Of course you are condensing. Those small VMs would have been running a full OS runtime each.
Assuming you relocate those workloads onto a single machine (1 process = 1 container), you no longer run 20-30 copies of an OS, just a single one.
And the container engine takes the place of the hypervisor.
That's something but probably not as much as you think since hypervisors can share identical pages (e.g. the Linux kernel) across guests and the base footprint for a server Linux install is not that high as a percentage of the private data most applications use. Unless you're running a ton of unnecessary services on those guests or have an application which uses almost no RAM you're talking about a fairly modest percentage savings even before you factor in all of the things you might be running for container management and other overhead on that side.
The other thing to remember is that this works both ways: containers are great for being able to upgrade one component independently but that means that e.g. you might have a dozen different versions of a common shared library because not all of your containers are using the same base image & version and with Docker your storage driver might actually force shared libraries to be duplicated across all processes anyway.
With ASLR, I'm now sure the gains are that substantial.
Or, to put that another way: the host memory for most modern hypervisors consists of a heap of "new" pages, and then a generational garbage collector that moves said pages, if still alive, into a content-addressible "old" store.
As such, if two VMs each have a process that
1. calls malloc() 1000 times to get 1000 1-page buffers randomly spaced through their memory, the mappings different for each VM; and then
2. uses a fixed PRNG seed to generate random data [but the same random data] to fill those pages;
then those two processes' pages will still get collapsed together for a 50% savings.
Everything else is mapped onto the single Linux kernel, and many pages are shared as a result; I think that even libs are able to be shared across VMs; so if you had 2 identical versions of glibc in 2 VMs, only 1 would be loaded and used.
1. "application containers" are effectively a single process [though that can fork more] with some kernel process-struct fields set to nonzero values, indicating that the kernel should present this process a different view of its environment.
2. "virtual machines" are the processor providing a separate virtualized view of the CPU, on which is then booted another virtualized kernel, which brings up with it virtualized OS services and eventually an app.
3. Between them, "OS containers" are a hybrid: they start up all the userland virtualized OS services that a VM does, but they do so on top of a kernel that's not actually a fresh, separate kernel; but instead a kernel that has been told (through setting tons of containerization process flags) to present to this group of processes a view of the world where this kernel looks like a fresh kernel in a newly-started VM.
"OS containers" are basically a raw optimization over VMs by asking one kernel to pretend to be multiple kernels, and to manage one pool of memory instead of having multiple pools of memory. Anything you can do with raw VMs, you should (in theory, given good inter-container isolation+quota logic) be able to do with OS containers as well.
You might be dismissing microservices too quickly. They do have overhead but so does any level of abstract; the benefit of them though is clear separation of responsibilities between services and residency(Swarms, clusters, etc). Both can be achieved with Vms but VMs weren't built with these goals in mind
I'm not sure the toaster analogy will gain mass acceptance.
When Docker can safely protect a Minecraft server in one container from a local DoS attack coming from a bot running in a sibling container, I'll reconsider using VMs. :P
containers bundled up libs and binaries in a single package, only for an "app" to come reliant on a zoo of containers doing one little part of the whole.
Makes one wonder if the stack is made of rabbits rather than turtles...
I'm starting to believe that the increased density provided by containerization is a myth, in practice. Both because orchestration tools bring their own overhead (compare all the proxies and filesystem/network overlays with multiple virtualized kernels) but also because containerization goes hand-in-hand with microservices thus increasing the number of components (often times with no real reason other than to be hip).
If you're running 20-30 containers on a beefy VM, you're not really condensing anything. You're just moving from running hundreds of small VMs on a single server to running much less larger VMs.