Re:Shutting down public FTP services
by agumonkey on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:34PM
(#14198774)
What we need if FTP over HTTP.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Shutting down public FTP services
by mschuster91 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:39PM
(#14198815)
Well, there is WebDAV. At least Windows and OS X support it (Windows from Explorer, OS X from Finder), no idea about mainstream Linux/Android/iOS support though. Also, no idea if WebDAV can deal with Unix or Windows permissions, but I did not have that problem when I set up a WebDAV server a year ago.
IIRC WebDAV uses GET for retrieval, so the read parts can be cached by an intermediate proxy and the write part be relayed to the server.
As someone who once tried to write a WebDAV server I cannot with good convince recommend it. It's Bizarre extended HTTP protocol that should not exist.
Re:Shutting down public FTP services
by mschuster91 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:52PM
(#14198928)
Out of curiosity: why did you try to write your own WebDAV server? Apache ships a pretty much works-OOTB implementation - the only thing I never managed to get working was to assign uploaded files the UID/GID of the user who authenticated via HTTP auth to an LDAP server.
More specifically a CalDAV server which is a bizarre extension of WebDAV that shouldn't exist. We wanted one to connect to our internal identity server. That project was abandoned.
Related: "I Hope WebDAV Dies"[1]
Re:Shutting down public FTP services
by eikenberry on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @07:35PM
(#14199226)
Linux has great webdav support with the fuse filesystem, davfs. I used it with my box.net account and it worked fine.
What about Gopher? Will nobody think of Gopher?
Re:Shutting down public FTP services
by badsectoracula on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @06:57PM
(#14198966)
Actually i thought about Gopher (i even have my own client - http://runtimeterror.com/tools/gopher/ - although it only does text) since it basically behaves as FTP++ with abstract names (sadly most modern gopherholes treat it as hypertext lite by abusing the information nodes).
Gopher generally avoids most of FTP's pitfalls and it is dead easy to implement.
As a side note, there was a nice podcast about Gopher a few days ago at Techstuff [1]
[1] http://shows.howstuffworks.com/techstuff/what-was-gopher.htm
Re:Shutting down public FTP services
by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @08:08PM
(#14199409)
At least there's still Jigdo.