Just because something is old does not mean it is worse, and just because something is new it does not mean it is better.
If you think about it, the modern languages are clearly made for programming higher on the stack (i.e., at application level). That makes a lot of sense. After all most programming is done at the application level, and it would make sense to write a language that makes that type of programming easier. And of course many modern languages are very successful in that respect. But it is silly to assume that just because they are successful at the application level they would make good kernel programming languages.
The reason why C++ is the language being considered is that it is also a relatively low level language which means that it can potentially replace C for kernel level programming. That of course does not mean that it should, and Linus does a good job of pointing out the issues with C++.
Not true. You just have to be smart enough to implement the stack and structure properly. Have a look at some of the experimental operating systems out there. Singularity is especially worth a look.
Lots of people write lots of kernels in lots of languages. I have some (small) contributions to one in D, for example. While still explicitly a systems language, there's still lots of room for people to write kernels in whatever they want.
When you created a lisp machine, it was a lisp machine - everyone knew why and how you did it (to some extent). If you wanted to run it, you ported "the program" to it and all was good. Right now you have users expecting at least the stuff they can get from other popular systems - and that's years of work away for any new project.
The best you can probably do, as far as "progress" goes is to create a new research system and port the good stuff back to mainstream (singularity, plan9, etc.)
To some extent we know all there is to know right now... New languages, periferials, usage ideas are still created. But for a new system language you need to either create or port a system and gather some followers. That's a big step.
Edit: Actually I believe that there's a new hardware change coming that will make current computers ineffective in some way. We could switch to new hardware, new languages, new systems... we could start from scratch :) I don't believe the current ways of parallelising computation can do that.. but if someone constructs a concurrent bus/memory/cpu that could invalidate some of the normal programming ideas.
See, even though Joe Blow may use Windows, he still uses Linux when he Googles. The web allows people to not have to worry about what OS the servers are running... so I think there's lots of room for innovation on the OS front, but on the server side of the cloud.
But C++ is not the answer here. It wants to be all things to everyone (low-level, high-level, object-oriented, functional, etc, etc) and is therefore useful for almost every kind of project but well matched to none of them.
Also, there is nothing wrong with programming paradigms from the 60s as evidenced by the popularity of Clojure and other functional languages that borrow heavily from LISP.
This is before you even get into things like the template-y standard C++ library.
Blatantly plagarized from: http://www.cvaieee.org/html/humor/programming_history.html
He ends with: "But C++? I really don't think the "good features" of it are very good at all. If you leave C behind, do it properly and get some real features that matter. GC, some concurrency support, dynamic code generation, whatever."
(disclaimer: I work on a VCS that's written in C++ and uses a real database, nice object-oriented libraries, and nice C++ abstractions :)
In git, branches are not a special entity. They are a property of the contents of the repository. The commits form a DAG, which is also a tree, and trees often have branches. A repository might have dozens of branch points that are never referenced by name, but that doesn't mean they don't exist.
You can even consider the whole set of repositories for a single project as forming a logical DAG in this manner. However, because of the distributed nature of git, there will be branches that are not visible to you.
Given this, what does it mean to somehow "separate" the concept of repositories from branches?
I tend to think of a branch more as "a buch of commits that go together", which seems to fit very nicely with common usage where you have a release branch, dev branch, etc. It just seems very bizzare that people working on the "dev branch" are actually working on entirely separate branches just because they're in different offices which use separate local mirrors in case the internet breaks.
The distributed nature of git (and any DVCS) means developers on the 'dev branch' are working on different branches, even if they all call it 'dev' in their local repositories. Their local development may have started from the same parent, but it's not the same branch. If you send the commits to someone else, they'll be completely separate from the receiver's dev branch until merged.
It seems to me that your idea of the "dev branch" is in git a purely non-technical thing. That is, a branch in some blessed repository that points to the so-far merged efforts of all the developers' dev branches, representing 'current' development.
I think this is a good thing, and I'm yet to be convinced otherwise.
Wait, you can't just write that and end your comment! What VCS do you work on?, if you're at liberty to share.
MS created Vista using 2000s paradigm. It was slow as a snail.
Experiments could fail too.
Do you terribly mind elaborating on this rather bold statement?
> Linux will never evolve if the programming paradigm stays in the 60s
C is a great language, but I firmly believe that OOP creates more maintainable code that is more robust. Sure, a simple C program is easy to understand, but the kernel isn't an easy program. Don't get me wrong, C++ has major downsides, but C isn't a magic bullet.
NOTE: this is not me bragging, it's me suggesting the mystique is a bit undeserved.
I still think there is some art to writing simple, efficient code, though. Most system-level code looks quite simple when it's done, but it may have taken several iterations to get it fast, clean, and small enough (particularly on embedded devices -- I once had to find 200 spare bytes to fit a bug fix in a 256KB firmware by hand optimizing various ancient parts of the code base).
However, I always cringe when I read some of his comments that seem to reject any element of forward progress. While C++ certainly has its share of issues, Linux will never evolve if the programming paradigm stays in the 60s. My gut feel is there is a lot of opportunity to do better over the next ten years.