The 2nd hand source was posted to HN, but quickly flag killed. The 1st hand source is not a media figure, nor are they in interested in writing a tell-all Medium article.
Moreover, the national security advisor's rather curt statement addressing the matter did not actually deny what the Post reported-- read it carefully.
You don't think he would deny it, if it didn't happen? C'mon.
have you heard of the glomar response? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glomar_response
or lying by ommision? or being deliberately ambiguous?
there are many reason why he wouldn't deny it if it didn't happen. I can't read his mind, and neither can you. assuming his intentions one way or the other is a dangerous misstep.
as for anonymous sources, their credibility is directly tied to the credibility of the source that reports their stories. what if they Washington Post is making stuff up to sell papers? not saying they are, but they could be.
There are also few news sources more credible than the Washington Post.
this is sockpuppeting 101: it happens every day on reddit and other internet forums. what makes you think that its not possible when we're talking about russia and the united states?
Lots of details as to specifically what Trump shared that was troublesome, and how McMaster's denial didn't address the issue.
See, now even the President has admitted it! You can't get any more first hand than that!