Re:Get started making music
by plussed_reader on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @10:52AM
(#14300499)
What don't current DAWS understand about music?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Same thing that pencils don't understand about writing, and paintbrushes don't understand about art.
I'd argue that current DAWs expect the user to understand at least something about music. Sounds like OP is working on some "syntax-aware" features for their DAW.
Also, if this DAW understands something about music, will it constrain me to its understanding about music?
Most of what I write is highly dissonant or straight up microtonal.
Re:Get started making music
by adamnemecek on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @11:58AM
(#14301108)
> will it constrain me to its understanding about music
This is actually exactly what I'm trying to prevent. Most of the current solutions only kind of constrain you to a certain tonal space that you can maybe explore but the space of possible compositions is actually insanely large. My DAW is going to try to help you explore all that.
Microtonality is definitely something I've thought about and I think I can make it work but I'm curious to know what do you use currently to compose?
I lean towards Reaper the most as far as DAWs go.
Often I'll use http://www.huygens-fokker.org/scala/ and my synths and a fair bit of SuperCollider/Overtone.
Isn't knowing something about music something of a prerequisite for someone who wants to make music? Of course everyone has to start somewhere, but as musician of 20 years who loves DAWs, I would say learn an instrument first, or at least concurrently, if you want to start producing music.
Re:Get started making music
by adamnemecek on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @12:08PM
(#14301184)
The thing is that once you learn the music theory, few DAWs let you leverage that to be more productive.
Also why do you have to learn music theory first, why can't the DAW teach you as you go?
Re:Get started making music
by quadrangle on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @01:46PM
(#14302263)
Mostly they don't understand well all the possibilities outside of typical meter and tuning systems. They can do some but tend to push you to writing 4-beat meters in 12-note-equal-temperament. Rhythm and pitch both have far far far more possibilities which DAWs either ignore or at least make second-class options you have to kind of fight for or try a few limited tastes.
Re:Get started making music
by adamnemecek on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @11:01AM
(#14300593)
Better question is what do they do understand about music?
Re:Get started making music
by PascLeRasc on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @11:27AM
(#14300814)
Well can you tell us about that? You're the one who made the claim.
Re:Get started making music
by adamnemecek on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @11:36AM
(#14300903)
Check out synfire, it's the only sw that somewhat similar. but it's very expensive, and the ui isn't great (sometimes it looks like writing music in excel, like it can provide "intelligence" but you have to check check boxes and click on things, aintnobodygottimeforthat.maymay. Some people might find it interesting that it's written in Smalltalk tho.