A company with crowdfunding will have to display stronger metrics than a company with strong angels / VCs.
Imagine two companies come to pitch, both are identical in every way. One has crowdfunded a $1M seed, the other got a check from Andreessen Horowitz and the CTO of LinkedIn. Which one do you put your money in? Even the potential deal flow from those individuals helps hedge your bet.
As a side note I think that this relationship of quality and crowdfunding is true (though not always by any means). I have seen fraudulent behaviour by companies misrepresenting their data to a group who are, by a VC's standard, very unsavvy investors. This company was certainly not able to raise money from a VC, but raised two $M+ rounds on a crowd funding site. However, I have also seen good companies who don't have an 'in' to the VC world raise money in this way.
Exactly the point the parent was making. Those are big time contacts. Somebody outside of the valley now has a chance to get $1MM(!!!!) of seed money for their idea without having to relocate and schmooze and network.
I'm as big a proponent of real world social skills as anyone, but this removes a significant barrier to entry for a lot of would be entrepreneurs.
Also, wouldn't a large number of crowdfunders indicate a better product-market fit?
Product-market fit is definitely a good sign a company is on the right track in terms of product. However, 99% of what makes a company successful is execution. A crowd funded campaign on Kickstarter doesn't need to even be possible[1] or it can be completely silly [2]. It doesn't need to show a 100x growth, nor does it need to exist.
On the other hand a VC will do vetting, to make sure the team is right to execute to solve a problem. Let's put it this way:
* A VC invests in a team to solve a problem
* Crowdfunding invests in a product/idea
A VC is a much stronger signal.
[1] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/gnut/kickstarter-open-s... [2] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/elanlee/exploding-kitte...
Well, VC's think so anyway. Given the success rate of VC funds, I'm not sure that's actually true at all.
Sure, like all the folks that were in on Color and Clinkle, right?
I would expand this to state that crowdfunding would fund product/idea but not product/idea fit with market.
Biases like this are market inefficiencies that can provide outsize returns for those who learn to look past it.
Until that happens, the implicit assumptions is that the startup tried shopping itself around to first-tier VCs and angels, failed, tried to go to second-tier VCs and angels, failed, so crowdfunding is their last resort.
Alternatively, a crowdfunded startup scorned by VCs needs to make a really nice exit or achieve a very impressive unicorn valuation.
Figuring out a way to create that VC/Angel connection implies abilities and characteristics that they pattern match to past success. There may be high potential teams that cannot pass this filter but will still succeed, but the industry's deal flow is large enough that they are fine with a small number of false negatives since false positives in their portfolio hurt more, especially when you consider VC math needing 100x-1000x return potential from each of their companies.
It's just like the FaceGooAmaSoft hiring filter we're familiar with that is designed to prioritize low false positives at the cost of having a higher false negative. (skilled programmers who aren't interested in the contrived coding quizzes or can't do them well will be a false negative in the hiring process)
This is backwards. Funding a company that goes nowhere is far smaller an error than turning down the next SpaceX.
Afterall didn't A16Z catch some criticism for not investing a large enough sum into Instagram (which iirc had 500x returns or something) to make a large enough difference to the fund?
A costly adherence to their own ethical rules, but it reinforces how seriously Andreessen Horowitz takes portfolio conflict.
source: https://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/04/20/how-andreessen-hor...
It's helped a lot. In my mind we are much, much better off for having their guidance and assistance.
If you crowdfund, you aren't getting that. You are weaker relative to the companies that did. Doesn't matter if you were stronger initially, the company that got institutional capital (especially first time founders) is going to have training that gives them a huge edge.
Having been on both sides of the fence, there is no question to me that good institutional capital will make a better team. Smart money goes a long way.
If it's a consumer product, probably the former. It means they can market and hustle. If it's an enterprise or B2B product, probably the latter.
Edit: with the caveat that I would only put my money in the former if they have shipped. There's a lot of vaporware in places like Kickstarter and crowdfunding markets. VCs and knowledgeable angels are more likely to be able to see through that (but as we've seen, they're not perfect either).
(I mean, "frankly, we wanted the most money for the least equity and if that was dependent on the public having more inflated expectations than VCs so be it" is a perfectly valid answer from the point of view of running a startup, but it's still an adverse signal if the investors most informed about your company at the last investment round were those willing to offer the lowest price for your shares)
This isn't limited to crowdfunding, by the way. A cap table of a hundred $10,000 cheques (I've seen these), even if all are from accredited investors, will have a harder time raising venture capital than one with a handful of early backers.
Hundreds?!?
(I originally wrote "doesn't sound crazy," but in fact it sounds totally crazy. Just not impossible.)
If I'm going to seriously join a crowdfunding investment, I'm going to be thinking like a VC. I would happily join a smaller "lifestyle" company as an employee or cofounder, but I probably wouldn't give them much money. I expect 9 out of 10 of my investments to fail, so I also need to look for those 10x opportunities.
On the other hand, if it's just a token amount like a few hundred dollars, then I'll throw some cash at a Kickstarter or whatever. But then you can't say I really invested in anything.
Let's imagine that fund spans a moderate size metro (2mil people) and 0.1% of people are willing to join once it gets "big".
2000 people by $500 is $1mil a year. If you figure seed money is $20-100k for a small business, you're creating 10-50 small businesses a year in your local area. (Possibly more once you're good at it and can leverage SBA and venture resources to help match your capital.)
That's not a ton, and would definitely work better if you could nudge participation up to 1% or raise the average funding amount (or get another funding stream, or tax breaks, etc), but I think generating that local entrepreneurial churn can only be a good thing.
I'd pay $50/mo to see several new businesses a year get started around town, just for the added cultural value small businesses bring.
I think you would have problems doing this with investors doing the decision making; I would imagine you'd need to spend at least 10 hours per company invested to make a remotely informed decision; people aren't going to want to spend hours making a decision about a $50 investment. If you get the time commitment much lower, it will probably be a huge magnet for fraud.
With a manager-based decision making process, I don't think the JOBS act affects the legality much. You'd probably need to house the decision-making in a registered investment company, which will probably cost you at least $50k/year in compliance costs. Getting even 1 remotely qualified manager would probably cost you $200k/year. I don't know that people are going to be as excited about the idea when they hear the expense ratio is 25%/year.
To make it work, it seems to me you would need a national-level parent organization to amortize compliance and legal costs, and (qualified) volunteer decision makers.
I was guesstimating about $200k/yr in operating expenses (and that's with a lot of volunteered expertise, as you note).
But structured as a social-purpose non-profit, with everyone paying in being a member who elects a management board, who allocates the money as they see fit (perhaps with some constraints chosen by members), I think this actually bypasses a large amount of compliance work -- if you never return the money, and are strictly a non-profit investing in local businesses which rolls returns in to future investments -- because the members aren't actually making investments: they're paying for a non-profit's operational funds to support local business ventures. Structuring this way also makes for a better case to get donated expertise, eg from local lawyers and investors, and probably makes your tax situation a lot better.
You probably need some rules about earning lifetime membership after a certain pay-in, and definitely some about conflicts of interest (eg, funding member's ventures) but those are more technical details.
It's not a good financial investment vehicle, in that even in the best case you'd almost certainly have negative returns and in the worst, you'd have no returns at all -- but if your goal is changing the function of the market to support local enterprises and you're willing to pay in to make that happen, I think it'd function excellently. (Of course, you only really need to seed one or two Starbucks to have the whole portfolio right-side up again, even after decades of total losses. So at a generational level, it might work as a financial instrument as well.)
Worth noting, even as a non-profit, there are ways to "return" the money besides the value of the businesses started if you do find yourself with extra funds -- investments in local parks, schools, art programs, etc. It'd never come back in currency returns, but I expect "investors" would see tangible value in their lives, quite possibly exceeding the monetary value they put in.
tl;dr: It's easier if you structure as a one-way investment in your community, and collect dividends from the output of a vibrant community.
The reason is I think you really need to focus on localization of such funds to make them effective -- metro scale ones. You can probably make the financials work by simply eating the overhead on that scale, but not on one trying to turn a profit, but paying for labor. Losing 17% of your investment every year to overhead is simply too rough, because you'd need to generate 20% returns.
You could do it, but it would substantially change the nature of the investments you could make and the size the fund would have to be to operate. There's a certain charm to funds in the 1-10 million dollar range making small investments in 10-100 businesses. (And I believe helps combat some of the problems involved with corporations, by intentionally distorting the market by "losing" money purposefully and recouping the value from the social change.)
I was (obviously) unaware of CDVCA, but even there, it seems like they're mostly a broader investment scale and set up as a traditional venture fund (ie, looking to connect traditional investors with high growth potential ventures) as opposed to operating a continual flux of small, local businesses at (likely) negative returns funded by the local populace at large. (I poked around the NYC one, for instance.)
That said, they likely have worked out some of the legal hurdles involved.
You are probably better off taking your money to Las Vegas and playing blackjack. At least there you only lose 6 out of 10 investments.
This scares agents because a wide-spread DIY real estate industry kills all of the middlemen (themselves)
'Never ask a barber if he thinks you need a haircut'
Though the interesting thing is, Y Combinator is interested in basic income. That's effectively like crowd-seeding, which makes all the 'cut out the middleman' stuff more practical.
If you're expecting 'disruption' and embracing it, and you see disruption coming for your own livelihood, the sophisticated response is to try and find a place for yourself in the new situation, rather than stop things from changing at all. In that light, Y Combinator looking at ways to cut out SV incubators could be prescient.
It's like with me: I run a very functional small recording studio as part of my business, and it's well on the way to handling the live recording of traditional bands and their instrumentation. Yet I'm a lot more interested in finding unusual ways to support electronic genres (a strikingly different skillset).
But you're signing up for a lot of work, not a sprint, and that's kinda the antithesis to 'changing the world' without making a profit then going to IPO.
I don't want to gamble on something, I want to build something with a less sophisticated valuation model where the revenue plan is clear from the start.
If the company needs to be recapitalized or restructured under a time crunch, tracking down 100 loosely involved investors and getting them to sign the deal may not be feasible.
Pedantically, "members" not "partners"; an LLC is not a partnership.
I think that is really the most important part. A lot of people sophisticated enough to have their interest peaked by the opportunity probably figure the deals being offered are (more or less) the deals already rejected by traditional and more sophisticated channels. If established but private companies (e.g. Lyft) were doing late stage rounds through this type of a marketplace I think demand would be much greater. The problem is those companies probably don't have a lot to gain by doing it that way.
Now my assumption on quality may be wrong but that sentiment seems like an important hump for these marketplaces to get over.
I think the existing VC investment structures hate the idea of crowdfunded VC as it threatens their model, which is personal connections and an old boys (and girls) network which allows more favorable terms for investors, especially for first-time founders.
I hope that crowdfunding becomes more normal. Not every idea has to have billion dollar potential, which is what most VC's are looking for.