These people are not in the same category as Jewish people
with regards to the Holocaust,” Hikind said following a
press conference at the memorial. “It is so vastly
different. You cannot compare political prisoners with
Jewish victims.”
The proviso I would add is that NYP a muck-racking rag that delights in outrage and controversy. I would be very skeptical it is giving a full and fair account of the individual's views. Anyone who's happy to make the former interpretation
needs to look very carefully at their motivations.
I don't believe the parent is making unfair interpretation of the actual article content. Using that as a source is somewhat suspect but any discussion of anything holocaust, Jewish or Israeli leads to accusations of anti-semitism these days. Its a problem, please be charitable.http://gawker.com/5986773/assemblyman-dov-hikind-king-of-one...
Look, the guy you have supported here is open in his support of Kahane and the JDL. That's just the territory you occupy.
It sounds like you were suggesting that that statement is a widely held belief amongst Jews in general. The tabloid article you linked doesn't support that claim. So what exactly is your claim?
Let me just say that the article and commentary you posted could very easily have been misinterpreted as suggesting that Jews try to minimise the suffering of non-Jews at the hands of the Nazis. I'm sure you didn't mean it to come across this way because it is a very common trope in anti-Semitic thought, and I guess it was an honest mistake on your part. We'll leave it at that.
http://www.haaretz.com/blogs/a-special-place-in-hell/visit-j...
... and I was proved correct in literally the next comment.
It's no wonder Israel supplied apartheid South Africa with nuclear weapons. They had a shared philosophy.
It categorically does not say that remembering non-Jewish victims diminishes the memory of the holocaust. It says that commemorating non-Jewish victims at that specific monument diminishes the memory of the holocaust vis-à-vis that specific monument.
Anyone who's happy to make the former interpretation needs to look very carefully at their motivations.