News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Sunday May 07, 2017 @10:17PM (#14288826)
How about returning the islands they stole, instead? We're happy to clean the mines ourselves. It's not like they're anywhere close to London, are they?
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by quirkafleeg on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:53AM (#14290141)
> How about returning the islands they stole, instead?

Obvious troll is obvious but for the sake of facts:

a) The Islands were uninhabited when the British settled there.

b) Argentina didn't even exist as an independent country when the British claimed the Falklands.

> It's not like they're anywhere close to London, are they?

It's not like Argentina is anywhere close to Madrid, but there seems to be a lot of people of Spanish descent living there.

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Monday May 08, 2017 @01:19PM (#14293600)
Ok, for the sake of facts, and I'm not quoting Wikipedia.

- Spain named several governors for those islands from 1774 to 1810. Sovereignity was clearly stated by Spain over those islands.

- During that time, those islands depended of Buenos Aires government.

- If Spain owned Argentina plus the Malvinas, then once Argentina got its independence from Spain, the Malvinas were included as part of that independence.

- 1820, frigate La Heroína sailed to Malvinas to take possesion of it

- 1825, Great Britain admitted Argentina's independence from Spain, but didn't claim the islands.

- 1828, Buenos Aires government granted Port Soledad to Luis Vernet, for building up a colony. For this purpose, he shipped 100 inhabitants to the islands.

- 1829, Vernet was named as governor of the islands

- 1833, Great Britain took the Malvinas, and expelled the inhabitants from the islands.

Not to mention other facts like geology, and that the UN approved the new map for Argentina, which expands the continental shelf all around the islands.[1][2]

So, care to tell me how can Argentina OWN all the argentinean sea shelf AROUND the islands, BUT the islands?

[1] http://www.staff.city.ac.uk/p.willetts/SAC/OP/OP14UPDT.HTM

[2] http://www.staff.city.ac.uk/p.willetts/SAC/IMAGES/ARG-CNSH.J...

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by quirkafleeg on Monday May 08, 2017 @04:07PM (#14295098)
> 1825, Great Britain admitted Argentina's independence from Spain, but didn't claim the islands.

They claimed the Falkland Islands before Argentina even existed as an independent country, as I said in my post. They didn't have to make a new claim every time they recognized a new country.

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Monday May 08, 2017 @09:51PM (#14297184)
Also, you didn't address the continental shelf bit of evidence.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by quirkafleeg on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @05:09AM (#14298619)
"Evidence" of what? A line drawn by Argentina around territory they want to take over? I'm going to assume you're kidding.

a) anyone can claim any territory they like; that doesn't automatically make the claim legitimate or credible

b) claiming a territory is academic unless you can actually enforce your claim

c) Britain claimed the Falklands (decades) before "Argentina" even existed in any form as an independent country

d) if a "British" claim and presence on islands with no native population is illegitimate, what does that make a "Spanish" claim and presence on land taken from the native population that is now called "Argentina"?

Maybe the people of the Falklands are going home when the people of Argentina do.

> No, they did not claim it before that year.

https://www.google.com/search?q=1765+falklands+claim

https://www.google.com/search?q=argentine+independence

Even after so-called "Argentine independence" - half a century after Britain claimed the Falklands - "Argentina" didn't exist even remotely like the country we know today.

In fact even by 1865 - 100 YEARS after the British claimed the Falklands, and 15 years after "Argentina" relinquished claims in the treaty of Arana Southern - this is what "Argentina" looked like:

http://www.davidrumsey.com/luna/servlet/detail/RUMSEY~8~1~21...

So who do the British owe the Falklands to again? Buenos Aires? United Provinces of the River Plate? Argentine Confederation? Chile? Uruguay? Araucania and Patagonia? Spain?

Tell me again the one about returning stolen land.

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @03:52PM (#14303261)
Oh, so your argument is that the country changed. Big deal.

Again: Spain asserted sovereignity over those islands as part of the colony way before that.

The "line drawn by Argentina" is the territory accepted by the UN. That little organization where all the countries are represented. I understand from what you say that you favor the rule of the strongest instead of the actual law and common sense, but it's something real and concrete: the Argentinean sea surrounds the islands, and it's been proved to be a part of the country. The UK has absolutely NOTHING to do there, as their country is on the other hemisphere.

I'll reply to the rest of the "arguments" as you so call them, about the "claims" they did. I need to retrieve some information from the library first, so I can give you some proper references, instead of Google, as you did. Maybe that way you can learn something.

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by quirkafleeg on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @02:02PM (#14310212)
This is going to go absolutely nowhere other than me repeating the same hard facts and you refusing to hear and accept them, but I'll just address this:

> The "line drawn by Argentina" is the territory accepted by the UN.

Do you not even understand what's written in the link you posted as "evidence" or something?

The very first sentences state (emphasis/capitalization mine):

    "The Argentine Foreign Ministry announced on 28 March 2016 that it
     had gained international recognition of a claim to an exceptionally
     large continental shelf. 
  
     BUT THEY WERE MISTAKEN.

     [...]

     On 23 May 2016, the [UN] Commission made public its recommendations
     and ONLY A SMALL PROPORTION OF THE ARGENTINE CLAIM WAS ENDORSED.

     This paper explains the legal regime and the political process 
     that led the Commission to REFUSE TO CONSIDER THE ARGENTINE CLAIM
     TO THE SHELF AROUND THE ISLANDS CONTROLLED BY THE UNITED KINGDOM,
     AND TO A PART OF ANTARCTICA. 
And, after citing Argentine government lies on the matter, and fake news reports from Argentina and the UK, it concludes with the following:

     the Argentine Foreign Ministry knew NO PART OF THE CONTINENTAL 
     SHELF AROUND THE ISLANDS UNDER BRITISH CONTROL WOULD BE CONSIDERED
     by the sub-commission.

     [...] 

     Indeed, the legal situation was so unambiguous that THE ARGENTINE 
     DELEGATION DID NOT EVEN ASK FOR THE FULL SUBMISSION TO BE CONSIDERED.
You literally, objectively, as a matter of fact don't know what you are talking about here.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @03:55PM (#14303286)
Just for the record: you're defending an imperial colony in the 21st century, that exists for the sole purpose of having a claim for the UK over Antartida. That's it. That's the whole point of the UK being there. Of course the oil and fish are a plus, but if those islands were closer to Brazil, they would've left a long time ago.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by quirkafleeg on Wednesday May 10, 2017 @02:32PM (#14310452)
> Just for the record: you're defending an imperial colony in the 21st century

It's almost as if you didn't post this (in the 21st century) as an argument for an Argentine take over of the Falklands:

"Again: Spain asserted sovereignity over those islands as part of the colony way before that."

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Monday May 08, 2017 @09:48PM (#14297166)
No, they did not claim it before that year.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by bulutsuzku on Monday May 08, 2017 @01:09AM (#14289388)
British still seem to believe they are legit in the Islands. It is actually an occupation since 1833.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by PhilWright on Monday May 08, 2017 @01:53AM (#14289527)
You know what they say, possession is 9/10 tenths of the law!

Besides, it is kind of difficult to decide who really owns any land when you look back through the long and complicated history of just about any modern country. Who should own Argentina? It used force to separate itself from Spain, so should Spain still have a claim over it? Should they demand it back again? How did Spain get it in the first place? By conquering the place, which means it was stolen from the natives. Should the descendants of the natives claim it back? But then the natives no doubt were made up of tribes/groups that used force to change ownership. So are you going to work that out backwards to the first tribe to arrive in the area many thousands of years ago? Where do you draw the line? Given the complexity you pretty much end up with the fairest method being to ask the actual inhabitants who they want to govern them. They said they want the British.

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Monday May 08, 2017 @01:22PM (#14293623)
Nop, you're just mudding the discussion. Here are the facts:

- Spain named several governors for those islands from 1774 to 1810. Sovereignity was clearly stated by Spain over those islands.

- During that time, those islands depended of Buenos Aires government.

- If Spain owned Argentina plus the Malvinas, then once Argentina got its independence from Spain, the Malvinas were included as part of that independence.

- 1820, frigate La Heroína sailed to Malvinas to take possesion of it

- 1825, Great Britain admitted Argentina's independence from Spain, but didn't claim the islands.

- 1828, Buenos Aires government granted Port Soledad to Luis Vernet, for building up a colony. For this purpose, he shipped 100 inhabitants to the islands.

- 1829, Vernet was named as governor of the islands

- 1833, Great Britain took the Malvinas, and expelled the inhabitants from the islands.

Not to mention other facts like geology, and that the UN approved the new map for Argentina, which expands the continental shelf all around the islands.[1][2]

So, care to tell me how can Argentina OWN all the argentinean sea shelf AROUND the islands, BUT the islands?

[1] http://www.staff.city.ac.uk/p.willetts/SAC/OP/OP14UPDT.HTM

[2] http://www.staff.city.ac.uk/p.willetts/SAC/IMAGES/ARG-CNSH.J...

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by avar on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @04:48AM (#14298559)

    > So, care to tell me how can Argentina OWN
    > all the argentinean sea shelf AROUND the
    > islands, BUT the islands?
The map you're linking to shows Argentina claiming much of the Antarctic. Leaving the Falklands aside, it should be obvious that a map like this is rather one sided and certainly doesn't have any international recognition given that no sovereign claim over the Antarctic is recognized by the UN or anyone else.

Aside from that I think you're misunderstanding what this map means. There's an international convention on continental shelves but national sovereignty supersedes it. There's no rule that if your continental shelf intersects territory intersects some island you own that island.

If it did then China would own Taiwan, France / Belgium / The Netherlands & Norway would own the British isles, South Korea would own Japan etc.

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by PhilWright on Monday May 08, 2017 @06:53PM (#14296373)
We should ignore the wishes of all the people that live their, speak English and identify as British. Sounds reasonable to me.

</sarcasm>

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Monday May 08, 2017 @09:53PM (#14297193)
I don't want to ignore them. I just want them to remain british in Britain, and leave my country were they reside without our approval.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by tjalfi on Monday May 08, 2017 @01:13AM (#14289401)
99.8% of residents voted to remain a UK Overseas Territory in 2013[0]. If that's an occupation then it has pretty overwhelming popular support.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falkland_Islands_sovereignty_r...

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Monday May 08, 2017 @01:24PM (#14293635)
Well, if I take all my friends to your house, kick you out of it, and we all vote it's ours, we can keep it then?
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by fmmseptiembre on Monday May 08, 2017 @01:42AM (#14289492)
What could be expected? Most local population on Malvinas these days is of British origin.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by int_19h on Monday May 08, 2017 @02:21AM (#14289628)
Most local population on Falklands has been of British origin since, what, 1840?

Ultimately, the important part is that there are no living people, whether on the islands or elsewhere, who are harmed by British control of the island, and there are plenty of living people who would be harmed by it being ceded to Argentine.

Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by throwanem on Monday May 08, 2017 @06:15AM (#14290438)
Really, the important part is that Argentina lost the war. But I get that people need to blow off steam about that sort of thing from time to time - there's something humiliating in losing a fight you started, especially when your opponent, basically just for the hell of it, sinks the severely superannuated secondhand light cruiser that's the pride of your nation's adorable little pocket navy. Why take it seriously? The result that matters is in. All the rest is just woofing.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Monday May 08, 2017 @01:25PM (#14293652)
All argentineans are harmed. We're being plundered from our natural resources by the UK.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by int_19h on Monday May 08, 2017 @02:10PM (#14294079)
If we're unwinding back almost 200 years to reach that conclusion, why not go 600? Have you appropriately compensated the native Argentinian tribes for the natural resources that you have plundered from them?
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by mrleinad on Monday May 08, 2017 @09:55PM (#14297204)
We're talking about modern countries, not prehistoric societies. Please try to keep up.
Re:Falklands minefields: de facto nature reserves for penguins by int_19h on Tuesday May 09, 2017 @01:54AM (#14298004)
We are? Do people in "prehistoric societies" (whatever that is supposed to mean) not have rights to territory, or to natural resources?

In any case, I was definitely talking about people, not countries - this is clearly spelled out in the comment that started this thread. I don't care about countries. They only exist to serve the people, and any such rights they claim above and beyond that are illegitimate.