News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by sctb on Monday April 24, 2017 @03:37PM (#14187380)
We detached this flagged subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14185513.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Jtsummers on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:49PM (#14185804)
This doesn't make social security racist. It means that there are systemic issues that disproportionately impact people based on race that need to be fixed. Disproportionate receipt of Social Security benefits is merely a symptom or indicator, not a cause.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Consultant32452 on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:55PM (#14185874)
This disparity in receipt of SS benefits has been known about by the people who run/regulate these things since its inception. I'd be shocked if they didn't know this would happen even before its inception. Can you name a single mainstream politician who has made a serious effort to correct this problem? Maybe a couple exist, but I've personally never heard it uttered by a candidate.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by dragonwriter on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:29PM (#14186181)
> This disparity in receipt of SS benefits has been known about by the people who run/regulate these things since its inception.

The "disparity" is a change from 1980; the whole article is comparing the current state to that of 1980. The charts show that the absolute surplus of benefits over contributions was highest in the lower quintile in 1980, and the surplus since then has dropped in that quintile and raised in the other four.

I'm fairly sure that at the inception of Social Security in 1935 it was not known that changes after 1980, including a growing discrepancy in rich v. poor lifespans, would drrive a greater share of social security benefits to wealthier retirees than had been the case in the past.

Note that Social Security has measure built in that mitigate the advantages of wealthy contributors that were known in the past, including benefit caps and "bend points" in the calculation of benefits from contributions, which give wealthier retirees (that is, those with higher lifetime covered income) a lower proportion of annual benefits to wage-indexing contributions.

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Consultant32452 on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:00PM (#14186454)
Income isn't the racist factor here I'm talking about, but lifespan. The life expectancy differential between a black man and a white woman is a decade. It's not the amount of each individual check someone gets, it's the fact that some groups collect checks for many years longer.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Shivetya on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:22PM (#14186122)
Well the question you fail to ask is, are the conditions the same at inception to today? Why is every imbalance a racial issue? Is that the issue guaranteed to induce the most debate?

Are rich insert-minority-here have similar lifespans to rich-non-minority peoples? How much does location affect the outcome? Inner city poor are likely to be disproportionately affected by violence; murder where as those in rural areas might not get quick response to medical emergencies.

All that really matters is that people who get to the appropriate age are paid similar benefits. If you want to mitigate longevity then what is the option, terminate benefits after twenty years?

sorry I just find it abhorrent how some see race in every system and how it must be purposeful when declared

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Consultant32452 on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:45PM (#14186331)
>Well the question you fail to ask is, are the conditions the same at inception to today?

Except for the fact that at inception nobody had spent their entire life paying into the system: yes. The demographic lifespan differentials are similar.

>Why is every imbalance a racial issue?

This is a system that, on average, redistributes money from poor black people to wealthy white/Asian people. Simple as that. The article already covers the wealth issue, but even correcting for wealth blacks/hispanics have lower lifespans than whites/Asians.

>All that really matters is that people who get to the appropriate age are paid similar benefits.

That's the WHOLE point of my argument, is what the "appropriate age" is based off of. Presumably it has something to do with ability to perform labor at various life stages. The life expectancy differential between a white woman and a black man is over a decade. That we treat those two groups the same with regard to how we calculate their life stage is insane.

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by cgy1 on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:17PM (#14186076)
I believe this was one of the reasons for George W. Bush's push for privatizing part of social security.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Jtsummers on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:31PM (#14186208)
Privatizing it still doesn't address any of the systemic issues regarding ageism, classism, sexism, racism which have impacts on longevity.

This argument is fundamentally absurd. It's like saying that public schools in predominantly rich, white districts are better than schools in predominantly poor, black districts so we should get rid of all public schools because poor blacks get a poor education so it's racist.

No, we should address the problem of the schools and opportunities themselves, not eliminate it (though that may still be part of the solution). Here, with pensions, they serve a need. Eliminating them will actually hurt the poor, and minorities, more despite the discrepancies in payouts. The focus should be, why do they have worse life expectancies and what, if anything, can be done to address that. Why do they have worse savings rates so what can be done to increase their savings rates, or increase their wages so they're more able to save.

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Consultant32452 on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:22PM (#14186662)
>Privatizing it still doesn't address any of the systemic issues regarding ageism, classism, sexism, racism which have impacts on longevity.

There are potentially many solutions to this problem, but privatization would be a huge step forward compared to the current system. At least with privatization you could pass on your accumulated wealth to your children, even if you didn't get to enjoy it yourself.

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Jtsummers on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:27PM (#14186714)
That certainly would be a benefit, but that changes it from a traditional pension to a retirement savings/investing account. Traditional pensions are typically not inheritable (except, potentially, by a spouse) and, also typically, offer guarantees on payout. You will get $3000/month. A retirement savings/investment account can make no such guarantees.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Consultant32452 on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:49PM (#14186357)
It's unfashionable to recognize it publicly, but there really are minor physiological differences between different races. Race is a dumb word, but people with DNA from different regions will be susceptible to different types of problems. And doctors who aren't racist at all will provide different medical care based on these things because of what tends to work best for different groups. Hell, we even know red heads need more anesthesia, and that's just a hair color, not even a race. Even correcting for income, education, and all that blacks and hispanics have a lower lifespan than whites and Asians. Additionally, women live longer than men.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by kbenson on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:21PM (#14186660)
I believe this point is valid, but I'm unsure how to relate it to the discussion at hand.

That said, while it's true there are differences in different genetic ethnicities and in different sexes, that we choose to downplay these currently is probably mostly for the best. Until there is much more acceptance for the idea that we're all actually much more similar than we are different, and that natural variability based on specific, non-racial genes and upbringing overwhelms most group differences, promoting the idea that we are all the same is probably the most beneficial path. The alternative is that these small differences get blown far out of proportion and are used as explanations and excused in inappropriate ways.

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Consultant32452 on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:43PM (#14186850)
The difference is significant. On average a white woman out-lives a black man by 10 years. That's a lot of wealth redistribution. The SS retirement age is surely intended to correlate to something akin to stage of life, ability to perform labor, etc. There have to be better ways to do this than simply drawing a line in the sand that applies to every group. One of the many ways this could be done, and I only mention it for its relative simplicity, would be to privatize and switch to a defined contribution system rather than a defined benefit system. This has other problems, of course, but it would at least allow a person to pass on whatever they accumulated to their children, even if they didn't get to use it themselves.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by dragonwriter on Monday April 24, 2017 @03:06PM (#14187066)
> On average a white woman out-lives a black man by 10 years.

Most of the difference in life expectancy at birth is because black men are particularly likely to die as children or in young adulthood without having paid much, if anything, into Social Security.

At age 65, the difference in life expectancy between black men and white women is about 4 years, and it's about 3 years between black men and black women. And about 2 years between black men and white men. The main redistribution is that between men and women, regardless of race. There's a smaller racial redistribution effect.

> it for its relative simplicity, would be to privatize and switch to a defined contribution system rather than a defined benefit system. This has other problems, of course, but it would at least allow a person to pass on whatever they accumulated to their children, even if they didn't get to use it themselves.

It would be a far simpler change to simply make survivor benefits for dependents of a worker who dies early more generous (and on a sliding scale depending on how early they die),though if you do that without decreasing baseline benefits you need to do it at the same time as a revenue enhancement like uncapping taxed income and expanding beyond labor income (perhaps with additional bend points, though the existing bend point system may be enough that you don't need that.)

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by dragonwriter on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:54PM (#14186393)
> Even correcting for income, education, and all that blacks and hispanics have a lower lifespan than whites and Asians.

Hispanics in the US (which even those who believe race is a real thing consider an ethnicity that crosses racial lines, not a race) have longer life expectancy than non-Hispanic Whites.

https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6335a8.htm

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Consultant32452 on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:25PM (#14186691)
Thank you for the correction on hispanics and life expectancy, but it doesn't change the racist nature of the system just because one of the groups that would benefit the most might happen to be a minority.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by mnglkhn2 on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:57PM (#14185902)
Care to clarify/confirm that I understood correctly that you mean to say the asians/whites are racists for living longer?

How did you reach this conclusion?

Edit: and it looks like hispanics are actually living the longest https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm6335a8.htm

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by Consultant32452 on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:02PM (#14185960)
I didn't say Asians/whites are racist. I said the SS system itself is racist because it disproportionately benefits some races over others. Arguably the legislators and voters who want to keep the same system are racist too, though I suppose the voters are just ignorant. I highly doubt the legislators are ignorant of this problem.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by braveo on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:24PM (#14186137)
> because it disproportionately benefits some races over others.

That's not what racism means, stop abusing a word to further your own agenda.

I mean what next, skin pigmentation is racist because it causes higher rates of skin cancer in some races than others?

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by throwanem on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:28PM (#14186177)
The obvious counter, I think, would be that Social Security, unlike the sun, is a system of human design, and susceptible to human redesign - which the sun isn't, not yet at least.

(For clarity, I'm not espousing this position, and will not defend it with any energy should it be attacked. I post it because I'm as curious what a supporter of the "Social Security is racist" claim will think of it, as I am convinced that it's the most obvious consistent response to your point.)

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by braveo on Monday April 24, 2017 @07:31PM (#14189414)
and I would agree that SS is not perfect, and that it CAN be improved.

I just dislike characterizing it as racist. You can absolutely argue for the betterment of SS, even on the grounds that it inadvertently affects things along racial lines, without calling it a racist system.

Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by antisthenes on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:45PM (#14186868)
It is classist first and foremost, which the article does a very good job of describing and backing up with data, then, perhaps racist.
Re:The Rich Are Living Longer and Taking More From Taxpayers by throwanem on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:25PM (#14186153)
Would one be correct to regard as a trivial inference from your argument the statement that Social Security is also ageist, because in the aggregate it benefits older people over younger? If not, why not?