News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by maxxxxx on Thursday May 18, 2017 @10:43AM (#14367600)
Work somewhere where software is the main product and not just a cost center. You can learn a lot quickly if you do cutting edge things with people who care about technology and not just cost.

Solve real world​ problems. Doing elegant things is very difficult because the real world is much more convoluted than theory.

Do a few things in depth. Don't jump at the latest thing every few months.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by randcraw on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:10AM (#14367872)
> Work somewhere where software is the main product and not just a cost center.

This is THE big difference between S/W dev and IT. For 20 years I worked in the former, and for the past 10 in the latter. No question about it: IT is hell. Theirs is a never-ending mission to reduce the cost of moving data and being "compliant" with often-meaningless ever-excessive corporate standards (and forever meaningless MBA/CIO fads and groupthink).

Worst, in most businesses, IT doesn't have a respected mission. Ii provides an infrastructural service (a cost center) that other C-suiters dis as no more important than HVAC and sewer. IT appears on their radar in only two ways: 1) when something breaks and info clogs up or stops moving, and 2) when the budget is revisited and interest in IT cuts are reinvigorated.

Since nobody else in the corp. respects IT's mission, senior mgt. compels the CIO to adopt meaningless surrogate goals because IT's actual mission isn't sexy enough. So for the next six months IT adopts "Platforms" or trains half the staff in Six Sigma, or outsources, or insources, or promotes of whatever other CIO groupthink initiative is in vogue at the moment.

So yes, work somewhere software is valued, unlike IT.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by QuantumGravy on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:35AM (#14368111)
Having regrettably started from the IT side, it's seemingly impossible to make the jump to a software company proper. Nothing I do day-to-day is flexing any mental muscles an interviewer would find sexy. We're like a permanent underclass of undesirables. Without spending time outside work to focus on sharpening basic undergraduate CS knowledge, I know I'm getting objectively rusty at the types of problems I actually do have some remaining passion for.

I fear I'll be hammering out poorly-spec'd features to the beat of another department's Gantt-chart for the rest of my life.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by b0rsuk on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:20PM (#14368509)
If you want to train yourself in programming, algorithms and understanding of time complexity, I recommend giving codility.com a go. You are asked to implement solutions for various problems in a programming language of your choice. Basic literature is provided, for example problems which are elegantly solved with stacks come with a pdf about stacks, their implementation in Python and so on. If you go trough the lessons in the order, you will learn many useful programming techniques, and big O notation will no longer sound scary.

The website provides a decent in-browser editor, or you can write in your own and paste the solution. You get a few data points for expected output, can write up to 10 of your own primitive tests (although I tend to use asserts). Your solution is automatically evaluated afterwards, because it has a bunch of unit and performance tests written for it. When your program fails on small correctness tests, the website says what was the wrong output and what the correct output should be like. VERY nice.

The language used to describe problems is a bit obfuscated and maths-like, but I treat that as extra challenge. You certainly don't have to remember much from your university or high school to get started. It is important to understand and rephrase what they are asking of you.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by bpyne on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:39PM (#14369303)
I sympathize. Early in my career I landed a job in a small software company. My skills improved greatly. Then I made the mistake of taking an IT job. That IT job rolled into another and another. While I stay near the technical top in my IT departments, I find it tough interviewing for software company jobs. The concerns of a software engineer in a software company are just so different from an IT developer’s.

I interview for backend engineer jobs. I notice a common theme in the interviews: efficiency. They are very concerned with transactional throughput. They optimize everything from the services layer to the database for trimming every microsecond. At a past interview, the people wanted me to talk about the efficiency and implementation of various data structures: nothing exotic, just garden variety queues, stacks, lists, and hashmaps. They quizzed me on threading issues. One guy got into various indexes in a relational database and then jumped into TCP vs. UDP questions. In my most recent interview, the guy started by asking me the difference between optimistic and pessimistic locking. In my IT job, I never deal with locking issues: they are all abstracted away. Two-thirds of the way through the interview, I remembered and circled back to the question. However, the damage was more than likely done. A person who deals with those issues daily would never forget. But, I know what to work on for the next interview.

I understand your predicament. It’s deadening on every level when you’re doing work beneath your capability and interest, but you don’t have the necessary knowledge to get through an interview for more interesting jobs. Hopefully, the observation I made above helps you to target particular areas to successfully navigate an interview.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by cookiecaper on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:44PM (#14369880)
Find a place that will quiz you on real-world work instead of CS textbooks. There are a lot of them.

Companies who base their interviews on CS curricula generally just end up only hiring people who've graduated recently enough to remember it (i.e., their staff ends up being junior because they're selecting for something that's, ironically, an anti-indicator of experience more often than not).

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by Retric on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:00PM (#14368359)
I agree that trying to get stuff done after work is often a non starter. But, I find you can do a lot with one weekend a month of real focused effort without burning out or feeling much pressure.

Alternatively, just put yourself out there. You don't need to be great, just find a job a little closer to your goal.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by QuantumGravy on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:30PM (#14368619)
Honestly, the amount of empathy here is encouraging. I'm not in the best position to take all the advice given just yet, but knowing I'm not completely surrounded by sharks is reassuring.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by Cerium on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:52AM (#14368274)
I have a background in Electrical Engineering, and six months ago I made the jump into my first pure software role. I worked up to it, doing lots of projects on my own time. Just a data point, that if you want to get somewhere you have to start wherever you are.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by codemac on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:53AM (#14368286)
Would you think that it's not sexyness, but applicability? What values do you bring to the table that a SW company would need?

Because I bet you that you could find some if you switched from targeting straight dev roles to something else that is part of a SW org.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by QuantumGravy on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:04PM (#14368388)
Other than time spent programming on platform X, I'm at a loss as to what values I'd bring. Would I hire myself, based on my job history? Probably not. I'm hardly going to impress anyone with such an attitude!

Any suggestions on alternate roles to look for? I'd worry that just because it's a software organization, it doesn't mean I wouldn't be filling their own version of cog in a cost-center.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by jrumbut on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:42PM (#14368725)
I guess this varies by location, but on average there are so many more openings than there are developers that it shouldn't be at all impossible to find a company willing to take a chance on you, especially if you are willing to either work very hard or take a slightly under market value paycheck (for the very first job).

So time spent using X is great, but just saying "I can learn" and giving an example of how you're able to learn is often enough. Then just look at X enough that you know the gist of it, have a small little sample project in your github account, and you'll be good enough that someone will hire you.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by cookiecaper on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:49PM (#14369928)
Yeah, pay grade is really where it gets sticky. If you have basic skills you can find an entry level gig easily... as long as you're willing to take a market-level salary for that role. A lot of people who've spent years building a career in a dead-end sector will have salaries substantially higher than that, and that makes it difficult to jump.

These people should focus on improving their credit, cutting expenses, and building up savings so that they can take the salary hit that will get their careers on a better track for the ~20 years until they're eligible for retirement.

Alternatively, these people can go in through a social backdoor. Befriend a powerful person at a company you'd like to work at and demonstrate why he needs you. If he has authority to set salaries, he will likely do everything possible to accommodate your higher-than-market salary, even if he can't get you 100% of the way there.

But beware: overpaying an employee is the best way for a company to trap him/her. Do everything possible to not become dependent on a rate you can't easily command somewhere else.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by taway_1212 on Friday May 19, 2017 @04:44AM (#14373852)
There is tons of middle ground between IT and "proper" software company - for example, banks, while not being tech companies, are nowadays operated via lots of sophisticated software, not unlike say Amazon (and BTW you could argue if Amazon is a retail company and not "proper" software company).
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by wayn3 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:05PM (#14368399)
maybe sign up for triplebyte and let them figure it out? nothing to lose
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by iamacynic on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:26PM (#14368578)
quit your job and use the downtime to retool the way you think. you won't have much success otherwise.

no pain, no gain.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by mavelikara on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:11PM (#14368434)
Marc Andreessen argues [1] that this will soon have to change.

I work at an SV software vendor which sells to big enterprise IT groups. From what I have seen, firms are starting to take their IT groups more seriously.

[1] http://a16z.com/2016/08/20/why-software-is-eating-the-world/

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by ajeet_dhaliwal on Friday May 19, 2017 @07:35AM (#14374601)
Right, so many companies, such as in finance/banks are really going to have to get on with changing that mentality to compete with new or existing competitors who are more tech savy.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by maxxxxx on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:19AM (#14367950)
"senior mgt. compels the CIO to adopt meaningless surrogate goals because IT's actual mission isn't sexy enough. So for the next six months IT adopts "Platforms" or trains half the staff in Six Sigma, or outsources, or insources, or promotes of whatever other CIO groupthink initiative is in vogue at the moment."

That describes exactly the IT department in my company.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by kzisme on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:30AM (#14368058)
I've noticed this even walking around at work in different areas other than where I sit.

"Hey aren't you in IT can you help me with my computer issue"

One of the things I dislike the most is being referred to as "The IT Department".

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by unixhero on Thursday May 18, 2017 @05:32PM (#14371284)
I am now in Telco

The only place where I've seen IT being highly respected.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by hasbot on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:57AM (#14368323)
> Work somewhere where software is the main product and not just a cost center.

I've done both and I can't say one is better than the other. I've worked on software products where marketing couldn't figure out how to sell it and kept changing the core functionality. Or where the CEO kept shoving his ludicrous ideas onto development. I've worked on rewarding IT projects where I worked very closely with the users and was very happy to see my work help them perform their day-to-day jobs. I've also worked on slog IT projects where the users had no idea what they wanted and we kept churning.

After 28 years, I ended up preferring working close to the actual users.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by fixed_carbon on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:52PM (#14368821)
"Marketing...kept changing the core functionality" "CEO kept shoving his ludicrous ideas onto development"

Check and check. There's also my personal favorite: marketing informs the dev team they've just inked a big contract with a tight deadline for features that were never discussed with the dev team. "We kinda told them we already had those features but hadn't released them yet. Can you guys build that real quick like?"

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by pvdebbe on Friday May 19, 2017 @06:45AM (#14374355)
Classic. Our supports operative just happened to promise full IE support (we promise only Firefox) just like that.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by lliamander on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:40PM (#14369852)
Interesting! I switch very early in my career to working for product companies because I saw no other way to have a rewarding career as developer. So far it's worked out pretty well for me.

However, recently I read Developer Hegemony[0], which seems to describe a path for IT developers to also have rewarding careers.

My current thinking is that the Agile philosophy definitely contributes both to successful projects and to satisfying careers for IT developers (Agile came primarily from that world of software development) but only when developers and users are equal partners. That generally only happens when the developers are independent consultants who can speak the language of business.

[0]https://leanpub.com/developerhegemony

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by collyw on Friday May 19, 2017 @06:51AM (#14374382)
The problem being that no one can actually define what agile actually is. (Or rather everyone can, but there is no consistent definition).
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by lliamander on Friday May 19, 2017 @05:11PM (#14379394)
Yep, it's a problem, and adding my own "what I think agile actually is" would only add to the noise.

However, I do think that the original signers of the manifesto were onto something. My recommendation for people is, rather than learning an official methodology, that they go and read the writings of the various different signers. Get an understanding of what it meant for them at the time that they signed the manifesto.

Martin Fowler has commented that one of the other names they thought about calling their movement was "conversational software", in the sense that software development process was an ongoing conversation between the developers and the users of the system.

The point I gleaned from the book I mentioned was that (in the general case) the power politics of most IT organizations prevents the development process from every being a real conversation.

As I understand it, many of the signers were independent consultants at the time of signing (or helped lead IT consultancies) and could speak the language of business. It seems to me that perhaps this put them in a more "peer" relationship with the business stakeholders, and allowed the development approach to be more conversational.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by walljm on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:31PM (#14369226)
> After 28 years, I ended up preferring working close to the actual users.

This is key.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by sgt101 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:54PM (#14369977)
this! but also note users and access to them is what "IT" have and "software" often struggles with. Run some field trials, do interviews and field visits to support requirements analysis...
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by colefichter on Thursday May 18, 2017 @10:48AM (#14367658)
> Work somewhere where software is the main product and not just a cost center. > Doing elegant things is very difficult...

These are great! I would also add: be certain that the organization shares your values. If you really care about code quality, elegant solutions, etc, you'll have a frustrating time working at a company that doesn't prioritize those things.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by laythea on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:39PM (#14369846)
I agree with all of this and I think there is a third category of job where is software is neither the main business, nor IT.

Once you have developed the necessary software skills in a "software house", in my experience, the best thing to so is to get stuck into a particular domain, where the company needs software developed (not IT), but is not the main business. These jobs and contracts attract the best $, but also in my experience, highest job satisfaction - you are not just a cog - well, less so, IMO.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by maxxxxx on Thursday May 18, 2017 @03:02PM (#14370070)
If you want to distill it to one factor it's to make sure you and your function are a respected part of the company and not just something that's easily replaced. If you are in that position usually the $$$ is good and the work is interesting.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by root_axis on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:19PM (#14368507)
> Work somewhere where software is the main product and not just a cost center. You can learn a lot quickly if you do cutting edge things with people who care about technology and not just cost.

Very true, but the company culture also needs to be right in order for this to really take hold. There's also the fact that the work and schedule will likely be more demanding. This can be a positive if you enjoy the work, but a big problem if you dislike unpredictable hours. When the company's primary revenue source is software, you will have to work extended hours at some point or another to solve critical business issues.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by JoshTriplett on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:00PM (#14368362)
Depends on what you want: if you work at a company where software is the product (or the service), it can be harder to make the case for releasing software as Open Source. If you work at a company where, say, hardware pays the bills, that can make it far easier to make the case for releasing software as Open Source.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by kzisme on Thursday May 18, 2017 @10:59AM (#14367774)
> Work somewhere where software is the main product

So a software company as opposed to working in an IT department - programming and solving problems that really _aren't_ interesting?

That's one of the main things I crave these days (and I think it would make a big day-to-day difference) is to work at a software company as opposed to a company who leverages software.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by unit91 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:11AM (#14367884)
Agreed, though I'd modify "software company as opposed to working in an IT department" to "work on something profitable". :-)

I don't work at a software company, or even a traditional "tech" company, but I write the software that powers our most profitable product. Since I'm the odd-man-out, and the higher-ups love org charts, they stuck me in the IT department. Net effect: IT just became a profit center and everybody in the company knows it.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by kzisme on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:15AM (#14367917)
> something profitable

Would that be the primary product of your company, or something that empowers other employees to work faster, and push _their_ products more easily?

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by unit91 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:37PM (#14368689)
Personal preference. In my situation, it's a retail product at a company that has a lot of other retail products. The one I work on just happens to be very profitable, so it gets a lot of attention. But I'd be very happy working on the empowering problem you mentioned too.

I've been blessed by having experience in several, very different kinds of applications (web apps to avionics). Over time, I've realized the specifics of the problem at hand are more-or-less irrelevant to my happiness. I'm looking for something that's sufficiently technically challenging, where I can be surrounded by honest, friendly people, and make decent money.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by kzisme on Thursday May 18, 2017 @01:47PM (#14369382)
> I'm looking for something that's sufficiently technically challenging, where I can be surrounded by honest, friendly people, and make decent money.

This is very close to my real goal as well - but CRUD apps seem like the norm lately :(

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by jimmywanger on Thursday May 18, 2017 @12:57PM (#14368872)
Without internal billing, only the first thing (profits from products) is measurable, and the second thing is mostly invisible.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by maxxxxx on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:02AM (#14367791)
It's even a money/salary issue. There is a huge difference between the CEO seeing you as someone who makes money for the company as opposed to just being an expense.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by bluedino on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:49AM (#14368250)
Automate things and make people's jobs easier. Then you're valuable.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by arethuza on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:58AM (#14368335)
That's reducing costs rather than increasing revenue. Of course, within a limited range they are equivalent but you really only have respect in a lot of organizations if you contribute towards the latter.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by sgt101 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @02:55PM (#14369989)
Odd - because margin being what it often is a dollar saved is worth three/four... ten... ?
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by kzisme on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:19AM (#14367949)
>It's even a money/salary issue.

Does this mean that you salary isn't increasing, or that you aren't valued at all?

I'm curious how most people receive or handle (or if raises are even a thing)

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by devopsproject on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:20AM (#14367954)
You want to be in a profit center, not a cost center.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by dhruvkar on Thursday May 18, 2017 @04:27PM (#14370813)
I worked in the IT department of an early software company (est. 1980) based in the Bay area.

It was slightly better, since people understood software's value, and Ops was shared between the devs and IT. However, maintaining that sort of culture always felt like a constant battle. Management often slipped into IT = cost center.

In fact, my job officially became bridging this gap as an IT Business Partner. I don't think I did a very good job.

Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by gyrgtyn on Thursday May 18, 2017 @03:22PM (#14370252)
I didn't think I had an answer for this thread, but this is it. After many years, I finally found my way into a software company. It's weird here... I don't feel like everyone is mad at me all the time.
Re:Ask HN: For those programming 10+ years, what do you wish... by canterburry on Thursday May 18, 2017 @10:55AM (#14367730)
Couldn't agree more.