Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by zaphar on Thursday April 27, 2017 @06:29PM
(#14215345)
It's all the more interesting because Google makes it ridiculously easy to ask for that permission and get a legally unambiguous go or no go for any side projects. It's not like this would have been murky waters.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by ChuckMcM on Thursday April 27, 2017 @06:42PM
(#14215430)
there was a joke posting on an internal alias that showed the internal /etc/aliases file for Google which had the mailing list going to '|/usr/bin/no'[1] :) I would be interested to know if anyone still there had ever tried that and gotten a yes answer. The three times I used the process it was always denied.
[1] To understand the meta-joke there is actually a /usr/bin/yes program but in the standard distribution there isn't a /usr/bin/no :-)
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by zaphar on Thursday April 27, 2017 @07:11PM
(#14215624)
I've never seen anyone get a yes for money making side projects. For Open Source projects which uses a slightly different process I've seen people get permission to do them without an explicit CLA.
It's pretty hard to find something on the internet or in commerce that isn't somehow competing with Google.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by Tyr42 on Friday April 28, 2017 @08:57AM
(#14218977)
My co-worker worked on some games to sell on the android play market.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by raphlinus on Thursday April 27, 2017 @08:29PM
(#14215992)
From Google's official opensource documentation on IARC[0]: We don’t approve every project submitted through this process, but historically we’ve been able to rapidly approve the vast majority of them.
I personally have had one IARC approved and one denied (and something like a dozen opensource launches), but from what I've seen, the above statement is accurate.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by ChuckMcM on Thursday April 27, 2017 @08:57PM
(#14216129)
Open source yes, but if it might earn you a bit of coin, then generally no.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by tdeck on Friday April 28, 2017 @01:19AM
(#14217025)
I work at Google and had a proprietary side project approved despite explicitly stating that I might make money from it. It's not a billion dollar idea or anything, but they didn't automatically say no. Meanwhile a tiny open source project I wanted to keep maintaining got denied rather rudely. I don't understand the process, but it is possible to get an approval. However the fact that you are supposed to ask for an approval to live your own life in your free time does kind of suck the soul out of it.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by ChuckMcM on Friday April 28, 2017 @02:31AM
(#14217280)
Excellent! It is nice to know that it is at least possible to get some things approved.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 27, 2017 @06:48PM
(#14215474)
Calling
/usr/bin/yes no
will yield you a working "no" program :).
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by jacquesm on Thursday April 27, 2017 @06:52PM
(#14215496)
I'm disappointed that symlinking to 'no' still produces 'y' when called. Oh well, that'll have to be an alias then.
Also, /usr/bin/yes will echo anything you give it.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by bobsil1 on Thursday April 27, 2017 @06:58PM
(#14215550)
Ah, the Indian head wobble.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by DonHopkins on Friday April 28, 2017 @05:50AM
(#14218108)
If by working you mean an infinite stream of "no"'s. Can google's email servers handle that, or do they need to bring back Google Wave to deliver an infinite stream of "no"'s in realtime, one keypress at a time? Or can they map/reduce an infinite stream of "no"'s into a single "no"?
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by joshuamorton on Friday April 28, 2017 @02:57AM
(#14217398)
I know of someone who got an explicit yes, but the project was a toy and didn't really require it.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by jacquesm on Thursday April 27, 2017 @06:30PM
(#14215351)
And it's also fairly clear that this would have been a 'no'.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by sriram_sun on Thursday April 27, 2017 @06:07PM
(#14215189)
Consider Google's investment in Uber! "The $258 million is an 86 percent chunk of Google Ventures’ $300 million dollar a year fund, and it’s unclear whether the firm will continue to make such sizable investments." - https://techcrunch.com/2013/08/22/google-ventures-puts-258m-...
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by jacquesm on Thursday April 27, 2017 @06:22PM
(#14215291)
Uber could really play that to their advantage: "Your Honor, Google is just trying to soften us up because they don't get their way in the boardroom..."
Having two roles in a lawsuit is a very dangerous thing, no matter how much their ex employee is at fault here they could easily make a lot of smoke out of that.
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by notatoad on Thursday April 27, 2017 @07:55PM
(#14215851)
How does that actually play out? Google Ventures and Google's self-driving car were both "Google" when that investment was made, but now Waymo and GV are ostensibly separate entities. Is Alphabet suing Uber, or is Waymo suing Uber?
Re:Uber’s Anthony Levandowski out as Advanced Technologies l...
by linkregister on Thursday April 27, 2017 @08:16PM
(#14215939)
Waymo is a wholly-owned subsidiary; there's not going to be much distinction here. Not that I agree with the parent poster: the equity ownership is unlikely to be relevant to the case. People have successfully sued their own corporations and other bizarre legal actions.
Challenging times indeed.