News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by praneshp on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:32AM (#14185090)
Absolutely yes, in this case. I'd prefer the officers went home to their families. If you want to go around pointing your phone at everything, you need to stop and think about the consequences.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by ajross on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:40AM (#14185166)
Genuinely confused about this morality. Why is it more correct that the officers "went home to their families" than that this innocent guy died in front of his?

I mean, I can understand arguing that sometimes protective violence is necessary and accepting that tragedies happen. But you're literally taking a side here and saying that police lives are more important than ours. Why?

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by praneshp on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:16PM (#14185493)
I wasn't trying to take sides. One set of people were doing their jobs, another person was doing something without thinking about consequences. I don;t hold this opinion in general, for example when someone videotapes police in a city street.

Several people were pissed off about privacy violations when Google glass was becoming popular. I'm trying to apply the same principle here. Yes, ideally the guy shouldn't have died, but if I have to take sides I'm supporting the cops doing their jobs over the person doing something without full knowledge of the situation. Shoot first, ask later, was a perfectly good response in this situation, IMO.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by bobwaycott on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:34PM (#14185664)
So ... you're not bothered that in this instance, LEO demonstrably "did something without full knowledge of the situation". Seems we should be holding LEO to a significantly higher standard of having full knowledge of a situation before doing something like employing lethal force. That's what we pay them for, and it shouldn't be to much to ask them to take an extra moment of extreme caution to verify the difference between a phone and an assault rifle.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by allannienhuis on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:38PM (#14186267)
"without full knowledge of the situation". Seems to me that the LEO had as much information about the situation as was possible in the timeframe required to act. Someone, at night, was pointing something at them from across the street during a gun battle with someone else (to be fair that's entirely based on information from this thread so we can treat it as a hypothetical situation if you like). I think it's pretty reasonable that a phone can be easily mistaken for a handgun in those circumstances (not sure why you're suggesting the comparison to an assault rifle).

That demands an immediate assessment of threat. I don't think it's reasonable to suggest that they just needed to wait a bit longer for more/better information to arrive when their current assessment based on the information available at that moment suggested a high risk to themselves or others.

LEO often have to deal with situations where information is imperfect (poor visibility, multiple actors, etc), and make judgement calls about what's the best/safest thing to do in the circumstances. Sometimes they get it wrong, because the information wasn't accurate enough, and sometimes they get it wrong because their training was insufficient or their judgement was flawed.

Clearly if training or poor judgement (or attitude) were factors in taking the wrong action then that should be addressed (and there may be a fair point to be made that in some jurisdictions LEO and their organisations are not held accountable enough for failures there).

And sometimes they get it right, and save the lives of themselves or others because they acted immediately.

Full disclosure: I have LEO family members (Canada), so I recognise I have some obvious bias on the topic.

[edit] looks like 'at night' may not have been correct; not sure where I got that from. I don't think it changes the argument much - information at hand is often imperfect; LEO need to act in some cases regardless of imperfect information due to the level of risk involved.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by syshum on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:56PM (#14185881)
>>>I wasn't trying to take sides

hmmm

>> I'm supporting the cops doing their jobs over the person doing something without full knowledge of the situation

Sure sounds like you are taking side....

I see this often when people excuse police abuse and over reach. They often claim they "dont want to take sides" or "dont want to defend their actions" but then proceed to defend the actions and/or take the side of the cops.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by praneshp on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:09PM (#14186000)
You forgot this part :)

>>> but if I have to take sides

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by jtuente on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:55AM (#14185308)
It's not a rationalization that police lives are more important, but rather about the stupidity of holding up a phone in such a way towards the police engaged in a dangerous situation that it appears as though you are acting aggressively towards them. The officers only have a limited time to assess the threat of any given person before more lives are lost due to an unknown danger. It's a high stress situation and wrong decisions are easily made. The officers weren't right in their immediate assessment of the danger, but that doesn't mean their actions were unwarranted.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by ajross on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:24PM (#14185576)
So... the police made a mistake, but that's OK. The guy made a mistake, but he died and that's warranted (your word!).

It's the asymmetry of this morality that horrifies me. I can understand people who think this is a terrible mistake but still sympathize with the officers and don't want to see them punished. But you guys... yikes.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by bobwaycott on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:40PM (#14185718)
For the equally callous flip side, we pay LEO to put their lives at risk and potentially die every day. We do not compensate citizens to put their lives at risk when a cop is around. In this cold and calculating scenario, maybe dying is what they're paid to do, kind of like soldiers. Except soldiers have massively more training and seem to be pretty decent at verifying an individual is a combatant before opening fire.

Because LEOs were dead wrong in their immediate assessment of the danger, that means exactly that their actions were unwarranted. When you act upon a false and unwarranted belief, you don't get to say your actions were warranted.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by eruditely on Tuesday April 25, 2017 @11:54PM (#14200319)
Military's are more than professional, get paid less, and still risk your life much more, being a LEO is not harder than being in the military.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by golergka on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:53AM (#14185290)
You're making this argument with full information. Police acting at the scene didn't have this luxury.

It is very easy to tell what others should have done in a situation that they perceive as life and death.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by SomeStupidPoint on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:05PM (#14185389)
The point is they're scaredy cats who jump at shadows and create deadly situations out of things that aren't.

If they want me to care that they perceive things as life-or-death, they need to adjust their perception. Being scared of your shadow holding a gun and pumping a house full of rounds isn't something I'm going to think is reasonable, even if you were really scared.

Soldiers in literal warzones facing trained adversaries trying to murder them aren't as jumpy as cops in a suburban neighborhood dealing with normal people.

Cops need better trigger discipline.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by praneshp on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:17PM (#14185500)
Well the person they were arresting was not quite normal. At least some part of your comparison is incorrect.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by stupidhn on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:40AM (#14185170)
>If you want to go around pointing your phone at everything, you need to stop and think about the consequences.

You should be embarassed of this comment.

>I'd prefer the officers went home to their families.

I'd prefer that unarmed, innocent civilians went home to their families.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by Broken_Hippo on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:03PM (#14185373)
I'd prefer everyone comes out of such encounters alive.

At the point these folks thought someone might have a weapon, the prudent thing to do is hold back and carefully plan your next moves. One of the first things would be to verify your suspicions - that there was, in fact, a gun.

They knew going in that folks hold things that can be mistaken for guns. Like phones and a myriad of other things - even during normal activities like running. Protocol should reflect that knowledge and err on the safety of everyone. Things change if there are actual shots fired from that direction, but caution before such time.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by i80and on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:42AM (#14185186)
I'm fairly sure you're being ironic, but I don't think it comes through in text very well.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by praneshp on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:19PM (#14185515)
Nope! I'm still learning to say potentially offensive things in a non-offensive way, so maybe that didn't come across well.

(Unless you are sarcastically saying that I must be trying irony.)

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by s73ver on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:24PM (#14186144)
Absolutely not. We hold cops to a higher standard. And I would have liked this guy to have gone home to his family.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by bonzini on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:38AM (#14185147)
Assuming it's necessary to shoot at all, aiming to kill is even more rarely the right thing to do.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by Kalium on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:44AM (#14185203)
In real life, there is only "do not shoot the firearm" and "shoot the firearm with the intent to kill". There is no practical aiming to disable or similar with a lethal firearm. There's no difference between the two, and no distinction to be drawn.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by grzm on Monday April 24, 2017 @11:50AM (#14185256)
Thank you for mentioning this. One minor adjustment I'd make to the above statement is "shoot the firearm with the intent to stop". This is a small, but important distinction. It doesn't change anything with respect to how the firearm is used (e.g., point of aim). At least from the perspective of police use of deadly force, the goal isn't to kill, it's to stop the person from continuing to be a threat. The outcome may be that the person does die, but if the person is stopped and doesn't die, that's an acceptable outcome once the decision has been made to use deadly force.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by bonzini on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:29PM (#14185621)
It's not minor at all, and it's exactly what I was hinting at.

If the person is stopped, doesn't die, and can be subject to trial in a court of law, that is a _better_ outcome.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by grzm on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:52PM (#14185831)
Would you clarify what you understand as alternatives to "aiming to kill" and how they would be effectively different from "aiming to kill"?

Edit: clarified question.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by bonzini on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:52PM (#14186383)
They aren't different at all from "aiming to stop", but the difference from "aiming to kill" is enormous. For example, aiming at the leg can be just as effective as aiming at the heart.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by grzm on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:23PM (#14186672)
Sorry, I can see how my question was unclear. I mean how "aiming to kill" is effectively different from "aiming to stop". I've edited it for clarity.

There are a couple of issues with the idea of, say, aiming at the leg.

* A leg wound may not stop the person.

* A leg wound can be lethal: you can bleed out very quickly if the femoral artery is hit.

* The trajectory of a bullet (and its fragments) once it impacts the body can be very unpredictable: a bullet entering the leg may strike bone and enter the chest cavity.

And all of these assume precise aim under stress. You mention aiming for the heart: police won't generally be aiming for something as small as the heart. Police (and all people using firearms) should receive the best training they can (and likely more and better firearms training than is often available today), but precise aim under stress is no easy task. They may be aiming for the torso (which of course includes the heart), because shots to the torso are generally more effective at stopping a person and it's a relatively large target: shots are more likely to hit and therefore less likely to miss (and hit something else: all bullets land somewhere).

Firearms are deadly force. Police have less-lethal alternatives available as well, and should be trained to use them effectively when it's appropriate to do so. If a police officer resorts to deadly force, the goal should be to stop the person as effectively and quickly as possible.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by bonzini on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:25PM (#14185585)
Not at all. In civilized countries, police are specifically trained to stop, not to kill. Sometimes one may imply the other, but not necessarily.
Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by Kalium on Monday April 24, 2017 @08:19PM (#14189711)
I'm 100% certain that you're absolutely right. Yet, I'm not aware of any way to use a lethal firearm in a capacity to stop in a way that is in some important and practical manner distinct from stopping a person lethally. I'm sure this is just a failure on my part to comprehend your point. Can you clarify, to help me with my personal failures? Perhaps you could detail what you mean about how police are trained in civilized countries?

Perhaps what you meant to communicate is that weapons other than inherently lethal firearms should be deployed?

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by praneshp on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:21PM (#14185546)
I'm by no means an expert gun-handler, but the only constant instruction every time I go to a range is "Don't point the gun at anything you are not ok with completely destroying".

I understand police should be better trained, and ideally they must shoot to stop vs shoot to kill.

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by nylonstrung on Monday April 24, 2017 @02:13PM (#14186585)
They already have non-lethal options available if they intend to stop someone. I feel like this would increase the lethality of situations where non-lethal approaches are warranted rather than decreasing the lethality of other ones.

Firearms should not be treated as implements of lethality and nothing but that. Imagine how many police shooting cases we'd see where cop claims he was shooting to wound but 'missed'

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by user5994461 on Monday April 24, 2017 @01:40PM (#14186294)
Safety on, unless you're actively practising.

Keep guns pointed toward the ground or the air when handling, don't point at things and never point at people.

Only have your hands on the trigger if you are planning to shoot. (Corollary: if someone has hands on trigger, consider that he's gonna shoot.)

P.S. That's what I've seen at European ranges, let's assume they are taking security more seriously than American ones :D

Re:CEO of ThinkPenguin, Inc arrested for filming police by grzm on Monday April 24, 2017 @12:53PM (#14185845)
> ideally they must shoot to stop vs shoot to kill

Would you clarify what you understand as the practical, effective difference between the two?