The main allure to Nix/Guix is to be used for the internals of an OS. For example, NixOS is the most stable and maintainable system I have ever used, even though the documentation is absolute shit.
The reason I haven't is that NixOS is just so damn comfortable that I don't want to leave.
Guix devs themselves have hinted that "adding impurity to a free OS is much easier than removing impurity from a non-free OS", so I suspect they may not be categorically opposed to the idea of non-free packages.
It's so easy.
When I upgrade or (un)install a package, I get a completely clean fresh installed system. If upgrading my video driver broke my system, I can just pick the most recent version of my install from the bootloader. When I want to start writing code, I can use nix-shell to create an isolated environment with all the dependencies I need, and get to work, with one command.
At any moment, I know that my entire OS install is completely clean, devoid of any cruft, even if I have been installing and removing obscure software for months. I don't have a mess in /etc, in /usr/share, anywhere.
> I'm not reinstalling my OS regularly so I don't really see the advantage.
With NixOS, I'm never reinstalling my OS, because every update leaves me with a fresh new system, guaranteed.
Maybe you are confusing state mutations with fixed points, which are used extensively (thankfully).
https://www.gnu.org/software/guix/download/
Essentially, all the benefits touted above apply here, but it is worth noting that Guix is a younger project. The author was originally a Nix dev, but found the DSL to be too awkward to use in practice, and opted to use Scheme through and through. Yes, Emacs bindings are available.
Also, Guix can now produce Dockerfiles, if that floats your boat:
https://www.gnu.org/software/guix/news/creating-bundles-with...