News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by 11thEarlOfMar on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @03:59PM (#14352764)
Several issues with statements in this article. Example:

"In all Western societies, the new formula for prosperity is inconsistent with the old formula for democracy."

This statement is not explained, just made as a de facto truth. It's a pretty sweeping statement that I find difficult to accept based on what I understand it to mean. So I am thinking I don't understand it, but there is no explanation.

"Once a complex manufacturing process could be supervised from afar"

true one can 'order up' a production run of a million units, however, many small and mid-sized companies have failed simply because they could not make this work. Pleo being the first example that comes to mind: The CEO flew between the US and their Asian mfr 20 times in a year, couldn't get the product built and wound up selling the company to the manufacturer. Apple successfully operates with distributed manufacturing, but still requires many (thousands?) of engineers to shuttle between the US and Asia-based factories in order to ensure that base materials, components, quality, design, lead time, and many other aspects of manufacturing are done per their requirements. It turns out that the dance between design engineers and the manufacturing team is much more involved than companies realized and the challenges of communicating all of that across an ocean has been the death of many products.

"A lot of what Americans think of as valuable service-sector know-how is actually mere prestige."

It's not know-how. It's 'know customer'. Americans are great consumers but to sell to them you have to know what they want and how they want it delivered. The non-US companies that succeed are the ones that tap into US-based design for things like, um, cars. Many foreign products are designed in LA.

Moreover, innovation is the true source of value. Nations that are more innovative will ultimately prevail. That is where one should focus in order to understand where the threats and opportunities are.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by roymurdock on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @04:35PM (#14353074)
"In all Western societies, the new formula for prosperity is inconsistent with the old formula for democracy."

The author expands on this further in the piece:

Do businessmen have an obligation to ensure that their neighbors get first crack at the job opportunities their enterprises generate? Should businessmen deny such obligations, are lawmakers justified in imposing them? High and relatively egalitarian compensation served a number of social purposes. Society owed a debt to modest workers who steadied the constitutional compact in peace and shed blood for it in war. The “family wage” that many corporations paid reflected that debt. It also partially compensated the at-home work of wives and mothers that made it possible to reproduce the society. Corporate executives giddily discovered, once they got to Mexico or Southeast Asia, that they no longer had to think about such things. They were now dealing with a workforce to whom they didn’t owe jack.

Viewed this way, the “prosperity” of globalization is just a transfer. It rests on a broken implicit contract. Globalization seems to have delivered up to private parties hard-won competitive advantages that were really the common property of American society. Some are quantifiable things like taxpayer-funded research and development, of the sort that the Carrier air conditioner company benefited from before it announced it was moving jobs from Indianapolis to Mexico. Others are advantages that can be grasped only conceptually, like economies of scale. The process of Western Bloc globalization that began in the 1990s differs in degree but not in kind from the contemporaneous Eastern Bloc looting of state assets. Globalization comes to seem a con game.

AKA the old formula for democracy, sharing the wealth and economic gains among the inhabitants of a geographically contiguous region that pooled funds to build the infrastructure (military, social, and utilities) necessary for the generation of that wealth, no longer applies.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by specialist on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @09:47PM (#14354958)
It's more simple than that. Growing inequity damages democracy.

Some of the major causes of inequity: Excess labor pushing down wages. Increased productivity leading to increased profits. Taxing income more than assets. Runaway housing, healthcare, education costs. Blah blah blah.

Any serious discussion of releveling the Capital vs Labor playing (battle) field has to tackle this list.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by jaggederest on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @12:15AM (#14355600)
I think I did some back of the envelope math at one point, that a 50 basis point tax on all physical assets in the US could replace all taxation at the federal, state, and local level.
Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by rrggrr on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @04:29PM (#14353031)
> innovation is the true source of value. Nations that are more innovative will ultimately prevail.

Really? Because the upside (spread) for innovation and productivity gains is much higher for developing nations (eg. China) than it is for developed nations (eg. USA). Every tic up in productivity in the US only exacerbates the existing underemployment and declining wage problems the United State already faces. Whereas, innovation and productivity gains in China are reinvested in new Chinese capacity, albeit more horizontally or vertically spread than would have been seen 5 years ago. In sum, you are wrong.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by Animats on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @05:36PM (#14353512)
Piketty says that industrializing countries can develop at a rapid pace until they catch up. Then they're stuck at a max of about 5% growth, reflecting technological progress.
Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by abandonliberty on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @04:27PM (#14353007)
Our democratic structure doesn't work in a society with vast wealth differences. Over the last 10 years, has the prosperity and freedom of average Americans increased or decreased? Increasing wealth inequality in the long term is almost a guarantee of a broken democracy because who wants to be less prosperous?

That statement does expect some background in this. Potential resources include the Iron Law of Oligarchy on wikipedia, rules for rulers, or google :)

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by Denzel on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @05:06PM (#14353304)
Is that a rhetorical question with a foregone conclusion?

As an average American, whether prosperity increased or decreased, I feel grateful and prosperous every day. I can walk outside without fear of bombs dropping from overhead; I can run, bike, drive, or fly anywhere within this vast, beautiful land without encumbrance; I have uncensored access to the internet at-large; I get to watch some of the greatest entrepreneurs in the world build amazing things; I can communicate and interact with any one of the 300 million+ people here; and I can make money as I please when I please without anyone blocking me. And I can start doing all this with a minimum wage job (like I did).

That's just to name a few things.

No one is owed anything except for equality of opportunity. Are we wishing for equality of outcome? On its face, I can't understand why that would ever make sense.

Do I think we're fully at equality of opportunity yet? No. But I feel that's what we should be working on. That's what we should be protecting. I don't give a hoot who made $10B as long as I have the opportunity to as well.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by BenchRouter on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @06:56PM (#14354060)
> No one is owed anything except for equality of opportunity. Are we wishing for equality of outcome? On its face, I can't understand why that would ever make sense.

I hear this frequently, but it's sorta missing the point.

Nearly all people want equality of opportunity, and not outcome.

What people are concerned about is:

1) The bad outcomes don't need to be Kafkaesque or medieval (e.g. "too poor to be sick" doesn't need to be a thing).

2) If bad outcomes are becoming more and more frequent (as we see with e.g. wealth inequality becoming more pronounced), it's a smell that something systemically bad is happening. It's probably a sign that equality of opportunity is being reduced over time.

> Do I think we're fully at equality of opportunity yet? No. But I feel that's what we should be working on. That's what we should be protecting.

As I noted above, if outcomes are becoming more and more polarized over time, it's a likely sign that equality of opportunity is ceasing to exist.

Outcomes are the dependent variable we kinda have to use for measuring equality of opportunity, because we don't really have anything else to measure.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by jaggederest on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @12:39AM (#14355689)
I think the key thing people miss when they go on about 'equality of opportunity not equality of outcome' is that by making some of the outcomes intolerable (dying of cancer because you can't afford care, for example), you actually deny opportunity.

If the route to wealth and satisfaction in life was russian roulette, would that be considered 'equality of opportunity' and thus fine? I doubt it.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by abandonliberty on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @08:04PM (#14354463)
Your list of things you appreciate is great! However, point in time data has little relevance to the argument I put forward.

Unless you are implying that average Americans care more about the FEELING of prosperity than ACTUAL prosperity, so that reductions in their actual prosperity do not go against their will. Lotteries exhibit wealth concentrating behavior, so there is some evidence for this argument as people(particularly the poor and less educated) voluntarily participate.

However, I'm pretty sure if we polled people they would disagree. I suspect even you may disagree.

Also: >I can run, bike, drive, or fly anywhere within this vast, beautiful land without encumbrance

I suspect making that claim requires either willful ignorance or a lack of exposure to minorities - or both. Oppression of minorities does not imply a breakdown of democracy though.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by Denzel on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @10:15PM (#14355074)
I'm not sure I understand your distinction between feeling of prosperity and actual prosperity. What do you consider actual prosperity?

And my claim requires an imperfect broad brush because nothing in this world will ever reach perfection in the eyes of everyone. However, I don't feel the need to add little conditions and details to everything I say when it applies to the vast majority of people.

I am a minority. I live in a city of minorities. My days are spent with minorities and people in the majority. My claim applies to the 1M+ minorities in my city. It requires neither willful ignorance nor lack of exposure to minorities.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by abandonliberty on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @12:10AM (#14355582)
Your claim is fine, except that it has no real relevance to the argument. It could be true in a kingdom or a fascist dictatorship. It's meaningless without something to compare it to.

You need to distinguish between "point in time" data such as your claim, and data collected over time or with comparisons.

Saying 'things are great!' is relatively meaningless to understanding the health of a democracy.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by Denzel on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @12:46AM (#14355716)
You didn't exactly answer my question. Show me the data on the real prosperity you're talking about. I'm asking for it.
Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by abandonliberty on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @12:51PM (#14360278)
My first comment referenced wealth inequality so you either lack good faith or comprehension.

I suspect it's the former. I'm not in this to win points, nor am I your adversary.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by Denzel on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @01:32PM (#14360700)
Funny, you're certainly speaking adversarially while I'm seeking an earnest answer.

Just like speed is relative given your frame of reference, wealth inequality does not prove a decrease in prosperity. Not by a long shot. So, if that's your proof, it doesn't make sense.

Because if my plane is accelerating while yours is accelerating faster: inequality of position has hastened while we've both improved.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by abandonliberty on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @10:08PM (#14364371)
It took you 4 messages to respond to my key point. Bravo.
Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by j2bax on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @07:01PM (#14354091)
>Do I think we're fully at equality of opportunity yet? No.

I think this would be the issue most people have with the increasing income gap. As long as billionaires can pay a lower tax percentage than the lower/middle-class, I think frustration and desire for change is valid.

Re:Sending Jobs Overseas by enraged_camel on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @04:30PM (#14353035)
Exactly. Wealth disparity results in disparity in political representation, and that is inherently undemocratic.