Re:The Whale
by Upvoter33 on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:55PM
(#14205333)
I do agree Amazon is amazing and frightening all at once. However, I really hate all of this analysis based on market cap instead of revenue/profit/etc. It's just like so much fantasy.
Re:The Whale
by debacle on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @07:29PM
(#14207945)
I'm intrigued by the coming future of the megacorp. Philip K Dick wrote many stories where the giant corporation is the tribal, protect-our-own protagonist against the faceless, authoritarian government. Paycheck being the most memorable example. It's going to be interesting when companies don't even have to pretend to be subservient to the government anymore.
Re:The Whale
by fela on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @03:47PM
(#14206328)
The current stock price (and thus market cap) already assumes future growth. The market cap would increase further only if growth exceeds the current expectations of investors. (Or due to other factors unrelated to growth).
I'm curious on how Amazon will take the world. I can read and understand how the America buys a lot of stuff from it, how good the delivery is, etc., but in some countries they are barely beginning. And some local companies tried to do the same model and couldn't. They haven't bankrupted, but simply don't have the same size, same relevance as Amazon has in the US.
Re:The Whale
by nl on Thursday April 27, 2017 @02:41AM
(#14209650)
It's weird to see all the people here complaining about how the article is about the market cap, when that's not only what the article is about.
Sure, the market cap is interesting, but this is an interesting article because it makes a compelling case that a $400B company is cheap even when Walmart outsells it and FedEx out delivers.
It was only a few years ago people complained about how Amazon didn't make any profits because they would reinvest them all in growth, and how that was impossible to sustain that.
They were right, but not in the way they thought. It does seem to be impossible to keep investing all the profits in growth - they are just making too much!
So, it's the combination of this growth AND the market cap that is unprecedented. No one can tell if it is overvalued, but complaining about talking about the Cap is missing a pretty amazing story.
In my experience, the quality of Amazon is average at best. The only reason why they are winning is because they are cheap. The Walmart model basically: Cheap wins over quality.
Re:The Whale
by ng12 on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @05:01PM
(#14206955)
What is your metric for quality? Amazon sells almost everything I want at a good price and I have to spend minimal effort to get it -- sounds like a quality service to me.
Re:The Whale
by giarc on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @05:29PM
(#14207173)
I would argue it's not the Walmart model. Walmart's model is to have a store in every town in America. Amazon (outside of a few book stores and experimental stores) doesn't have a single brick and mortar business. Amazon's model is to 1. power the internet and 2. put a store in everyone's home through their phone/computer.
Re:The Whale
by exclusiv on Thursday April 27, 2017 @01:19AM
(#14209343)
Amazon does have brick and mortar stores - both bookstores and Amazon Go. Walmart's new model is to sell online, but they just aren't very good at it and I don't see Jet saving them.
Re:The Whale
by ethbro on Thursday April 27, 2017 @09:19AM
(#14211211)
Walmart has the Microsoft Office problem.
Anything that canabalizes physical store revenue is going to have to fight beauracratic headwinds. So while Walmart online may be necessary (in the same way Office 365 / on iOS & Android was), I don't have much faith on their being able to organizationally get there in a timely manner with sufficient resources.
Far more companies seem to recognize changing marketplaces and then botch business transitions by not being aggressive enough vs simply missing the changing marketplace signals.
Re:The Whale
by exclusiv on Thursday April 27, 2017 @05:29PM
(#14214869)
Perhaps that's the case right now. However, I was just pointing out that they do indeed have brick and mortar stores because the parent said they didn't have any.
Anyway, AWS was once a decimal point in their revenue too. In fact it's around 10% right now, but very important in terms of profit.
Re:The Whale
by exclusiv on Tuesday May 02, 2017 @11:10PM
(#14252721)
It did. You edited it. Then in your reply above you still remain stubborn with "for all intents and purposes". Amazon has brick and mortar and expanding it's part of their strategy. I'm not saying it's a big piece of their business right now. No need to adjust your statements semantically and go back and forth because you weren't accurate in your prior claim.
Furthermore - you said "Walmart's model is to have a store in every town in America". Amazon wants a piece of that $480 B in revenue too. You can't steal all of that revenue by only being online.
i don't think they are necessarily cheap. i buy from them because they are convenient and have everything. I only want one online shopping identity and even if toothpaste is more expensive there, i go ahead and get it over heading to the store many times.
Re:The Whale
by ethbro on Thursday April 27, 2017 @09:22AM
(#14211231)
On everything that isn't backed by a highly optimized logistics chain (e.g. groceries or appliances), they're always cheaper on any random item I've compared to a physical store.
Which makes sense, because the price difference is essentially the ammortized cost of a physical store.
Re:The Whale
by kolbe on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @05:08PM
(#14207017)
The author regularly conflates Amazon's price and Amazon's value. I understand articles like this getting traction on pump and dump finance forums, but I'm a little disappointed to see it on the front page here.
Just my opinion, but Amazon, FB, Apple, and all these companies that these thought leaders like MG Siegler, Stratchery, and Gruber write about aren't interesting.
They won at the same game by outcompeting others at selling commodity junk. Great. How? Same way. They had leaders whose business won the lottery and simultaneously didn't care about other humans to the same infinitesimally small way necessary to win that big (one can lose big with that give-no-f*cks mindset too, hence the lottery).
Selling crap isn't interesting. Show me somebody that makes a similar-sized dent in human health, the environment, or world peace then I think the fawning Medium articles will be worth it.
Re:The Whale
by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2017 @02:55AM
(#14209703)
>Just my opinion, but Amazon, FB, Apple, and all these companies that these thought leaders like MG Siegler, Stratchery, and Gruber write about aren't interesting.
They won at the same game by outcompeting others at selling commodity junk.
First of all, all 3 companies have very different business models.
Second, Apple never sold "commodity junk". The company sold (and sells) on the high end of the market, they take a different approach to design than competitors, use more expensive materials, machining, etc., design lots of their own internals (from logic board part to processors, even their own OS and programming languages, and create their products end to end (hardware to software), and come to market with lots of firsts (e.g. from small stuff like magsafe or the best trackpad in PC-land, to hi-dpi etc). And of course have won all kinds of design, quality awards.
Third, Facebook doesn't sell anything (except ads). What's the "commodity junk" they sell? Their service is junk? Compared to what? MySpace and similar competitors, whose websites were crap even at the time? What's the better social network people aren't on?
Fourth, Amazon? Has a first tier store, a first tier web service business. What's the commodity junk they sell? If you mean actual products on their store, then they sell everything, from expensive high end stuff to mass market cheap products. And of course, for ages, they started with books -- where there's nothing "commodity crap" about them, books are books, whether a high end bookstore sells them or Amazon does.
>Same way. They had leaders whose business won the lottery
If your explanation of 3 of the biggest companies on earth is "won the lottery" then you're missing a lot. Might a well invoke God.
>Selling crap isn't interesting. Show me somebody that makes a similar-sized dent in human health, the environment, or world peace then I think the fawning Medium articles will be worth it.
You conflate businesses with NGOs or revolutionary parties.
Which is a valid comparison for some aspects, but not one that can conclude that "businesses are not interesting" when speaking about business.
Think less literal please. High-end stuff is still junk on an absolute scale.
The marketcap and "I want it all"-scale don't make businesses interesting. What's interesting are things that can't be quantified well and therefore can't be competed on by hard work and assholery.
Re:The Whale
by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2017 @09:02AM
(#14211113)
>Think less literal please. High-end stuff is still junk on an absolute scale.
If you think "less literal" everything is "junk" compared to personal health and/or love.
>The marketcap and "I want it all"-scale don't make businesses interesting. What's interesting are things that can't be quantified well and therefore can't be competed on by hard work and assholery.
For your own definition of "interesting".
But Amazon, FP, Apple (and tons of other subjects) are still interesting if we use the common, agreed upon, dictionary, traditional definition of the term interesting: "arousing curiosity or interest; holding or catching the attention.".
And there's few things about Apple, FB, and Amazon's success stories that can be "quantified well", as their story and success goes beyond their financial status. How about why and how they succeeded?
Re:The Whale
by bsder on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @04:25PM
(#14206643)
Except that suddenly there are lots of people NOT buying at Amazon anymore.
In fact, most of my purchases go into 3 buckets:
1) Standard but I don't want crap--probably I'm going to a retailer website and picking it up (Target, Frys, etc. -- NewEgg is my exception to actually having brick and mortar). If I can pick it up, it's probably at least a notch or two above crap.
2) Total crap--probably ordering from Alibaba--not Amazon.
3) Something I need to go to a store for
To me, Amazon is being used decreasingly by everybody around me.
Re:The Whale
by ng12 on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @04:58PM
(#14206934)
While we're being anecdotal, I live in NYC and almost all of my purchases are done through Amazon -- the only exceptions are perishable goods and things I absolutely 100% need today.
Re:The Whale
by mastazi on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @07:10PM
(#14207844)
I'm not American so I was wondering: do Target and Frys sell higher quality products than Amazon? Where I live (Australia) those large stores sell absolute crap, and I have to rely on online sources for quality items (example: it's almost impossible to find a good mechanical keyboard at a physical, big-chain store).
Re:The Whale
by coldtea on Thursday April 27, 2017 @02:58AM
(#14209712)
>To me, Amazon is being used decreasingly by everybody around me.
Yeah, just not by anybody that actually affects their rising retail revenue.
I'm not even sure how this idea about "crap" works. If you order e.g. a Dell or an Apple laptop or a Sony camera or a WD HD or a Philips bulb etc, on Fry's or Best Buy etc, you'll get something different that if you order those on Amazon?
Revenue 2012 - $61B
Revenue 2016 - $136B
Income 2012 - $15B
Income 2016 - $48B
Don't forget that Amazon has 2x the market cap of Wal-Mart–but only slightly above 1/4 of their the annual revenue.
What they should really do is not rely on a single indicator.
There are many places where that has been happening for over a century...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_republic
Will that model still be applied worldwide?
Sure, the market cap is interesting, but this is an interesting article because it makes a compelling case that a $400B company is cheap even when Walmart outsells it and FedEx out delivers.
It was only a few years ago people complained about how Amazon didn't make any profits because they would reinvest them all in growth, and how that was impossible to sustain that.
They were right, but not in the way they thought. It does seem to be impossible to keep investing all the profits in growth - they are just making too much!
So, it's the combination of this growth AND the market cap that is unprecedented. No one can tell if it is overvalued, but complaining about talking about the Cap is missing a pretty amazing story.
I now live in australia, I really miss the website (they only sell e-books here so far).
http://www.news.com.au/finance/business/retail/amazon-launch...
If I were Gerry Harvey or Richard Murray (CEO of JB Hifi) - I'd be _very_ worried...
And both are totally irrelevant to their operation, and a decimal point in their revenue. They could close them tomorrow and nobody would care.
Whereas for Walmart their stores are essential to their operation.
Anything that canabalizes physical store revenue is going to have to fight beauracratic headwinds. So while Walmart online may be necessary (in the same way Office 365 / on iOS & Android was), I don't have much faith on their being able to organizationally get there in a timely manner with sufficient resources.
Far more companies seem to recognize changing marketplaces and then botch business transitions by not being aggressive enough vs simply missing the changing marketplace signals.
Anyway, AWS was once a decimal point in their revenue too. In fact it's around 10% right now, but very important in terms of profit.
Furthermore - you said "Walmart's model is to have a store in every town in America". Amazon wants a piece of that $480 B in revenue too. You can't steal all of that revenue by only being online.
Compared to what?
What e-shop has at least same level web experience, same level delivery, same level customer service, same breadth, same trust, etc, all together?
And don't mention some niche web store that sells like 1 item to enthusiasts, where the owner personally mails the products...
Which makes sense, because the price difference is essentially the ammortized cost of a physical store.
That's because the price is also important, it's not some 1850's world, where value is everything.
People can sell on the price and make billions.
They won at the same game by outcompeting others at selling commodity junk. Great. How? Same way. They had leaders whose business won the lottery and simultaneously didn't care about other humans to the same infinitesimally small way necessary to win that big (one can lose big with that give-no-f*cks mindset too, hence the lottery).
Selling crap isn't interesting. Show me somebody that makes a similar-sized dent in human health, the environment, or world peace then I think the fawning Medium articles will be worth it.
First of all, all 3 companies have very different business models.
Second, Apple never sold "commodity junk". The company sold (and sells) on the high end of the market, they take a different approach to design than competitors, use more expensive materials, machining, etc., design lots of their own internals (from logic board part to processors, even their own OS and programming languages, and create their products end to end (hardware to software), and come to market with lots of firsts (e.g. from small stuff like magsafe or the best trackpad in PC-land, to hi-dpi etc). And of course have won all kinds of design, quality awards.
Third, Facebook doesn't sell anything (except ads). What's the "commodity junk" they sell? Their service is junk? Compared to what? MySpace and similar competitors, whose websites were crap even at the time? What's the better social network people aren't on?
Fourth, Amazon? Has a first tier store, a first tier web service business. What's the commodity junk they sell? If you mean actual products on their store, then they sell everything, from expensive high end stuff to mass market cheap products. And of course, for ages, they started with books -- where there's nothing "commodity crap" about them, books are books, whether a high end bookstore sells them or Amazon does.
>Same way. They had leaders whose business won the lottery
If your explanation of 3 of the biggest companies on earth is "won the lottery" then you're missing a lot. Might a well invoke God.
>Selling crap isn't interesting. Show me somebody that makes a similar-sized dent in human health, the environment, or world peace then I think the fawning Medium articles will be worth it.
You conflate businesses with NGOs or revolutionary parties.
Which is a valid comparison for some aspects, but not one that can conclude that "businesses are not interesting" when speaking about business.
The marketcap and "I want it all"-scale don't make businesses interesting. What's interesting are things that can't be quantified well and therefore can't be competed on by hard work and assholery.
If you think "less literal" everything is "junk" compared to personal health and/or love.
>The marketcap and "I want it all"-scale don't make businesses interesting. What's interesting are things that can't be quantified well and therefore can't be competed on by hard work and assholery.
For your own definition of "interesting".
But Amazon, FP, Apple (and tons of other subjects) are still interesting if we use the common, agreed upon, dictionary, traditional definition of the term interesting: "arousing curiosity or interest; holding or catching the attention.".
And there's few things about Apple, FB, and Amazon's success stories that can be "quantified well", as their story and success goes beyond their financial status. How about why and how they succeeded?
In fact, most of my purchases go into 3 buckets:
1) Standard but I don't want crap--probably I'm going to a retailer website and picking it up (Target, Frys, etc. -- NewEgg is my exception to actually having brick and mortar). If I can pick it up, it's probably at least a notch or two above crap.
2) Total crap--probably ordering from Alibaba--not Amazon.
3) Something I need to go to a store for
To me, Amazon is being used decreasingly by everybody around me.
* Just a few months ago, I was able to buy something at Best Buy for only 10% more (~$30) than it would have cost to order from Amazon.
* On the other hand, I purchased a part for my clothes drier at 400% markup because I needed the part right away.
* I bought a personal hygiene item on Overstock because it was 260% of the cost at Macy's.
* We just started buying shampoo from Amazon because it's far cheaper (33%) than from Walgreens.
* My wife buys all of our socks, underwear, and most of my children's clothes online for ~50% of the in-store price.
Being "able" to buy 10% MORE doesn't sound like any kind of a deal. In fact, it sounds like the opposite...
Yeah, just not by anybody that actually affects their rising retail revenue.
I'm not even sure how this idea about "crap" works. If you order e.g. a Dell or an Apple laptop or a Sony camera or a WD HD or a Philips bulb etc, on Fry's or Best Buy etc, you'll get something different that if you order those on Amazon?
What's the idea here?