Product-market fit is definitely a good sign a company is on the right track in terms of product. However, 99% of what makes a company successful is execution. A crowd funded campaign on Kickstarter doesn't need to even be possible[1] or it can be completely silly [2]. It doesn't need to show a 100x growth, nor does it need to exist.
On the other hand a VC will do vetting, to make sure the team is right to execute to solve a problem. Let's put it this way:
* A VC invests in a team to solve a problem
* Crowdfunding invests in a product/idea
A VC is a much stronger signal.
[1] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/gnut/kickstarter-open-s... [2] https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/elanlee/exploding-kitte...
Well, VC's think so anyway. Given the success rate of VC funds, I'm not sure that's actually true at all.
Sure, like all the folks that were in on Color and Clinkle, right?
I would expand this to state that crowdfunding would fund product/idea but not product/idea fit with market.
Exactly the point the parent was making. Those are big time contacts. Somebody outside of the valley now has a chance to get $1MM(!!!!) of seed money for their idea without having to relocate and schmooze and network.
I'm as big a proponent of real world social skills as anyone, but this removes a significant barrier to entry for a lot of would be entrepreneurs.
Also, wouldn't a large number of crowdfunders indicate a better product-market fit?