocean.

Water is heavy. 5000 feet of it is a whole lot of pressure that such a tunnel would have to withstand.

The "simplest solution" is often one that is completely impractical given the facts.

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by giardini on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @11:40PM (#1437861)
No, No! Neither "tunnel" nor well need to withstand the pressure of 5000 feet of water. Reason is that the well (tunnel) is always filled with either water or drilling mud (roughly the same density as water) so the inside and outside pressure on the drilling pipe are the same. The pressure differences are not significant until/unless drilling into an oil or gas pocket. Even then the pocket must have a pressure significantly greater than that of the 5000 feet of water to be any problem. But that's what blowout preventers are for.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by SapphireSun on Thursday June 17, 2010 @12:05AM (#1437909)
Don't forget that it's not only the lateral pressure you have to deal with, you have to have pipes that can not crumple under their own weight and simultaneously withstand extremely high torques due to ocean currents.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by billswift on Thursday June 17, 2010 @01:48AM (#1438077)
This is underwater remember - the weight thing is a solved issue, just include flotation along its length and its effective weight is as low as you care to make it.

There are few strong currents in the Gulf - it is a source for the Gulf Stream, but internal currents are fairly weak compared with those dealt with regularly in the oceans.

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by ramchip on Thursday June 17, 2010 @09:03AM (#1438731)
Is this a fact based on actual calculation/experiments, or your personal theory?

I don't think the solution is practical in this case for various other reasons, but the fact that offshore platforms exist incites me to think that long, underwater pipes can in fact resist ocean currents. They will also be naturally buoyant so long as there's enough air pockets in the material (or just floaters as the other person posted).

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by SapphireSun on Friday June 18, 2010 @08:49PM (#1443903)
Personal theory. I should have said that in the original comment.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by brown9-2 on Thursday June 17, 2010 @07:55AM (#1438565)
Even if the inside water pressure is the same as the outside water pressure, isn't there a great amount of pressure exerted on the pipe's structure simply by it's existence at such deep depths?

In other words, even if it's filled with water at 5000 feet of equal pressure, isn't there still a much greater pressure exerted on the pipe's walls at 5000 feet than there is at 100 feet?

Or am I misunderstanding something fundamental about water pressure?

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by ramchip on Thursday June 17, 2010 @09:47AM (#1438865)
You just need more numbers/sources. Intuition is a limited tool, especially in physics.

According to this ( http://www.calctool.org/CALC/other/games/depth_press ) the pressure would be around 15 MPa (this isn't hard to calculate by hand either). Consider that the mud/oil pushes 15 MPa, and water the same: that gives 30 MPa of purely compressive stress. Concrete could take this much ( http://www.cement.org/basics/concretebasics_faqs.asp ), and steel even more easily ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tensile_strength -- if I'm not mistaken, steel behaves roughly the same in compression and in tension).

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by signa11 on Thursday June 17, 2010 @12:54AM (#1437982)
> simplest solution of limiting the leak effects is not possible...

For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong.

-- H.L. Mencken

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by billswift on Thursday June 17, 2010 @01:50AM (#1438081)
Mencken was talking about political and economic problems which are extremely complex. The oil spill is a hard problem, but it is not an especially complex problem.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by jrwoodruff on Thursday June 17, 2010 @08:39AM (#1438660)
At least as far as you know. What qualifies you to make that judgement?
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by Rhapso on Thursday June 17, 2010 @08:15PM (#1440871)
what qualifies you to be a judge of qualifications?
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by jbarciauskas on Wednesday June 16, 2010 @09:41PM (#1437676)
I don't know but I imagine that the complexity of building said tunnel is much higher than the alternative that is currently being pursued - relief wells and the "bottom kill".

Building things in water is many many times more complicated than the same things not in water. Which is why deep sea drilling is so controversial to begin with.

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by jonknee on Thursday June 17, 2010 @10:55AM (#1439083)
That's what they tried with the containment dome (a big box with a pipe up to the surface where oil would be collected in tankers. Turns out that at those depths gas from the well makes methane hydrate crystals and it blocked up the pipe and no oil was collected. Back to the drawing board...

Flash forward a few crazy ideas (namely tossing a bunch of trash into the BOP to try and clog it) and they went back to a similar method called the LMRP. This time they sawed off the riser from the BOP so that the opening was flush and designed a containment cap that fit better around it than before (less of a chance for water to mix in and make the hydrate crystals) and developed a system that continually pumps hot sea water and methanol down the pipe to also help tap down on the hydrates. This method is actually gathering oil, but since they sawed off the riser a lot more oil started leaking so the net result is even more oil is getting into the ocean. BP hasn't "sealed" the LMRP for fear that it will blow out the BOP, which is pretty much what the Mother Jones piece is about.

tl;dr they have and it's not that easy.

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by stcredzero on Thursday June 17, 2010 @11:25AM (#1439201)
Not just the BOP. The actual well lining itself is eroding from the flow. There's a risk that this will deteriorate to the point that there's no way to seal the leak and the entire oil deposit will leak out.

It seems the article was too long for many people's patience/understanding threshold.

Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by jonknee on Thursday June 17, 2010 @11:37AM (#1439254)
The relief well should still stop it as it would intersect far below the surface (down where the bedrock is). The issue being it would be an enormous flow until that gets set.
Re:Is the BP Gusher Unstoppable? by stcredzero on Thursday June 17, 2010 @12:02PM (#1439339)
A potentially bigger issue: what if the erosion damage is too great at or below the point of intersection?