News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by Animats on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:24PM (#14200202)
Uber's self-driving system doesn't actually have to work beyond the demo level. It's mostly to pump up the company's valuation. Uber is losing money, and unless they find another sucker within a year, they're toast. They've already had to borrow on unfavorable terms.[1]

Operating a fleet of self-driving cars may turn out to be a lousy business. Uber's business model is built around others buying the cars, maintaining them, replacing them, and doing all the hard work. All Uber does is run an app.

Running a fleet of self-driving cars is running a car rental company. The company will have to buy the cars, maintain the cars, fuel or charge the cars, and obtain parking lots for storing the cars. They also have to figure out what to do with the used cars after a few years. Car rental companies turn over their fleets in a year or two, and are big sellers of used cars.

It's more likely that car rental companies will get into self driving than that Uber will get into car rental by the trip.

[1] https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/uber/funding-rounds

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by timewarrior on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:37PM (#14200247)
I think the biggest cost in this business is the human component. For that all you need to do is check the price difference between renting for a day or getting taxi for a day.

Given a choice, Uber would love to be the first to have self driving cars. Once they do that their business model scales predictably with capital.

Whoever gets self driving technology right, will own all transportation and logistics - which is huge!

However, I doubt they can do it. The quality of engineering talent is subpar compared to Google. Given that they couldn't compete with R&D they probably resorted to other means.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by bduerst on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:42PM (#14200269)
I think Matt Levine succinctly said it best:

>Eventually there will be self-driving cars, and there's no special reason to think that Uber will be the best at building them, or that its dominant position in the ride-hailing-app space will protect it from better self-driving-car businesses.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by timewarrior on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:38AM (#14200679)
Agreed. Unless they have a monopoly on self driving technology (which I seriously doubt).

On the other hand, I feel that we will not have self driving cars for a really long time. Instead I believe we will have flying cars before that, who will solve the last mile problem. They will take you from the house to the hub and hub to the final destination. Buses can transport people between hubs.

With self driving cars you need to deal with existing regulations, traffic rules, other drives on road, people jaywalking, animals running into you.

However with flying cars - you literally have exponentially more roads in air (which don't even have to be built). No existing regulations (unless at risk of being in flight path). Technology is already there (make drones bigger). These drones will communicate using MESH networks leading to lesser risk of collisions.

I also feel that Elon Musk is doing something really smart with The Boring Company. If he can dramatically reduce the cost of building tunnels (like he did with space travel) - he could build a lot of underground roads at a lower cost and faster pace than roads on surface. No need to deal with buying out land and getting approvals.

Imagine if these tunnels are exclusive to Tesla cars, who can auto-drive these tunnels for long distances. No need to worry about other cars, animals, rain, snow, traffic regulations. All the problems that auto driving cars are facing now, will go away. Multiple Tesla cars will communicate with each other using MESH network. Teslas could be driving in these tunnels at 150+ mph and discharged cars could be swapped with charged cars on the way. Drivers might need to take over minimally just for the last mile.

If a tunnel like this could be built between SF to LA. It could be faster door to door vs flight.

To get started, a tunnel from SF to really South Bay could have an huge impact on the commute.

I do not have much experience of these industries. So these are my hypotheses. Would love to know what others think!

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by enraged_camel on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:58AM (#14200781)
>>On the other hand, I feel that we will not have self driving cars for a really long time. Instead I believe we will have flying cars before that, who will solve the last mile problem.

We already have flying cars. They are called helicopters, and they are only available to various government agencies, large corps and the rich.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by abpavel on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @02:55AM (#14201005)
> No existing regulations (unless at risk of being in flight path).

Obviously you haven't had your flight lessons yet. Not only there are scores of airspace regulations, but flying is a much harder task to do as well. The freedom you're thinking off is akin to freely driving in a 4x4 on an open ranch, which has more to do with joy, and less with transportation needs.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by Animats on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @02:30PM (#14205649)
tunnel from SF to South Bay

I have a copy of the 1960 U.S. Corps of Engineers plan for the Bay Area. It totally predates environmentalism, and they were thinking big. They proposed five freeways on the SF peninsula - US 101, I-280, CA-1, CA-35, and one out in the bay on stilts. There's a second Bay Bridge at Candlestick. The area south of the Dumbarton bridge was to be filled in and developed.

Marin was planned as a heavy industry center, with steel mills at Tiburon. There was considerable WWII heavy industry in the north bay, including big shipyards, and the Corps thought that would grow, not shrink.

The SF peninsula would be a center for "business machines". They got that right.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by nihonde on Saturday April 29, 2017 @04:23PM (#14228551)
I would settle for a system that takes over control of otherwise regular cars on highways and in congested areas.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by SilasX on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:17AM (#14200594)
But note that Uber doesn't become superprofitable from SDCs unless they're the only ones with them; otherwise, they have to cut prices in line with the other SDC-ride-hailing apps.

Even under an optimistic scenario, might have a two-year SDC monopoly, after which others can offer the same product. That's still not nearly long enough to justify the valuation.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by yawaworht12 on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @03:51AM (#14201234)
No company is going to have a monopoly of self driving cars. Uber just needs to get them at the same time as everyone else to with either through build or buy. The main reason for doing as much building now is to have a sizable patent portfolio for defensive reasons. Google bought Motorola's patents to protect them while they competed with Apple.

With this in mind, how does anyone else compete without burning through far more money trying to gain market share. Uber burned through the money trying to be efficient when the market was much smaller. Once the market is much much larger, any competitor will have to burn through a orders of maginitude more cash to buy market share.

There's a lot more to succeeding in this market than self driving cars.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by NamTaf on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:34AM (#14200654)
For that all you need to do is check the price difference between renting for a day or getting taxi for a day

There's also the burden of convenience. A taxi is an instant, summonable affair that ends completely with the trip. A hire car has to be hired and returned to a specific location, you have to stow it during your hire period and you have to fuel it. Beyond the tangible costs of fuel, parking, etc. there's also the opportunity cost. For exmaple, people will pay for convenience of a car to pick them up and take them home when drinking, and they may only need the hire car for a couple of 10 minute bursts but you can't hire a car for less than a 24 hour period. Both of those help buoy the cost of a taxi.

I'm not suggesting you're wrong, but it's not as simple as [hire car] + [driver] = [taxi] from a cost perspective.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by pricechild on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @06:13AM (#14201852)
I don't think that's necessarily true... but I don't think anyone's cracked it yet either.

There's https://www.car2go.com which ran for a year or so in my city but has since shut down. You could leave the car within the bounds of the city.

There are also various bike schemes with a similar idea?

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by ghaff on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @08:29AM (#14202377)
Car schemes exist like Zipcar. I know people who live in cities and don't own a car who use them all the time. But it's turned out to be a pretty niche business. Zipcar is the highest profile of these businesses, at least in the US, AFAIK and even they ended up bought by Avis.

I suspect that with all the VC money subsidizing Uber et al, for most people the gap between regular rentals for a day+ and just calling an Uber isn't large.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by throw_away on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @08:04PM (#14208114)
car2go and reach now are much more usable than zipcar.

* cars are littered throughout the city rather than in designated parking spots

* cars are rented by the minute rather than by the hour

* cars don't have to be returned to where you got them from

The last point is the game changer. Now, it's feasible to do things like drive to the bar, but get a taxi back, or go on a long walk and grab a car back home when you're tired out.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by timewarrior on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:41AM (#14200700)
I agree it's not the same from the user point of view.

However from Uber's point of view - cost of 24 hours to rental company vs cost of 24 hours of taxi+driver would probably be a good approximation to get an idea of the order of saving which might make owing self driving cars feasible for Uber vs their current business model.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by celticninja on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @10:19AM (#14203153)
In addition they need the law to allow them to have driverless vehicles, right now these vehicles need a human driver 'just in case' with that expense autonomous vehicles will struggle against their traditional rivals. Where uber have an issue so that whilst Google can wait for the laws to allow for it Uber can't burn money for that long.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by ForHackernews on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @08:01AM (#14202244)
> Whoever gets self driving technology right, will own all transportation and logistics - which is huge!

Why? Presumably others will develop self-driving technology too, and then ground transportation becomes an interchangeable commodity that competes on price. It's not like there's only one container-ship firm in the world.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by mandeepj on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @12:49AM (#14200506)
> Running a fleet of self-driving cars is running a car rental company.

I am very surprised this comment got the top votes. OP - in which world do you live in? Uber already lease out vehicles so people who don't have a car but want to drive for Uber.... can lease it out from them.

Uber does not have to maintain their cars. They can sign an AMC with some company.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by djsumdog on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:00AM (#14200542)
I was not aware drivers could lease vehicles from Uber. I assumed they couldn't because I once reserved a ReachNow car, only to find an Uber driver setting up in it. He had ended his ride by accident, and was on the phone with their customer service. He was talking about needing to start work. The customer service rep said there was another car nearby (it was 2 blocks away when I looked at the app).

The guy then says on the phone, "I'll get this guy to drive me too it." He takes forever to get all his crap out of the car and says "We can drive-"

"Dude, it's two blocks that way. I'm paying by the minute. I'm not driving you.."

..and I thought to myself, there is no way this guy is really a Lyft/Uber driver and is using ReachNow or Zipcars? Even if that wasn't against policy (which I have a feeling it is), that also has to be incredibly expensive. How does he turn a profit?

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by fstuff on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @04:36AM (#14201431)
I don't know what reach now is but ubers leasing program is called exchange lease. Its scummy as hell. Anyone can get approved if they agree to drive for uber. A Toyota corolla is 150 a week and your fairs pay the lease. If they cur rates or itw a slow week you're underwater. Lots of people got screwed when the cut rates and had to drive for uber just to break even

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bloomberg.com/amp/news/arti...

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by cstejerean on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @02:02AM (#14200802)
That seems unlikely. You need to register each car you intend to drive with Uber and each one requires them to perform an inspection. So the chances of just grabbing a ZipCar and using it for Uber for the day being allowed are pretty much zero.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by Neliquat on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @12:47PM (#14204680)
Ehh, except I have seen people use different cars. I imagine you could just have a random zipcar inspected, and grab a similar looking one each time. People who drive for uber already have a terrible idea of finances, so not suprising.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by cstejerean on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @11:10PM (#14208905)
As a rider I would report that. If the license plate doesn't match what I see in the app I also wouldn't get in the car. Maybe not enough riders care enough and some drivers can get away with it.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by sangnoir on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:46AM (#14200733)
> Uber already lease out vehicles so people who don't have a car but want to drive for Uber.... can lease it out from them

Do you have any links for Uber-backed leases? This is the first I've heard of them and I'd like to know more. Last O heard, Uber was encouraging/facilitating leases from 3rd parties for its drivers without being involved in the resulting lease itself.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by mandeepj on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:51AM (#14200754)
> Do you have any links for Uber-backed leases?

One of the uber drivers told me this. I forgot the exact amount. I guess he said he pay around $250 per week to Uber

Here you go - https://www.uber.com/drive/vehicle-solutions/leasing/

Uber might have collaborated with some third party to handle the paper work

Edit - Uber partnered with Xchange Leasing, LLC for this leasing program

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by isubkhankulov on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:58AM (#14200780)
Xchange Leasing is an Uber affiliate which takes capital from wall st banks and loans it to uber drivers. uber takes out the loan payment before paying the driver.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by fstuff on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @04:41AM (#14201466)
Copied this reddit post ive linked to before that sums it up:

"It's their xchangleasing leasing program. It's basically a sub prime car loan like from the housing bubble days. You use Uber as your income verification and they'll let anyone lease a car provided they do X amount rides each week regardless of credit. They require a three year lease, you a have month to back out but after that you're on the hook for the car 100%. So if Uber cuts it's rates they still have same payment but less fare money each month. They did this to a lot of people and it's well known within the company that a lot of Uber black drivers were screwed when this happened. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-05-31/inside-ub.... <q>He leased a 2016 Toyota Corolla from Xchange in November, paying $155 a week. Two months later, Uber slashed fares nationally. Soon Hofstede had trouble keeping up with his payments. He went from making $200 in a weekend to $140 in a weekend, he said. "It got to the point that I would drive just to meet my payment," he said. "If you were short on your payment for a week it would roll onto the payment for next week. It starts adding up." </q> In this guys case they did a similar program for uber black years ago. Then they changed which cars were considered black cars. If I remember right a year after they started the program they changed which cars were considered "black" cars and this guys Lexus?? Was no longer a black car. They said it couldn't exclusively be used for black and had to pick up Uber X riders as well. Uber x pays a lot less. The people this happened to were basically bait and switched when Travis changed the terms on them. He can refuse uber x rides and only pick up uber black riders but if he refuses more than 45 rides in a month he's fired and forever banned from Uber but still on the hook for the car lease. The old Uber black leases started around 4k or 5k a month(I forget which cars but this was for a base "black car") but they made 6k to 8k, 10k a month back then depending on market. They cut rates and required you to pick up cheaper fairs and you're underwater. That's the 97k he's talking about. A lot of Uber black leases were repo'd because after this change their leases were more than their entire monthly wage. That's the personal responsibility Travis wants him to have. It's "Sorry the market change, too bad". Also the market changed or I mean people did. They just stopped using Uber black. I mean if you're taking at 10 or 20 minute ride across town are you really so vain to need a uber black. Turns out actually rich people are cheap and flocked to Uber x. That's why Travis mentioned their reducing the amount of drivers beacuse the number or riders also drop double screwing guys like this. Now let me say YES Travis is correct the guy is responsible for his desisions and things don't always work out like you'd expect. That said I see the guys side he made a 3 year commitment to Uber he couldn't walk away from and everything he was promised changed."

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by Balgair on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:34PM (#14205139)
Wow! So, Uber is not a taxi company, it's a sub-prime auto-loan company with draconian terms that masquerades as a taxi company. So much more makes sense about Uber in this light.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by bluetwo on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:58PM (#14200336)
Sure but Uber has one big ace up their sleeve... they could go public anytime they want.

The last best sucker is the stock market.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by Animats on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @12:42AM (#14200476)
They'd have to publish real GAAP financial numbers. Those numbers would look awful. Years of losses.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by danderino on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @02:40AM (#14200947)
Didn't stop Snap
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by justicezyx on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @12:39AM (#14200469)
> they could go public anytime they want.

Why? I cannot believe Uber's status-quo supports its valuation at all.

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by xapata on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @03:32AM (#14201151)
You say that like public stock shareholders are more discerning than other kinds of investors.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by yawaworht12 on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @03:55AM (#14201246)
As someone that worked on Wall Street, most HNers aren't any better than Main Street investors. In many ways I'd say they are worse. Specifically, the level of emotion some people have on HN when it comes to liking or disliking companies based on their pet issues leads them to make some financially asinine statements. If you want to make money in the capital markets, you have to be dispassionate, making your decisions based on financials and fundamentals.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by prawn on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @01:33AM (#14200646)
One solution to parking, once the human drivers are out of the picture and fuel costs are largely removed, is in self-driving cars purposefully getting themselves stuck in traffic.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by microtherion on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @03:34AM (#14201159)
That would be really anti-social, but plausibly cost effective. Or, as Uber management would say, "a no-brainer".
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by celticninja on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @10:17AM (#14203136)
And all of that is only going to be profitable if they are somehow allowed to operate fully autonomous cars without the need for a driver. If a driver wage has to be paid then the additional cost of an autonomous car is going to fuck up the already slim margin for potential​ profit. And whilst they have been able to disrupt the existing system by bypassing or ignoring laws they don't like and then fighting them in the courts there is no country on earth, at least not in somewhere they want to to operate​, that will allow them to run an autonomous car and seek approval later.
Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by SilasX on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @02:53PM (#14205869)
How does the link show that they were borrowing on unfavorable terms? Crunchbase doesn't show the terms of the funding round, and when I followed the link for the July 2016 round, it shows that they got a loan at 5%, which is ridiculously good in tech:

https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/07/new-reports-confirm-1-15b-...

Re:Uber must turn over information about its acquisition of ... by cannonpr on Wednesday April 26, 2017 @09:20AM (#14202694)
I think that might be missing the point of something like uber a bit, they could very well just rent you the self driving cars of individuals when they are not using them. Once self driving features hit most cars, companies like uber will be very well placed to capitalise on that. As software providers for the networks of self driving cars and trucks, owned by others.