News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by amarant on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:25AM (#14340996)
Id like to be able to configure 2 passwords on my devices, one that logs me in, and another "destruct password" that when entered as password, wipes the device clean and overwrites the drive.

preferably I'd be able to configure certain directories that should be wiped, so only confidential data is destroyed.

then it would log in normally. I doubt silly borderguards would realize the pwnage

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by kortex on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:05AM (#14341222)
That's clever and all, but I feel like it dodges a very important human rights issue, rather than tackling it head-on. People shouldn't have to resort to some Inspector Gadget-esque "this message will selfdestruct" or real-partition-hidden-partition mechanism. Furthermore it also disadvantages people who are less tech savvy and can't implement such mechanisms. If you're not served a warrant, they shouldn't be allowed go snooping into locked devices.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by komali2 on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:01PM (#14343149)
The problem is in this case, the guy is specifically in a grey area of "enemy of powers-that-be in the country he's entering." He deals with for example cases where western nations torture terror suspects.

If we leave law aside and think only in terms of "sides," that means that he is "opposed" to these governments, and it would only make sense for them to be hostile to him using their powers (arrest, taking his laptops, etc).

Now let's continue to leave the law aside, because that's what our governments can do when they please, usually by not telling us (Snowden showed us this several years ago in no uncertain terms).

So, human rights or no, a hidden-partition mechanism is merely allowing a civilian to use the same tools a government is - non-legal ones. In an ideal world, everybody (governments and civilians) would follow perfectly fair laws. That's not this world, those aren't our governments, so we all should be open to resorting outside the legal system to protect ourselves.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by chii on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:14AM (#14341265)
When a legal rights don't exist, people go for a way to enforce their rights technologically.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by wordupmaking on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:51AM (#14341546)
So "the internet" keeps saying for over a decade, yet the collar keeps shrinking. I think it's kool-aid.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by sqeaky on Monday May 15, 2017 @04:18PM (#14344768)
As a group it doesn't work for any but the largest issues, look at SOPA.

But many individuals do what they can. Consider the increase in encryption use.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by mikeash on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:55AM (#14342024)
It's not a dodge unless it's being proposed as an acceptable alternative to reforming these powers, not merely a way to cope with them. You can reasonably attempt to implement both technological and political solutions.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by lr4444lr on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:42AM (#14341084)
Clever, but would likely add "obstruction of justice" to the charges against you, and reduce your chances at beating the original point of suspicion, should it ever result in charges, due to spoliation of evidence.

Why not instead just refuse, and use the technicality of violation of privacy, to beat the authorities by making anything they find inadmissible in the first place?

(I'm assuming US-centric here, of course.)

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Normal_gaussian on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:54AM (#14341153)
That may work if you are covering up possession of illegal downloads or something similar.

But if you are protecting your privacy (personal documents etc.) or your companies privacy (source code, plans, etc.) then you've still lost.

The deletion password would work, as long as they don't image the drive first and use your software to decrypt.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by wiz21c on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:13PM (#14343731)
The only way is to physically destroy the hard disk, like making confetti with it. For example, it's very hard to destroy data saved on SSD drives (last time I heard)
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by eDISCO on Monday May 15, 2017 @03:25PM (#14344362)
There's a clever way to destroy data on SSD: just overwrite your (encrypted) hard drive encryption key, then even though the data remains, the key is lost forever. I think most modern SSDs come with the feature.

More info in this question: https://superuser.com/questions/986387/why-does-my-ssd-inter...

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Bartweiss on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:51AM (#14341548)
But this is a request made prior to any charges being laid. I'm actually curious what the legal situation would be: if you had been charged on other evidence it would likely be obstruction, but is that a charge that can be laid without any reason to suspect a crime has occurred?
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by lr4444lr on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:52AM (#14341988)
IANAL, but I have had the pleasure of having several in my family. One of the things I've come to learn is (again, U.S. centric) that you don't typically get out of legal trouble once you're in the authorities' clutches by "technical cleverness". You don't know at the time described by the parent poster what other evidence might exist, and that includes faulty witness statements. If you mislead the prosecutors to destroy harmless data that could have gotten the whole case dismissed through a technicality, the act could be used in the worst way against you. Don't help the prosecution. Keep your mouth shut and your data expressedly off-limits until you get your legal representation.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by 3131s on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:34AM (#14342355)
> that you don't typically get out of legal trouble once you're in the authorities' clutches by "technical cleverness".

Right, technical cleverness is the lawyer's job. If you get arrested on any serious charges in the US politely tell the police that you need to speak to a lawyer.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by valuearb on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:24PM (#14342818)
In the US you should almost always tell police, no matter what the question, that you decline to answer any questions without your lawyer. Don't talk to the police, they aren't your friends. They are trying to build a case to convict someone, and not necessarily a guilty person.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Jach on Monday May 15, 2017 @06:36PM (#14345776)
I feel like this advice, though not bad, always needs to have some sort of follow-up about how you procure "your" lawyer. Is it best to do it in advance (by having a list of local names and areas of expertise) or at the time of arrest (will you have access to Google?)? Should you take your chances with either a court-appointed one or whoever has the flashiest advertisements made available to you? Most of us don't have someone to call "my lawyer", so the prospect of invoking a non-existent figure makes it all the more tempting to simply answer the police's questioning.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by valuearb on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @08:39PM (#14354639)
If you are talking about the US, If you don't have a lawyer, one will be appointed for you.

You still don't have to answer questions and should never answer questions until you can consult with a lawyer.

The classic video from a law professor and former criminal defense attorney, with a response from an active police detective.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d-7o9xYp7eE

"I will never talk to a police officer under any circumstances"

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Jach on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @10:26PM (#14355130)
Yes, I know, I watched that around when it was first posted. But how effective is a court-appointed lawyer going to be, controlled for various types of legal hassle, controlled for (in the case of an accusation) actual guilt and innocence? In a case of refusing to disclose a password (or even admit the existence of a password, saying literally nothing), are you going to trust the court appointed lawyer or (if you could procure them) someone at the EFF to better represent you? All lawyers have to meet certain obligations but that doesn't mean they're all equal.

Given that most people talk too much to the police most of the time without dire consequences (police have a lot of flexibility in what they can do with your volunteered information, it's a two-edged sword) a more careful cost-benefit analysis of saying nothing or saying certain things is irresistible to smart tech people. If you're going to take the principled 'never talk under any circumstances' approach you need to have thought of various situations so you can make that principle work the most for you and not let it become an unnecessary cost.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by openasocket on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:50AM (#14341979)
Whether charges have been made is completely irrelevant. If you prevent a LEO from doing is or her job that's obstruction, or spoliation, or one of a couple other charges depending on the specifics.

If this wasn't the case, you do these sorts of obstructions to trick officers into never laying charges for the crime you committed. You might respond, "well shouldn't they be charged with the crime they committed in that case, not the obstruction stuff?" And they can be charged for that as well, but often the obstruction, especially the destruction of evidence, makes it impossible to actually get a conviction.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by dsp1234 on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:08AM (#14342138)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tampering_with_evidence

... or destroys evidence with the intent to interfere with an investigation (usually) by a law-enforcement, governmental, or regulatory authority.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Rmilb on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:41AM (#14342418)
What would be the legality of stating " My password is not XYZ", when XYZ is the destruct password. Can you get the obstruction of justice charge if they try it and it destroys evidence?
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by falcolas on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:57AM (#14342569)
Intent matters. If your intent was to trigger the destruction of data, you'd probably still be slapped with the obstruction of justice charges.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by roywiggins on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:38PM (#14342939)
And judges aren't fond of people who are obviously trying to pull a fast one.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by ryukafalz on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:54PM (#14344113)
Here's an idea: write the self-destruct password on a post-it note and leave it on your monitor. It's the same sort of thing, but preemptively - it's not obstruction of justice if you're not under investigation when you do that.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by kazinator on Monday May 15, 2017 @05:11PM (#14345163)
How can the sentence "X is not Y" possibly specify the intent "I want you to try X anyway, to see what happens".
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by khedoros1 on Monday May 15, 2017 @06:55PM (#14345919)
Because it's reasonable to assume that you know that a statement like that will arouse their curiosity. You're dealing with humans looking for some kind of actionable information, and with reason to believe that you may be trying to deceive them on some level or another.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by jjnoakes on Monday May 15, 2017 @06:35PM (#14345769)
When you have prior knowledge about what X does (deletes evidence) and there's no reason to say "the password is not X" other than to trick someone into trying X as the password, that's how.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by triplesec on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:16AM (#14341720)
I don't think this objection flies, because if you just turn up with a wiped phone and special login accounts they also can't do anything to you.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Belphemur on Monday May 15, 2017 @08:36AM (#14341049)
I'd prefer a clean partition with some unconspicuous data on it.

Better that way then they won't dig more into the phone.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by flipp3r on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:05AM (#14341217)
Truecrypt and variations have something like this, I believe they call it Hidden volumes
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by bitwize on Monday May 15, 2017 @09:43AM (#14341481)
If they find out or even suspect it, hello felony obstruction of justice and making false statements charges.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Posibyte on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:28AM (#14341816)
Can you be charged with obstruction of justice if you haven't been charged or served a warrant? i.e. just being suspect doesn't put you in line of perjury charges in this case.

I'm not a lawyer, but that was my interpretation in case that's wrong.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by openasocket on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:02AM (#14342089)
Yes, you absolutely can be charged with obstruction without a warrant. If you are being interviewed by an LEO and you lie to them to disrupt their investigation, that's potentially a crime. It doesn't matter if you haven't been subpoenaed or aren't under oath.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by mirimir on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:26PM (#14342839)
OK, how about this. I offer FDE as a service, anonymously via Tor. Your Linux machine uses LUKS, with remote unlocking via dropbear. But you don't have the decryption passphrase. Before booting, you must alert me via Signal with video, stating that you are not under coercion, with identity and time verification. Then I SSH via Tor, and unlock your machine.

The argument is that authorities can't force you to lie to me, in order to get your machine unlocked. And you don't need to lie to them, either.

But of course, you'd need to trust me implicitly ;)

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by openasocket on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:15PM (#14343269)
It's a cute scenario.

I'm not a lawyer, but I'm fairly sure they can compel me to lie to you. I think the standard is that the police can, at least with a warrant, compel you to do anything that you would do normally. For instance, if you're a company that keeps a database of user actions, they can compel you to give them access to that database, because accessing that data is a part of your normal business process. They can even compel you to write some software to extract the specific data they need (within reason). And in your scenario, I am able to access my own computer, and do so regularly as part of my normal life.

You probably came up with this scenario thinking about so-called "warrant canaries," which hinge on law enforcement not being able to force companies to lie to their users. But it should be noted there is no case law or precedent regarding warrant canaries, and the legal consensus seems to be it is unlikely to hold up in court.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by mirimir on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @12:32AM (#14347381)
Yes, I was thinking of warrant canaries. I'm also unaware of case law or precedent. But I do note that Riseup did not update its warrant canary while under subpoena. This generated considerable controversy. But Riseup made no statement either way, except for this enigmatic tweet:

    listen to the hummingbird, whose wings you cannot see,
    listen to the hummingbird, don't listen to me.
    #LeonardCohenpic.twitter.com/PZisFt6mHm
    — riseup.net (@riseupnet) November 11, 2016
So it seemed to work, and I haven't seen any fallout.

How about this. When you use my FDE as a service, part of my payment is selling your computer to me for a nominal fee. So you're never using your computer, you're using mine. And my lease agreement requires confirmation that you're not under compulsion.

Fantasizing a bit, one can imagine a multi-probe EEG net that could report your state of mind. Perhaps the remote processor could be trained to recognize coercion, nervousness, etc.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by openasocket on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @12:36PM (#14350923)
> my lease agreement requires confirmation that you're not under compulsion.

You can't have a "no cops" requirement in a lease agreement, that wouldn't be remotely enforceable.

> Fantasizing a bit, one can imagine a multi-probe EEG net that could report your state of mind

Ordinarily, at this point, the warrant would then be given to you, not me. This is complicated by the fact that you presumably are trying to stay anonymous and there are questions of jurisdiction. But they will at least try to contact you and compel you to give them access. If you refuse now you're committing a crime, and they'll go after you. So you'd better hope your OPSEC is solid. And, after a certain point of ridiculousness, they might go after me, saying I purposefully used this system to elude lawful requests for access (which would be true!). That's going to be tricky to prove, and at that point I don't have enough legal knowledge to figure out if that holds up.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by wiz21c on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:19PM (#14343779)
I'm sure in this kind of human rights stuff the problem is absolutely not technical. It's just a detail. What counts is to be able to put yourself in a position where you can be defended by a lawyer or whatever support (like an Ecuadorian embassy ? :-) ). Trying to technologically sidestep the law enforcement is just ridiculous. It proves that you recognize you're doing wrong stuff (wrong in the eyes of those running after you), it sends a very bad signal.

And anyway, as said elsewhere, at some point you are opposing a government. And if you're opposing in a strong way, then well, you basically declared war and you'll have to fight the Goliath. Thus before attempting any fight, make sure you have a very good network of supporters...

Technology won't help :-(

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by mirimir on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @12:51AM (#14347441)
In my experience, changing unjust laws is at least as hard. Consider the fights against slavery, for women's rights, to end segregation, for gay rights, for gender freedom, and generally for decriminalization of all victimless crimes. Privacy has arguably played key roles for all of them. For peer discussion, for organizing and logistics, for fund-raising, etc. And technology has always played a key role in protecting privacy.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by wiz21c on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @02:51AM (#14347834)
yep. I was talking about using technology to protect against an ongoing threat. Technology can help to make myself invisible but as soon as the opposing force gets me, it's very tough to use technology to keep invisibility...

So I'll use Tor and Tox to hide myself as long as possible. But when the bad guys rings my bell, I know the only way out is to burn everything. They won't be deterred by some 2048 bits password...

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by mirimir on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @03:06AM (#14347884)
Yes, my thoughts exactly :)

Based on an OPSEC risk assessment, it may seem rather unlikely that the NSA and other national intelligence agencies are adversaries. Why would they care about Mirimir?

However, I find it useful to assume that they are. And so I employ many countermeasures that might seem foolish. Basically, I do whatever is workable. And then I write about it for income and pleasure. I do keep in mind, however, the "possibility that [a] countermeasure could create an OPSEC indicator" (DoD OPSEC manual at p. 14).[0]

But burning everything, that's also obstruction, I think.

0) https://www.OPSECprofessionals.org/official/081103_DOD_OPSEC... OPSEC manual

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Canada on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:02PM (#14343152)
You could add shamir secret sharing and restrict your remote access to running a program that accepts your secret.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by mirimir on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @01:04AM (#14347483)
Sure. I don't know how to integrate that with LUKS, however.

But even so, once I had remote SSH access to initramfs, and had unlocked LUKS, I could mount /root and mess with the system, adding my own trusted key for remote access, etc.

So basically, users would need to trust me fully.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Canada on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @04:11PM (#14352875)
Your special login shell would not allow you to do anything except provide your secret, after which you are simply disconnected without having the opportunity to do anything else. A different process not under your control would mount the volume. At no point would you get to execute arbitrary commands or open any files. You would only have to be trusted not to hold your secret for ransom.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by komali2 on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:10PM (#14343216)
Then exactly what happened here occurs - he gets arrested for not unlocking his laptop, I'd imagine.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by mirimir on Tuesday May 16, 2017 @01:05AM (#14347487)
Except, as I say above, it's not his laptop. It's mine, and I'm just letting him use it. If they want access to it, they can come after me :)
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by Posibyte on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:09AM (#14342147)
Right, but in this case, when there isn't a crime. When they're looking for evidence to charge you with or use as a reason to deport or something in that area. In that case, can that be construed as Obstruction of Justice?
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by openasocket on Monday May 15, 2017 @11:27AM (#14342301)
> Right, but in this case, when there isn't a crime

There wasn't a crime, until you deceived officers. It doesn't matter if you deceived them to cover up a crime, or to protect your privacy, or just for fun, it's still illegal.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by jriot on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:25PM (#14342829)
How is that illegal? They asked for a password to their device. He gave a password which then cleaned the device. For all the authorities know, it was a clean device i.e., brand new. Maybe they enjoy regularly installing new OSs using a clean install.

This being illegal is equally as bad them searching devices in the first place without just cause.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by openasocket on Monday May 15, 2017 @12:51PM (#14343063)
They'd have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt you were tampering with potential evidence to convict you. So they'd have to try and prove in court you gave them a password which cleaned the device.

> For all the authorities know, it was a clean device i.e., brand new

Just because you can get away with something doesn't mean it isn't a crime.

Lying to or misleading investigators is a crime, I don't know how to be more clear than that.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by jriot on Monday May 15, 2017 @01:41PM (#14343475)
If the password you give them also cleans your device you have given them the password to access your device. How is that lying or misleading?

I would argue their invasion of privacy is a crime but no one is watching the watchers, thus these types of measures are going to be used.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by openasocket on Monday May 15, 2017 @02:01PM (#14343638)
They ask to access your files, and you delete your files. I guess that isn't lying per se, but it definitely is destruction of evidence, which falls under the general heading of obstruction of justice. And before you ask, yes, it is still considered evidence even if there's nothing incriminating there. It is considered evidence because an LEO asked for it as part of an investigation.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by LordKano on Monday May 15, 2017 @04:32PM (#14344864)
Yes and that's why you should never lie to investigators. They can lie to you and it's legal, if you lie to them it's a crime.

You're always better off to pass all communications through a lawyer. They're not allowed to lie to a lawyer.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by triplesec on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:17AM (#14341725)
Really? For a search? You are allowed to hide things in your house. This is certainly not legislated.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by sillysaurus3 on Monday May 15, 2017 @10:33AM (#14341864)
It's illegal to lie to investigators. (They're allowed to lie to you, but not vice-versa.)
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by jessaustin on Monday May 15, 2017 @03:22PM (#14344336)
This fact actually makes it a potential offense to say anything to them. After all it's not their fault if they misunderstand you...
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by kazinator on Monday May 15, 2017 @05:14PM (#14345182)
The problem is that if people do this, the authorities will quickly learn to gain physical access to a device first and make a bit exact copy before doing anything else. (Which they probably already do anyway.)

It's as if you've created a computer game for the cops in which they have one "life", before "game over". But they can easily defeat that by "saving the game" before the risky encounter with your data-eating password monster, to give themselves as many lives as they wish.

Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by khedoros1 on Monday May 15, 2017 @06:57PM (#14345943)
Well...except in the case of the disk encryption key being stored in a "secure enclave"-style chip. You don't need to erase the data on the device, just clear the unreadable keystore.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by incompatible on Monday May 15, 2017 @07:24PM (#14346100)
Why bother? If you are happy to delete the data, no doubt you've got a backup online somewhere. So you may as well delete it before you travel and get it back when you need it.
Re:Human rights activist risks prison over refusal to disclo... by kazinator on Monday May 15, 2017 @05:08PM (#14345135)
I'd like to be able to enter my ATM pin in reverse, so that it logs in normally, but also secretly phones for help!

(Widely circulated, unimplemented idea which some people believe actually exists.)