News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by groby_b on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:59AM (#14193538)
Uh, what?

First, the idea of declaring this un-American is grossly un-American itself. "We, the people" and "promote the general Welfare" seems to come somewhat before "mine, mine, MINE!" in the Constitution.

Second, Native Americans (and Puerto Rico) are fine with the idea of community property - which deals with your last point. I suppose you could declare them un-American, that's a very American thing to do, so you've got that going for you.

If you'd like to criticise this on the merits, go ahead - there's plenty of room. (For starters, a 100% estate tax will leave dependents destitute). But I'd be happy if HN could be kept free of the unthinking flag-waving approach.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by yequalsx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:17AM (#14193712)
It wouldn't necessarily leave dependents destitute. Adult children generally can make their own living.
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by pc86 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:33AM (#14193834)
Someone with Down Syndrome is (un)lucky enough in your scenario to have wealthy parents and they're forced to go from a comfortable life to state housing?

Someone's estate is theirs to do with what they see fit, including after their death. It is, after all, their property. If they want to donate it to the state or fund a foundation/non-profit, or give it all to their children, that is their right.

The state should not take ownership of my home, my bank accounts, and my assets simply because I die.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by EliRivers on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:09AM (#14194182)
"The state should not take ownership of my home, my bank accounts, and my assets simply because I die."

This is your personal axiom; many others disagree, including myself. I think that if you want to give something to someone, you should have to actually give it to them. You should experience that loss.

Holding onto everything until it is of absolutely no use whatsoever to you, and then insisting that the wishes of someone who doesn't exist anymore should continue to apply to those physical goods? I don't consider that the same as you choosing to give something to someone, and don't see why it should be indulged.

"It is, after all, their property."

No it isn't. Dead people don't have property. It was their property, and if they wanted to give it to someone, they should have done that while they were alive.

There is a middle ground to be found here somewhere so that people don't give everything they own to their children, who promptly turn them out on the streets in an amusing but predictable turn of events, but the way estate taxes are going (i.e. ever more to the benefit of the very wealthy) is the wrong way.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by icelancer on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:32AM (#14194420)
Say I'm 47, planning for retirement but haven't yet given my things to my relatively young kids. I am worth a few million. I am shot and killed in a random accident but I have not given my estate to my kids. I am a widow.

Because I didn't "experience that loss," all of my wealth is now transferred to the state because I was randomly killed?

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by EliRivers on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:55PM (#14196845)
In principle, yes.

That principle is that I believe that people should, broadly speaking, benefit from their own efforts, their own work, their own risks and indeed their own luck (and not the results of someone else's luck passed on by default because they get shot), and that we should aim for a society where this is the case and the opportunities to do so exist; not to benefit by default because someone else died rich.

As I said, there's a middle-ground to be found, perhaps in this case based on the belief that had you not been shot you would have given to your children for education or other such, and that can be accounted for (on the other hand, if you knew that in the event of your death, all your stuff goes back in the pot rather than to your children, perhaps you'd have bought some insurance against this event). If you make it to the age of 90 and you're still holding onto all your stuff, it's another matter.

In terms of middle-ground, if we're talking a few thousand dollars, it's not such a big deal. If we're seeing the rich get richer in each generation through accumulation of capital and passing it on, creating a new society of aristocracy and peasantry, it's a bigger deal.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by icelancer on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:53PM (#14197349)
I have a strong suspicion you have not evaluated the effects of variance if such an extreme policy such as yours was enacted.
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by EliRivers on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @04:14PM (#14197552)
When you say variance, I guess you don't mean the statistical value? Or you do mean that?

Is your objection to this moral (you disagree with my position that people should principally benefit from their own success in life) or practical (you think rich people will find dodges)? I'm certainly not convinced it could be done, but I think we can do better than where we seem to be going with the concentration of wealth through completely unearned income.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by yequalsx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:59AM (#14194737)
I think in a country as large and as complicated as modern societies one will encounter edge cases regardless of inheritance laws.

If I walk down the road and find $1 million I owe tax. If I win the the lottery I owe tax. If I work for the $1 million I owe tax. But if someone dies and I'm their heir I don't owe tax. To me if you didn't do anything to earn the money you ought to pay more tax than someone who did earn the money.

I don't advocate for a 100% estate tax but I be.ieve it should be much higher than it is in the U.S.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by donretag on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:23PM (#14195029)
The money was already tax when the original "owner" received it.
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by yequalsx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:34PM (#14195201)
All money is taxed multiple times. The basic principle behind taxation is that when you receive a profit you pay a tax on it. There are exceptions.

The money I earn is taxed. When I spend my after tax money to buy a car it gets taxed. The car dealership pays tax on the profit generated by my purchase even though I already payed income tax on the money I used to buy the car.

All money is "infinitely" taxed. When I find a million dollars on the street I owe tax on it. Why not when I get the money because someone died?

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by EliRivers on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @04:15PM (#14197563)
When I buy a chocolate bar, the store owner shouldn't pay tax because I already did, and the store employees likewise shouldn't pay tax because I paid tax on the money they're being paid with.

Extend to everything else anyone ever spends money on.

I can see a problem with this system.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by zip1234 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:36AM (#14194452)
"I think that if you want to give something to someone, you should have to actually give it to them. You should experience that loss." There is actually a tax on gifts over a certain amount/yr.
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by bobwaycott on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @09:37PM (#14199832)
Yes, but that doesn't really have anything to do with the parent's point.
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by yequalsx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:42AM (#14193931)
The word 'necessairly' is not unimportant in what I wrote. Over the centuries many societies and cultures have formed various ideas about how to deal with inheritance.

Presently in the U.S. inheritence is as you say it should be. It doesn't have to be this way and this way is not the only ethical or American way of dealing with inheritance. Indeed, Jefferson disagreed with what you wrote.

Also, I presented no scenario and have given no indication on what my beliefs on the issue are. I just said that a 100% estate tax would not necessarily leave surviving family members destitute. This is not disputable.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by pc86 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:07AM (#14194168)
I agree "necessarily" isn't unimportant in what you wrote. It's also a weasel word and can be used to make just about anything technically correct.

It's not necessarily a bad idea to edit production live. It's not necessarily a bad idea to have JavaScript on the server.

I agree that a 100% estate would not necessarily leave surviving family members destitute. However it absolute would leave some (another weasel word when you don't have data) family member completely without a means of support.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by yequalsx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:51AM (#14194624)
The percentage of people who can not make a living for themselves is quite small. The number of people who can not make a living for themselves who have rich parents is quite small.

My use of the word 'necessarily' was to highlight that we are talking about very small numbers. Indeed, it is disingenuous to bring up people with Down Syndrome who have wealthy parents into the conversation. It's such a small number of people. There are ways to help such people in a 100% estate tax society. There are ways to make legal exemptions based on extreme situations in a 100% estate tax society.

To say people will necessarily be destitute in a 100% estate tax society is wrong. It is bad thinking and indicates a poor understanding of public policy and potential remedies. It is wrong to say that absolutely at least one person would be destitute in a 100% estate tax society. It could be the case that this is true but it doesn't have to be the case.

One should strive to be accurate in how things are phrased.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by lovich on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @10:42AM (#14193933)
Ain't yours if you're dead
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by groby_b on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:57PM (#14195537)
A dependent is somebody who relies on somebody else for financial support[1]. So no, if the dependents aren't actually dependents, they won't be destitute.

[1] Tax law specifies that as a gross annual income of $4,050. Which in itself is probably debatable, but is certainly well below "making your own living".

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by yequalsx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:09PM (#14195711)
i read dependent as child. Yes if they are true dependent you are correct. Remedies can be created in such cases and it isn't necessarily true that dependents in 100% estate tax societies have to be destitute. Policies and programs can be created put in place. Exemptions can be made too. Whatever the case, it is bad policy to base inheritance tax for everyone on the small possibility that we are discussing.
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by maxxxxx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:09AM (#14194178)
"promote the general Welfare

I remember this from my citizenship test and always find it interesting that the people who quote the constitution all the time never use this phrase.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by maehwasu on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:29AM (#14194382)
That's because virtually no one at the time of its writing would have understood the term to mean "wide-scale re-distribution."
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by zip1234 on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:38AM (#14194467)
Yes, the term refers to congress not passing laws just to benefit a few people.
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by maxxxxx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @12:10PM (#14194880)
How do you know?
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:41PM (#14196099)
By reading their writings (not just the Constitution, but the Federalist Papers, their letters, transcripts of their speeches, and so on).
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by maxxxxx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @01:47PM (#14196157)
What does "general welfare" then mean?
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @02:31PM (#14196618)
It's a high-level goal or purpose for the government, right alongside "form a more perfect union", "establish justice", "insure domestic tranquility", "provide for the common defense", and "secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity". It's a top-level overview to answer "Why the Constitution?"

It is not a blank check to let the Government take everything it needs in order to provide everything everyone wants.

Look at the size of the Federal Government before World War I (meaning, for more than a hundred years after the writing of the Constitution). Look at the lack of even an income tax before 1913 (except for briefly during the Civil War, IIRC). If you're going to argue that "promote the general welfare" meant redistribution, you're going to have to argue that for over a hundred years, everyone forgot about that and the government didn't do its job.

But if you say that it's an explanation of the overall intent (as understood by the people of the time), but with a meaning that falls far short of large scale redistribution, then the historical actions of the Federal government make perfect sense, and the current understanding of that phrase is what's out of line.

Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by maxxxxx on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:09PM (#14196984)
I never mentioned redistribution but the phrase to me seems to mean that the intent was that the country should be governed in a way that benefits all and not just the few who have the money to pay for lobbying to get the laws they want.
Re:The fading American dream: Trends in absolute income mobi... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @03:21PM (#14197098)
I would agree that what you think it means is at least part of it - promote the general welfare, not a few specific welfares.

I was arguing against redistribution because maehwesu raised that point (seven posts upthread from this one). I misread your comments as arguing that redistribution was the intended meaning of "promote the general welfare".