News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by norikki on Saturday April 29, 2017 @11:53AM (#14227111)
First listed reason for inequality in America according to The Atlantic: Slavery. Good to know what political slant they bring to the table.
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by alexc05 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:09PM (#14227195)
I really think these articles are important to read. I still think about and reference Ta-nehisi Coats' article "the case for reparations" https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-cas...

He makes a strong point.

Now, I'm a white guy, my father owned a small business after selling his scanning electron microscope company to a bigger player. He paid for my University education outright including rent. I had to work for any spending money I wanted, but I basically had a free ride into my current programming job.

A poor black kid living in a high-violent-crime area who is the child of a minimum-wage-working single mother, is not going to have the same chances.

If he gets caught underage by cops with a six pack of beers or a jar of mixed hard-alchohol stolen from a liquor cabinet, or good forbid enough marijuana for a joint, he's not going to be able to rely on his parents' to hire the lawyer to get those charges removed.

This is (according to this article and others) traceable in a large part back to slavery. But it also comes from gererational poverty. Lack of parental resources leading to malnutrition, which leads to inattention in school, parental long hours at work leads to a lack of attention and corrective feedback. Or the parents are addicted to something and modelling bad behavior to begin with.

The child in these cases starts innocent and realistically has an infantessemal chance of success.

The solution is for government programs to tax me and people like me to provide simple things that can help break the cycle of poverty.

Free breakfast and lunch for kids, raise minimum wage, etc...

The Palmer Luckey's of the world have to catch on to just how fucking privileged they are as middle class white kids.

These articles don't deserve to be rejected outright under "bias" they're based on real solid research.

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by teslabox on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:28PM (#14227290)
> The solution is for government programs to tax me and people like me to provide simple things that can help break the cycle of poverty.

It'd be even better to end institutionalized racism, institute a mass pardon program, and pay reparations to the victims of Nixon's stupid escalation of the war on plants:

  At the time [1994], I was writing a book 
  about the politics of drug prohibition. I 
  started to ask Ehrlichman a series of 
  earnest, wonky questions that he impatiently 
  waved away. “You want to know what this was 
  really all about?” he asked with the 
  bluntness of a man who, after public disgrace 
  and a stretch in federal prison, had little 
  left to protect. “The Nixon campaign in 1968, 
  and the Nixon White House after that, had two 
  enemies: the antiwar left and black people. 
  You understand what I’m saying? We knew we 
  couldn’t make it illegal to be either against 
  the war or black, but by getting the public 
  to associate the hippies with marijuana and 
  blacks with heroin, and then criminalizing 
  both heavily, we could disrupt those 
  communities. We could arrest their leaders, 
  raid their homes, break up their meetings, 
  and vilify them night after night on the 
  evening news. Did we know we were lying about 
  the drugs? Of course we did.”
- Legalize It All: How to win the war on drugs, http://harpers.org/archive/2016/04/legalize-it-all/ https://web-beta.archive.org/web/20160323102916/http://harpe...

edit: John Taylor Gatto [1] points out in one of his books that black families were pretty stable post-civil-war, until the governments started sending black men to prison for teh ganja. Children do better when they have a father around.

[1] https://www.JohnTaylorGatto.com/

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by alexc05 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:38PM (#14227702)
I miss-wrote. It sounded like I thought there was ONE solution required. Clearly you have a point and there is far more to the story and there isn't any reason I can think of why you wouldn't be able to do both of these and more.
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by chongli on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:53PM (#14227444)
It's a red queen's race. On the one hand you can give free lunches to kids who don't have enough to eat. You put together a volunteer after-school study group to help the kids get their grades up. Meanwhile, the rich kid has private tutors coaching him on SAT prep for several years, he belongs to multiple extracurricular clubs, maybe he gets a summer internship at a Cravath System style law firm or a job as a page in Washington, maybe he wins a medal at the International Math Olympiad...

We're not going to solve inequality by nudging people up from the bottom. We've gotta tackle the elephant in the room: capital pays more and capital is easier to move around than labour. That's all there is to it.

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by phil21 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:50PM (#14227419)
> If he gets caught underage by cops with a six pack of beers or a jar of mixed hard-alchohol stolen from a liquor cabinet, or good forbid enough marijuana for a joint, he's not going to be able to rely on his parents' to hire the lawyer to get those charges removed.

I'm curious if you've ever lived in these areas and had friends that fit the description of your comment.

I think you'll find that inner city kids get just as many breaks as suburban white kids. You'd have a point if it was the black ghetto kid in the suburbs being caught at a party - but within the city environment absolutely no way. The kids who got in trouble for that stuff growing up were on their 14th chance.

I lived in such a neighborhood and had local friends growing up. It took a lot to get arrested for something as simple as a joint. You were generally well known as a troublemaker by then, and rightfully so.

The typical response to those issues was dumping out the liquor/drugs and telling the kid to go home unless he was a known problem, in which case yeah - the cops used broken window policing to get them off the streets.

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by sprafa on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:41PM (#14227711)
Inner city kids have as many chances as suburban white kids ? What city is this?
[dead]
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by curun1r on Saturday April 29, 2017 @03:06PM (#14228168)
My mother is a child psychologist who works primarily with victims of crime and, overwhelmingly, African-Americans. She's come to the conclusion that there are specific parenting faults that you find in the African-American population that you don't find in other similarly-impoverished populations and she believes that they're a legacy of slavery. Parenting abilities/tendencies/techniques are all passed down through the generations. We, as humans, learn our parenting by being parented. But, too often during slavery, this chain was broken. Children were ripped away from their parents and that accumulation of parenting practice was lost.

Since involved parents are the single biggest determining factor in educational outcomes and education is the surest way out of poverty, this legacy of slavery rings the most true to me as the explanation for why African-Americans find it so much harder to break out of the cycle of poverty than other minority groups.

Perhaps the best group to compare with are more recent immigrants from Africa. I have a number of friends who's parents came to the US from Nigeria, South Africa and Zambia. They had very little when they arrived here and have the same skin color which is purported to be such a disadvantage to the African-American​ population. And while they've universally told me that they have experienced discrimination and prejudice, they've also not had much difficulty lifting themselves out of poverty by the second generation.

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by alexc05 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:35PM (#14227689)
Well, not precisely, he was a single dad as well. But I take your point, along with another commenter who says "mass pardon program" (which one would expect to have the effect of bringing some fathers home)

Maybe it's a case of yes, and.

I'm certainly a little embarrassed for making it sound like I knew one solution would fix it. I definitely meant "among other things"

Overall the situation is pretty fucked. There will have to be more than one solution all pointing towards the same goal.

I don't agree that there has been 60 years of a failed taxation experiment. In fact from the 30's to the 80's the middle class grew massively​ which was a period of high taxation, while from about '85 to now, under voodoo trickle down, we've seen massive GDP growth but virtually none of those gains going to the middle class.

We really need to increase the amount of support in the social network​.

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by maxerickson on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:40PM (#14227354)
It's a good thing it was such a nice tidy experiment, with perfectly designed programs providing assistance and no other factors in play at all.
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by josho on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:53PM (#14227441)
Your comment is being downvoted because you dismiss the article based on the first sentence and offer no specific criticism. We can do better than that here.
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by r00fus on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:06PM (#14227520)
I'd also say the comment is being downvoted for mentioning rational, on-topic facts as "political slant".
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by loeg on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:02PM (#14227162)
Can you explain how Slavery represents a political slant? Are facts political now?
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by AckSyn on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:08PM (#14227190)
Facts that are so old that they have no resemblance of any reasonable basis of someone's current situation should be called out for being political.
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by cmurf on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:33PM (#14227683)
Because you're not arguing facts, by ignoring them if not flat out suggesting they don't exist in the present time, what you've written is worthy of legitimate ad hominem attack. And that's because the problem is with you, the person. You are a deeply ignorant and foolish person - whether it's malice or not I cannot say. But it is damaging to your personal credibility and is damaging to discourse by speaking mistruth.

Jim Crow laws are from 1965, they directly connect to this country's history of slavery. That is not "so old" at all. And variations of Jim Crow laws still persist to this day, hence the Voting Rights Acts. That there are clever derivatives of these practices does not at all mean "they are so old they have no resemblance of". Yes foolish person, they do have resemblance of.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/pasadena-texas-voting-ri...

For some book ideas so you can work on your ignorance of this present day relevant history: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/03/16/books/review/chris-hayes-...

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by pikzen on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:22PM (#14227257)
Facts that have affected generations and driven a part of your population to the lowest levels are, indeed, political. Especially if they point out facts you don't like.

Aree you going to say the same thing about Jim Crow laws? There has been a systematic will to enslave and degrade black people in America, and this is a continuing effort.

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by AckSyn on Saturday April 29, 2017 @05:05PM (#14228742)
> There has been a systematic will to enslave and degrade black people in America, and this is a continuing effort.

Are you mad, or are you posting from the wrong century?

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by pikzen on Sunday April 30, 2017 @07:04AM (#14230985)
I am posting from the century where, for example, the war on drugs is still a thing, which affects black communities more. I'm posting from the century where an African American will get a harsher sentence than a white person, for the same offence or crime.

Reality is tough, huh?

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by yardie on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:30PM (#14227295)
Indeed. It began with slavery and stayed with us in various forms of oppression up to and including today. But America is great so we're going to take it back to Jim Crow.
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by cmurf on Saturday April 29, 2017 @01:16PM (#14227570)
How is this a political slant?

If you want to refine the cause of inequality, that's fair, but on the face of it, calling it political and somehow therefore invalid or a weak argument, is itself weak and invalid.

I'd refine it by saying the reason is when exploitation is considered valid and moral, it exists for a purpose. It is OK to select your targets, where you gain and they lose, if they don't stop you. It's finders keepers losers weepers. It's a game of might makes right. You either agree that there are superior people with superior ideas and it's morally OK to exploit others, or you don't. But I consider exploitation the superset cause of inequality.

The specific instance of this exploitation in American history has been various kinds of servitude, varying from targeting races (African, Chinese, Irish, Italian). And even today there's exploitation that's class based: trying to make public institutions in a democratic tradition a pay for play, or privatized. Justice, education, privacy - these are products to be paid for, and if you can't pay, you get none or you get lower quality versions.

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by aphextron on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:04PM (#14227172)
How exactly is this a political slant? Slavery is directly responsible for the mass genocide and economic subjugation of African Americans for the past two centuries. Beyond that, it set the stage for the civil war, which crystallized the economic disparity between north and south forever.
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by sctb on Sunday April 30, 2017 @03:09PM (#14233282)
> Please avoid introducing classic flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say about them.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by LyndsySimon on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:02PM (#14227163)
Oh, it gets better: "Temin advocates doing away with the belief that private agencies can act in the interest of all citizens in the way that public entities can, and should"
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by Applejinx on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:22PM (#14227253)
Makes sense to me. Private agencies must act in the interest of themselves in a fiduciary sense, even outside of market forces.

Once you involve market forces, and worse, the issuing of stock leading to ownership by a class that demands immediate returns of money for their investment, private agencies are seemingly required to screw over citizens, because that's how you extract money from them in large quantities.

Contrasted to that, the bureaucracy of public entities is a much more insignificant problem. Public internet might be sort of 'third world', but right now they are kicking our butts in that, and Comcast might be working hard (meh…) but they are not working for you, they are working to extract capital out of you in the most efficient manner possible.

Once you include the caveat of 'all citizens' (even in Podunkville) it's not even an argument anymore. There's an assumption that it's right and proper to hose Podunkville because they're not the big city and shouldn't have nice things if their productivity doesn't warrant it, and this assumption is fair to challenge or even contradict outright. I'm rooting for Podunkville (the big city doesn't need my ideological help) so I'm in favor of public entities.

I guess we'll be seeing some experimentation, in that we're likely to see a heavy swing to privatization right now, and most likely a counter-swing in four to eight years. Should be worth keeping track of how it all works. That 'all citizens', though, that's a conditional which is at the heart of the discussion.

Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by greggyb on Saturday April 29, 2017 @12:41PM (#14227358)
Private != for-profit. Perhaps you realize this, but it does not seem clear in your post.
Re:Economic Mobility Requires the Nearly Impossible by scarface74 on Saturday April 29, 2017 @02:46PM (#14228060)
The distinction between private for profit and not for profit is a distinction without a difference. It just means that outside shareholders aren't making money, but you'll find that stakeholders in a lot of not for profit companies are just as interested in making money as for profits. The stakeholder are often just the employees.