It's not like I'm working on some bitcoin business or anything but I am offended that you think Bitcoin is the same type of hype as "AI, IoT, etc.". Trust me I'm the biggest hater of the AI hype in 2016-2017 (driven by VCs and BigCos for their own interest). The reason I know these are hypes is because most technical people who actually have been working in these fields know exactly what's possible and what's not, but the non-technical VCs and marketers are driving the "market" (that doesn't exist) thinking that something groundbreaking has suddenly happened. The fact is: nothing groundbreaking has happened. The technology is getting better for sure, but compared to bitcoin these are nothing new.
Bitcoin is actually something new and a novel piece of technology, which is different from all the other marketing hypewords you compared it with. At this point I think the chances are 50/50 that it will succeed, but really nobody knows what will happen. Anyone claiming to know the future is being arrogant.
I don't follow coins closely anymore but the main one I saw was namecoin, which hasn't yet seen much use.
There are many companies now where you can get your salary paid in Bitcoin. In fact, it is so infinitely more convenient, I think that only the forces of mental inertia hold this approach from immediate universal adoption.
Blockchain is at place right now where managers and marketers are asking "What can blockchain do for us". But where are the examples of "Big company X implemented blockchain to solve problem Y?" maybe it's too soon for those.
But these "top down" approaches never work. That's how it played out with Internet vs Intranet. When the Internet was first gaining traction all the bigcos thought the money was in Intranet because that was more "monetizable". MS went down that route and never recovered.
I also used to be skeptical about all these VCs jumping into Bitcoin ecosystem, but now it's 2017 and if you look around, they kind of gave up on investing in "companies", and are instead trying to buy up the currencies themselves, which means everyone's on level playing ground, which is exactly what happened with the Internet.
I am more annoyed at these marketer types who jump into Bitcoin than anyone, but I don't think these people will end up winning because they have no substance.
But I have no idea what he's talking about when he says "And without exception, I observed that they were initially loaded in the back door by geeks, without asking permission, because they got shit done and helped people with their jobs."
Is he saying Bitcoin is not being developed by geeks?
Is he saying Bitcoin is not "helping people get shit done and helping people with their jobs"?
There are valid criticisms, and there are really baseless rants like this. Just because you're "old" doesn't mean you know the future from your past experience. Tons of talented old people (and younger people too) with tons of experience never realized the potential of the Internet when it first came out.
Oh, and when Internet first came out, it never was meant to "get shit done and help people with their jobs", for a long time. It was a fringe culture. If he's as experienced as he claims to be, he should know better.