News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by splintercell on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:11AM (#14324064)
I never bought this argument that somehow Walmart is abusing the system.

Abusing the system implies that only if Walmart stops doing the abuse, somehow abuse will stop, but this clearly is not the case.

Contrary to what writers of this article believe, prices are not formed in isolation of buyer and seller, in this case labor is being sold, and if Walmart does not lower the salaries and transfer the savings to the customers then some other company is going to beat the to it and manage to provide the cheapest good for the same quality.

Most people believe that when a company does something X, to achieve a reduction in costs, then it simply uses it to increase it's own profit margin, but they don't understand that instead of increasing their current profit margin, they can increase their future profit margin by selling their products for less by passing that lower cost to the customer.

Calling it a 'Walmart' tax is a spin on things which is aimed to invoke emotional imagery, it's like if NJ lawmakers called a tax as 'Tesla tax' because by bypassing the dealers they are putting more people out of job and on welfare, therefore the tax which will be used increase the benefits is 'Tesla Tax'.

There is a wide welfare structure in America, and the market will reflect that. If you give certain group of people free healthcare, then their employers will stop providing them with healthcare, if they give 3% 401K contribution to all working employees then yes, their employer's contribution will go down by 3%.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by the_gastropod on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:16AM (#14324095)
> if Walmart does not lower the salaries and transfer the savings to the customers then some other company is going to beat the to it and manage to provide the cheapest good for the same quality

This excuse can be used to justify virtually any deplorable behavior by a corporation. "If _we_ don't cut prices by dumping waste directly into the river, another company will!" Costco competes head-to-head with Walmart on prices, and doesn't treat their employees like cattle.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by jrs95 on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:39AM (#14324293)
I think it's more about ensuring that the system is structured in such a way that these things are minimized. If you don't want waste dumped in the river, ban it or tax it rather than subsidizing it. The Costco comparison is a bit apples to oranges, too. They have a substantially different customer base. There are a lot of people who can't afford that $110 membership. Lower income Americans are the ones who benefit the most from WalMart's services. Aldi is more competitive in this area, but they do it by significantly different means, and they're still focused on maintaining a very low labor cost, they just do it differently than WalMart does.

And as someone who worked at WalMart for awhile, their lack of a union (Meijer and Kroger both required I have full weekend availability as a result of their union contract -- and I needed weekends free for my job at McDonald's) and the relative ease of being able to get a job there was a huge part in my own escape from poverty.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by the_gastropod on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:26AM (#14324810)
I totally agree. I don't think wanting to improve the system and being critical of corporations exploiting the current system are mutually exclusive. You can have both.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by jasode on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:49AM (#14324405)
>Costco competes head-to-head with Walmart on prices,

This isn't really true. Costco carries less than 4000 SKUs in its warehouses. Walmart carries 40000 SKUs. That's an order-of-magnitude difference.

Costco competes more with (Walmart's) Sams Club warehouse but based on my shopping, their product selections don't overlap. (E.g. Costco has high-end wine that Walmart/SC doesn't carry.)

To make Costco vs Walmart an apples-to-apples comparison, Costco would have to eliminate the $60 to $110 annual membership fees, allow any non-member to shop there, and add 45000 additional SKUs.

I don't know anyone who shops at both Walmart and Costco on a regular weekly basis. Their business structures attract very different shopper demographics.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by ftlio on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:55AM (#14324469)
The income of your average Costco shopper is massive compared to your average Walmart shopper as well.

They can't eliminate the annual fee either because it's literally less than their annual profit (well maybe not in this market but it was a few years ago). Their demographic is people with the financial 'ability' to think $100 ahead for a year, to whom they deliver goods at basically cost.

Walmart vs Costco is a complete myth. Costco operates where Walmart does very poorly.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by mholmes680 on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:28AM (#14324199)
I agree with the parent comment here, the system allows this so I can't fault Walmart on it. What I can fault is them lobbying against/killing labor unions [0]. Labor Unions would fix this problem in a capitalist way.

It is interesting to see the numbers in this article ~$6B in subsidies, and then compare that to dividends/buybacks: oh, look $6B-$7B [1] not even including buybacks. That is a direct redistribution of wealth [edit] from bottom to the top.

[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/features/2015-walmart-union-survei... [1] http://www.vuru.co/analysis/WMT/dividendsBuybacks

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by jrs95 on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:40AM (#14324306)
I was actually glad they did this. Union rules at their competitors are terrible for people working two jobs. Although mandatory overtime pay laws are also a huge pain to someone with a legitimate need to work more than 40 hours a week.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by splintercell on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:08AM (#14324615)
> What I can fault is them lobbying against/killing labor unions [0]. Labor Unions would fix this problem in a capitalist way.

But that's not true at all. Unions do not actually benefit all workers equally, they benefit senior workers more at the expense of the more junior workers. And because of Union wage requirements, many times the junior workers are pushed to supplement their income by working in other industries, by suppressing wages in other industries.

Unions have a lot of problems associated with them, you should talk to someone who is young and part of a union and see all the issues they have.

I once had a conversation with an actor who was claiming the huge benefits of actors union and how because of that she is able to afford to have healthcare. The problem with this conversation was that this was happening while she was talking my order at a restaurant where she worked to supplement her income. I mean that defeats the whole point of union, wouldn't it be better if she was able to work more number of hours on screen at a lower wage and increase her skill set rather than working as a waitress on the side?

Nearly all the union attempts to increase wages result in companies either dropping the number of employees they have or drop the number of hours they employ them for. Sadly only the younger or junior workers pay this cost. If you are an older union workers, then there are nothing but benefits for you.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by mholmes680 on Friday May 12, 2017 @12:27PM (#14325368)
I was once young and part of a union (an electrical union), and while I didn't directly appreciate it then i see it better now. It allowed me a $15/hr 40hr/wk summer job with overtime available instead of $6 working at an ice cream truck or minimum wage retail... My experience aligned with the findings of this report: http://www.epi.org/publication/briefingpapers_bp143/

But back to Walmart... sans unions, only a consumer boycott over morals would change anything, and if it didn't [0] happen yet [1], I feel like its not going to... or hopefully it'll boil over in a few years. Personally, I've shopped there twice in the past 10 years - which i guess means i'm stupid since i'm paying a tax for them regardless, but maybe that's cancelled out since i participate in the stock market getting those dividends? I'm confused easily on those things.

[0] http://www.ethicalconsumer.org/boycotts/boycottslist.aspx#w

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wal-Mart:_The_High_Cost_of_Low...

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by skybrian on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:18AM (#14324735)
I don't follow your argument. It seems unlikely that there is anyone could do that would guarantee employment to everyone who wants to work in the entertainment industry. It's structurally a winner-take-all industry. Providing health insurance to part-time workers is no small thing.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by lotsofpulp on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:35AM (#14324257)
I don't think Costco competes head to head with Wal Mart at all.

Costco has the membership fee, and they only sell in bulk, which are usually better quality and higher cost than Walmart items. If you can barely afford Wal Mart, you definitely can't afford Costco and aren't even comparing the two.

Costco also doesn't put its stores in low income areas, automatically selecting for higher income customers.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by specialist on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:44AM (#14324335)
Exactly. Walmart competes with Costco.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam%27s_Club

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by djrogers on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:48AM (#14324385)
There's nothing in the article about Sam's Club employees or conditions - it specifically calls out Walmart stores.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by splintercell on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:16AM (#14324708)
> This excuse can be used to justify virtually any deplorable behavior by a corporation.

It's not a justification, no more than if you ask me to shoo away the flies from food and I said "but what's the point, some other fly is going to sit on it", I am not justifying it, I am merely pointing out the futility of your solution. The real solution would involve not having to constantly shoo away the flies.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by humanrebar on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:23AM (#14324152)
Paying people less or hiring people getting government benefits is nothing like dumping poison into a water supply.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by hedora on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:39AM (#14324294)
It is similar to slowly poisoning the water supply when you destroy dozens to hundreds of local mom and pop stores with each supercenter (which leads to decreased life expectancy in the community, due to drug/alcohol abuse, suicide, etc).

Anyway, that well-documented boat sailed in the '90s, and now we have Amazon (and I think Amazon deliveries are a net good thing).

What really bugs me is that I have to subsidize low wages at walmart. If the US would just switch to guaranteed income or raise the minimum wage, walmart prices would go up something like 1%, but their employees would make at least 33% more. Then my taxes could be used for something useful, like education.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by jrs95 on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:45AM (#14324348)
Those expenses would also be passed on to working class people who are not making much more than the minimum wage, though. Paying for it with taxation is probably better in that regard. Although that could be offset in other ways. Adjustments to EITC and universal child care could make a huge difference for low income people, without having to have a full guaranteed income.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by specialist on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:53AM (#14324441)
Walmart's business model is to enrich themselves by stealing from suppliers, taxpayers, employees. Their retail operation is how they launder the money.

The Freedom Market™ zealots willfully ignore that Walmart destroys competition, with other people's money.

I do not mind mega corporations being anticompetitive. Sociopath is as sociopath does.

I do mind pretending that its a moral good.

I do mind that I (Jane Taxpayer) is paying the bill.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by dang on Saturday May 13, 2017 @02:56AM (#14329832)
Please don't post ideological rants here, regardless of their flavor.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by forgotpwtomain on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:18AM (#14324109)
This is a spurious analysis, Walmart is large enough and invested in keeping the system the way it is (low un-liveable minimum-wage) to support its business. As a huge corporation it has considerable effect in that regard.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by djrogers on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:07AM (#14324597)
Walmart doesn't pay minimum wage to it's store employees. It may be a low wage, but it's well above the legal minimum wage...

[1]http://www.cnbc.com/2017/01/27/wal-mart-is-making-it-easier-...

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by humanrebar on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:24AM (#14324170)
> low un-liveable minimum-wage

Why does a grocery bagger need to have a livable wage? Seems like a great first job for someone in high school or a nice part-time job to help generate a little extra income.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by bradleyankrom on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:32AM (#14324233)
Because oftentimes it is the wage by which they are forced to live?
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by humanrebar on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:31AM (#14324851)
So the proposal is to give employers a choice:

- hire no grocery baggers

- only hire grocery baggers if they're willing to pay $20 an hour or more

...it doesn't necessarily follow that someone will end up with a living wage from this kind of regulation.

There is also the unintended consequence that (no longer employable) young people are less qualified for future work because they've never learned how to work hard, manage their bosses, etc.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by brianbreslin on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:46AM (#14324364)
Minimum wage is not something only teenagers work for. That fantasy has been disproven over and over again. The largest group of minimum wage earners are 18-40 year old women, many supporting families.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by winstonewert on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:00AM (#14324532)
So?

When a single mother is trying to support her family on a minimum wage, yes, that's bad.

But there's nothing wrong with a teenager making minimum wage in his first job.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by specialist on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:54AM (#14324454)
Because incorporation is a charter to do business in the service of society.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by vidarh on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:27AM (#14324196)
Are you suggesting those are the only people in those types of jobs?
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by pjmorris on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:33AM (#14324244)
Where do you see the cut-off between jobs that can be lived off of and jobs that can't be lived off of?
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by humanrebar on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:01AM (#14324534)
I'm not sure I need to make that cut off? If people could provide enough value to live off of, then they would. Everyone wants to be paid more. If adults with kids aren't qualified for something more involved or demanding than grocery bagging, the problem is elsewhere, not with how much it's worth to an employer to pay someone to put milk in a paper bag.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by forgotpwtomain on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:12AM (#14324652)
> If people could provide enough value to live off of, then they would. Everyone wants to be paid more.

Have you ever had to support yourself or others while earning minimum wage? Or did your upper-middle-class family fund your college education so you could make a comfortable living as a software engineer? I'm seriously wondering because your tone is full of self-entitled, condescending ignorance.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by humanrebar on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:53AM (#14325055)
> Have you ever had to support yourself or others while earning minimum wage?

Yes. The home I grew up in was lower middle class at best, though it's irrelevant to my arguments and generally none of your business.

But since it's now a subject of interest, what is relevant was that earning minimum wage as a teenager helped my blue collar family since I paid for my own clothes, transportation, gas, food, school incidentals, and many other expenses.

I wouldn't have found a job paying $15 an hour. I would have been unemployed (though we don't count poor teenagers as unemployed usually). And my family's budget would have been negatively impacted.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by forgotpwtomain on Friday May 12, 2017 @04:14PM (#14327494)
> though it's irrelevant to my arguments and generally none of your business.

I don't think it's irrelevant because certain foundations predispose one to certain lines of arguments. Particularly

>> If adults with kids aren't qualified for something more involved or demanding than grocery bagging

Not all adults have had an equal opportunity to obtain a skill-set that would qualify them for a better job and once you are stuck barely scraping by with a livable-wage it's very difficult to alter that situation. Culture and upbringing play a large part; children are easily impressionable, those growing up in troubled families or neighborhoods are less likely to do well in school and less likely to gain a skill-set that they would need to provide more value in the future.

> what is relevant was that earning minimum wage as a teenager helped my blue collar family since I paid for my own clothes, transportation, gas, food, school incidentals, and many other expenses.

I think it's great you were able to do that, but that doesn't mean that this minimum-wage would be sufficient for someone without a family to support them, or trying to acquire a skill-set later in their twenties.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by humanrebar on Saturday May 13, 2017 @07:20AM (#14330394)
> I don't think it's irrelevant because certain foundations predispose one to certain lines of arguments.

Regardless, bringing personal history into it is bad reasoning and unnecessarily divisive at best. And at times it brings out the worst in people.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by watwut on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:44AM (#14324346)
What makes grocery bagging different from any other kind of job?
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by humanrebar on Friday May 12, 2017 @11:55AM (#14325075)
Why did I pick it as an example? It's usually minimum wage, entry level, and often done by teenagers as their first job. It's also not generally part of the tipping economy, which complicates the discussion a bit. It's also a job that one might do at Walmart or a competitor.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by j2bax on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:47AM (#14324373)
If you can't afford to pay a living being a living wage, then you can't afford to pay for the service... Maybe you should automate the task.
[dead]
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by sctb on Friday May 12, 2017 @02:05PM (#14326291)
Please do not violate the guidelines by posting uncivilly like this.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by gech on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:28AM (#14324206)
Go to a store and see the people actually working in reality.
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by abandonliberty on Friday May 12, 2017 @12:59PM (#14325657)
You are entirely correct in our competitive capitalist environment. Maximizing for short-term company gain outperforms those who would maximize for long-term social gain.

Companies must abuse every law, regardless of original intent, or risk irrelevance and failing to maximize shareholder value.

The problem is that what's good for the company often isn't what's good for society. It's a function of the basic rules of our society.

If we keep the capitalist model, then the problem is that risk/benefit ratios reward bad behavior. It's extremely hard to legislate soundly to prevent this.

Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by specialist on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:43AM (#14324323)
What measure of proof do you require?
Re:The Walmart Tax Every American Taxpayer Pays by gech on Friday May 12, 2017 @10:35AM (#14324258)
I don't buy your spin either.