News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by shaqbert on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @04:49AM (#14356667)
Pricing mistake 101: You never ever change those old plans. Instead, you grandfather them. Especially so if you're still a young platform and have most growth ahead of you, the "loss" of not charging the new - and supposedly higher - pricing is gonna be trivial 2 years from now, with lots of new projects coming in. But the NPS hit from pissing your most loyal users off and the subsequent damage to your growth curve are huge.

Also, I do love Bezos mantra of always becoming cheaper over time. That is the core of Amazon's brand. Whereas Oracle, IBM, and the old guard always make you pot committed and charge an arm and a leg, the Amazon guys will leave money on the table. That is how you earn trust.

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by delhanty on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @08:36AM (#14357780)
Tell that to FastMail, who have pissed me off by deciding to end-of-life the "lifetime" 16Mb member account I set up for my father with a one-time $15 payment.

16Mb is modulo zero these days, but it's enough for him - he just deletes some emails when it gets full. He also gets imap access and FastMail's spam filtering, which is really very good. I can also assign him an email address from a domain that I own that is associated with my FastMail enhanced account.

I don't want my $15 back. What I DO want is for FastMail to honour our existing agreement, which was a LIFE-TIME 16 Mb member account in exchange for $15.

See also here:

http://www.emaildiscussions.com/showthread.php?p=599512

Text of their latest email is below the line:

=============================================

Back in January we contacted you with some important information about your @.* FastMail account.

We're now contacting you again to remind you that from 31st July, 2017 our 'Member' level plans will be discontinued.

To continue using your FastMail account after this time you'll need to select one of our current plans. Please note: your email address will remain the same.

As a long-time FastMail user we're offering you 50% OFF all upgrades until the end of July, which includes our already discounted multi-year subscriptions.

And if you upgrade now we'll also add all the remaining time until 31 July for free!

As an added bonus we've also given you $15 credit to put towards your subscription, which is equal to the amount you originally paid for your account.

This means if you were to upgrade to a Basic account today for one year, with the discount and account credit you are effectively getting FastMail at no charge until 31 July 2018 with a massive 2 GB of storage (up from 16 MB)!

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by muraiki on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @10:10AM (#14358544)
Thanks for sharing this. I had recently set up an account with FastMail, but now that it's clear that they won't abide by their own promises, I'll look elsewhere.
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by FireBeyond on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @03:40PM (#14362114)
Yeah, don't be so fast. I've had a legacy Enhanced account which they show no signs of removing - I went to renew it today and could (though I went to the Standard).

I've had nothing but excellent, and personal, service from them, for years. Very high availability, no canned responses.

Even when bitching about Google's support of "this address used to be with Gmail but is now external, but we'll make it problematic for other users to send it calendar invites", though in no way did I imply Fastmail was at fault, they jumped into the HN thread to say "Hey, let us know if we can be of assistance figuring out the issue".

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by macintux on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @01:13PM (#14360492)
I would be cautious about extrapolating from that. Yes, it sounds like an unfortunate decision, but I've been a FastMail user for many years and have been very happy with them.
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by sleepydog on Monday May 22, 2017 @07:22PM (#14397652)
I'm a long-time and happy Fastmail user. I'm not defending their decision, but I personally never trust "lifetime" plans of any kind -- it's impossible for a business to know they can sustain you forever, and dishonest for them to say they can.
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by eridius on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @01:34PM (#14360728)
I think you're being a bit hasty. This is literally the first negative thing I've seen anyone post about FastMail, and my experience as a customer of theirs has been fantastic.
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by ams6110 on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @11:15AM (#14359239)
I am a long-time Fastmail user who also was on the "lifetime" 16MB plan. Last year I switched because I wanted some features that were only available with a newer plan. I was a little annoyed to have to give up my lifetime plan but in my case it was more understandable.

I've been very happy with Fastmail for over a decade and this seems like one of the few missteps they've made. New "lifetime" 16MB accounts have not been available in years. It really doesn't seem that there could be very many of them still in active use that it would hurt anything to just continue to grandfather them, especially since they were sold explicitly as "lifetime" one-payment accounts.

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by jbob2000 on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @08:44AM (#14357844)
There could be technical issues with keeping grandfathered plans around. Maybe the 16mb email accounts were on an old system that was getting increasingly difficult to maintain?
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by delhanty on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @08:53AM (#14357905)
I'm sure that's true.

But then it's not my problem.

FastMail made an agreement - $15 in exchange for a lifetime member account.

Now they don't want to honour that agreement.

And they've created work for me: What to do about my father's email account?

I have his email address as part of the domain that I have associated with my (legacy) FastMail enhanced account. They've discontinued family accounts for new signups.

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by staticelf on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @10:15AM (#14358608)
Then they should upgrade the account to a new plan without cost imo.
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by Can_Not on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @09:34AM (#14358225)
Yeah but you could move their account over physically but continue to not bill them. I doubt 16MB is anything more than a properly enforced column value in a CRM.
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by pranavsinghca on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @12:01PM (#14359775)
I don't think this should have ever been offered.

Curious - how could FastMail ever properly close/sunset these accounts? Were they going to regularly check on all of their customers to see if they had passed away? Was there some 'we close the email if you don't log in for 5 years straight'?

Serious question - how should these type of lifetime promises ever be properly managed? (especially when the customer is an individual)

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by delhanty on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @12:39PM (#14360148)
From a business point of view, they are generally regarded to be a bad idea. See various comments on what is now the main FastMail thread:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14357859

My point is simply this:

FastMail unwisely offered lifetime email service for one-time $15 payment. I accepted that offer on behalf of my father.

FastMail should now honour that agreement.

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by delhanty on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @08:49AM (#14357878)
I decided to submit the link that I gave:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14357859

I'm not sure whether my chosen title follows HN guidelines - admins please feel free to edit

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by user5994461 on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @12:22PM (#14359978)
Pricing mistake 202: Relying on services that don't charge enough to be sustainable.

They will go bankrupt sooner or later, it's only a matter of when.

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by manigandham on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @05:37AM (#14356882)
> the Amazon guys will leave money on the table

What? they're a business like any other and they're not interested in minimizing profit, there's lot of thought that goes into their pricing and you can be sure that your opinion and trust is an outcome of their strategy to make more money.

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by jhall1468 on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @10:33AM (#14358776)
> they're a business like any other and they're not interested in minimizing profit

Actually they are. Minimizing profit is sacrificing short-term gains for long-term gains. Increasing prices helps your short term profit, but you tend to lose customers to competitors. Decreasing prices means less profit right now, but you tend to convert more customers.

Companies aren't purely RIGHT NOW profit-driven. That's why many companies burn cash and take on debt. They're driven by growth (whether vertical or horizontal). Bezos is obsessed with growth. That's why they've only recently started making money. Enormous investments in AWS, FBA and a host of other products put them in the red, but in doing so, Amazon has incredibly horizontal growth.

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by manigandham on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @03:02PM (#14361704)
The timeframe does not change between my first phrase and the last. Overall (as in lifetime) the company is maximizing profits (as companies are designed to do). They certainly aren't "leaving money on the table" unless it's a plan to extract even more, so I don't see why that's so great as the GP comment says. They're good competition for the industry but I don't understand how their pricing automatically engenders trust. Also value is not equal to price and many major companies understand that absolute price is rarely the significant factor.

> Minimizing profit is sacrificing short-term gains for long-term gains.

That would actually be maximizing profit...

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by jhall1468 on Thursday May 18, 2017 @11:03AM (#14367799)
> The timeframe does not change between my first phrase and the last.

The timeframe dictates behavior. But, you responded to a comment that said Amazon will leave money on the table, arguing that they won't. They will, and do, leave money on the short-term in order to benefit their long-term strategy.

Short-term vs Long-term profit motivations are actually MASSIVELY different sets of behaviors.

> That would actually be maximizing profit...

Yes, if you assume a company is infinite that's true. But since there's currently not a company that's existed forever, I can safely assume that such a thing doesn't exist.

You can't argue profit without arguing time. Particularly when your argument was that all companies focus on profit at the exclusion of all other things. Growth companies focus on growth over profit. And while, yes, over time that can result in more profit, it also may not. If pure profit were the only motivation, short-term MASSIVE profits would be the only goal ever, since it's vastly more real than potential profits if everything works out.

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by philfrasty on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @05:47AM (#14356924)
„...you can be sure that your opinion and trust is an outcome of their strategy to make more money...“

Is exactly what the parent comment said...

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by thr0waway1239 on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @06:11AM (#14357038)
..making up in scale what you lose in margin.

I think Amazon pulls this off because their prima donna is the paying customer, not the programmer who thinks talking directly to customers is the worst possible reflection of their ability to automate. Automation is great and all, but Google has a major problem when it comes to empathizing with the customers.

Also, is there any possibility of legal action against Google for this bait and switch, which seems to be quite clearly the case here?

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by fovc on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @07:36AM (#14357446)
I would seriously look into small claims court. It's allegedly somewhat effective with airlines (e.g. https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/travel/small-claims...)
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by manigandham on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @07:24AM (#14357383)
What trust does that earn exactly? It's a strategy, not some noble cause.
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by 83457 on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @07:30AM (#14357416)
Trust that you won't be ~extorted~ bait and switched in the future?
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by manigandham on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @02:03PM (#14361026)
How so? Because they haven't done it yet? Where does this extra trust come from?
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by vthallam on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @08:37AM (#14357786)
> What? they're a business like any other and they're not interested in minimizing profit

Of course, they are a business. But they look at minimising the price, increase the scale, have a monopoly and earn money.

Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by draw_down on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @11:38AM (#14359493)
Boy, how do you look like a company like Amazon and conclude they're not interested in minimizing profit. That is exactly what they do.
Re:A startup’s Firebase bill suddenly increased from $25 to ... by manigandham on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @03:06PM (#14361752)
Bezos is worth 80B. Amazon is a global empire operating in practically owns the ecommerce industry and extracts an enormous amount of profit. What exactly are they minimizing?

Charging less to make more is actually maximizing profit for the company.