News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Engadget deleted the "EVO 4G vs iPhone 4" poll as soon as... by rbanffy on Thursday June 10, 2010 @07:19AM (#1419690)
So, you write and publish an article comparing two phones under non-ideal circumstances, let it air a couple hours, attract attention and then pull it - along with comments and a poll - because it was a comparison done under non-ideal circumstances that should be redone later?

Write a second article apologizing for the first one. Don't make the first article disappear.

This is seriously bad journalism.

Re:Engadget deleted the "EVO 4G vs iPhone 4" poll as soon as... by marknutter on Thursday June 10, 2010 @09:50AM (#1420024)
I think what happened here is the poll was posted before being approved by someone slightly higher up the totem pole at Engadget and was retracted by said person so that a more full treatment could be done later.

People make mistakes, this doesn't really bother me too much, especially since they have apologized and promised a more in-depth re-post in the future.

What does bother me is how crazy people are getting about this. I understand being a fan of something, but there's such a thing as taking it too far. Yeesh.

Re:Engadget deleted the "EVO 4G vs iPhone 4" poll as soon as... by rbanffy on Thursday June 10, 2010 @10:47AM (#1420229)
When you publish news for public consumption, you have to be held to higher standards. Engadget is not an opinion blog for someone. Engadget is news about... gadgets.

Engadget certainly welcomes the traffic and attention offering news bring.

Re:Engadget deleted the "EVO 4G vs iPhone 4" poll as soon as... by maukdaddy on Thursday June 10, 2010 @10:28AM (#1420161)
Please don't use the word "journalism" and Engadget in the same post. Ever again.
Re:Engadget deleted the "EVO 4G vs iPhone 4" poll as soon as... by cookiecaper on Thursday June 10, 2010 @11:15AM (#1420345)
He didn't actually use the word "Engadget"
Re:Engadget deleted the "EVO 4G vs iPhone 4" poll as soon as... by KirinDave on Thursday June 10, 2010 @11:26AM (#1420378)
Is it great work? No. Is it possible given the speed of the gadget news cycle? Yes.

And I read that article before it was taken down, it was total fluff. It shouldn't ever have been posted. They should have taken it down and left the editor's explanation in place.

But seriously, Android-fan readers need to calm the fuck down. This inconsequential editing gaffe doesn't mean Engadget hates anyone's phone, nor love anyone else's phone, or have any special conspiracy-driven agenda to hide bad press for Apple. It reveals the profound insecurity of that forum's collective mentality when they say things like that and get a lot of people agreeing.

I know the EVO has been getting socked in the press for its battery life (and these complaints are legitimate), but really it's a cool phone with a lot to offer and all signs point to the launch going very well for a Sprint phone. Re-lax.

Re:Engadget deleted the "EVO 4G vs iPhone 4" poll as soon as... by rbanffy on Thursday June 10, 2010 @11:29AM (#1420390)
It could be improved without being taken down.
Re:Engadget deleted the "EVO 4G vs iPhone 4" poll as soon as... by KirinDave on Thursday June 10, 2010 @11:43AM (#1420439)
No, it probably couldn't; the entire premise of what they are doing is bad tech journalism. Comparing something that doesn't have any concrete data to a recently released phone, declare half the things subjective, and then draw conclusions.

The only thing they could have done to improve it without takedown is put a big disclaimer at the top, “Journalism is hard. Sorry about the pile of poop below. We dropped the ball on this one.”

Re:Engadget deleted the "EVO 4G vs iPhone 4" poll as soon as... by rbanffy on Thursday June 10, 2010 @12:04PM (#1420517)
> The only thing they could have done to improve it without takedown is put a big disclaimer at the top, “Journalism is hard. Sorry about the pile of poop below. We dropped the ball on this one.”

That would be a perfectly acceptable solution ;-)

A disclaimer stating all data on the iPhone 4 is from spec-sheets would do too.

It would not be hard to make a comparison matrix between the two phones from the data that's publicly available. With the proper disclaimer, it wouldn't even be a bad article - just a very preliminary one. You don't need to refrain from reporting on an important development (Apple announcing a phone is important) when you have incomplete data - all you need is to clearly state that.