> The real issue isn't paying for it, it's administering it.
Just give it to everyone and increase taxes slightly (very slightly). We already have the whole "report income for taxes" part done, so just use that to increase taxes on those who would otherwise not be eligible, then give the benefit to everyone.
The net expense will be the same, except with much less administrative effort.
> Me?
Thanks for your sacrifice. What if I am not willing to pay? Will I be sent in prison? That'd be pretty ironic.
Re:The Oldest Problem in American Prisons
by HarryHirsch on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @11:15PM
(#14305661)
Americans manage crime by moving away from it into the next county. Don't worry, you'll get to pay anyhow through a longer commute and a HOA-mandated minimum enclosed floor space.
If only we analysed actual costs and not just numerical metrics!
Re:The Oldest Problem in American Prisons
by BoiledCabbage on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @11:33PM
(#14305730)
Do you think the cost of the program would be less than the 30k per person you're already paying?
If it were less, would you pay? Or is more of principal thing?
Not to mention the gdp boost. If half those in prison instead end up with jobs, we have a more functional society. Even if they aren't paying taxes they are still helping the economy.
I'm "not willing" to pay for a lot of things our government does but that's how society works, you don't get to pick and choose individual line items.
I was pointing out the paradox that even in the fantasy where there is no crime because everyone gets "free housing and food", there will always be people who refuse to pay for housing and feeding other people.
Re:The Oldest Problem in American Prisons
by kasey_junk on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @11:30PM
(#14305725)
Reductive arguments rarely hold up in the real world. It is not true that if we had a great universal safety net there would be no crime. But it's also not true that advocating for a rebalance of the resources going into this space towards prevention and away from punishment is arguing for mass wealth theft.
There is no paradox in that.
Well, if you're not willing to pay your current tax that already goes towards funding prisons, you'll eventually be sent there as well. It's not that ironic.
Re:The Oldest Problem in American Prisons
by grondilu on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @12:12AM
(#14305876)
"We should give money to people so that nobody feels miserable enough to commit crime and we won't have to put them in prison." -> "But what about those who refuse to pay?" -> "We'll put them in prison".
That's the irony.
"We should pay lots of money to keep people who have committed minor crimes locked up in prison for a long time just so we can pretend we're making the world safer." -> "But what about those who refuse to pay?" -> "We'll put them in prison".
That's the further irony.
You're already paying lots of money to keep too many people in prison. The poster back up the thread was simply suggesting a cheaper alternative that would save you money.
The real issue isn't paying for it, it's administering it. We make it so difficult to to navigate the social safety net that it becomes a skill and the people who need help are frequently without that skill.