Re:New Evidence Suggests Humans Arrived in the Americas Earl...
by Balgair on Thursday April 27, 2017 @12:37PM
(#14212839)
Permanent populations are not a sign of civilization. Many religious sites today are sparsely populated except for once/twice a year, but we still have civilization. The Mongols were civilized even when they were raiding the entire old-world and establishing many dynasties. They had writing, religion, generals and well-organized armies, a bureaucracy, laws and customs, tariffs, etc, just not a single plot of land they went to sleep on every single night. Heck, even NYC doubles in population daily [0], those people may be daily commuter nomads, but they are 'civilized' people.
[0]https://cityroom.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/06/03/commuters-near...
Re:New Evidence Suggests Humans Arrived in the Americas Earl...
by simonh on Friday April 28, 2017 @07:10AM
(#14218438)
>Many religious sites today are sparsely populated except for once/twice a year, but we still have civilization
Yes, but we don't have civilization because of those religious sites.
Living permanently in the same place on a large scale is a completely different way of life compared to living a mainly nomadic life and gathering at special sites from time to time, even if you make a permanent mark on those sites.