News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by twsted on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:01AM (#14177246)
This is great, we all should support this.

The web is at a crossroad and we should promote multiple platforms, old-style blogs, decentralized navigation, classic journalism, etc.

For too many people, Facebook is the web and this is really sad and wrong.

We must find other ways to pay for information and curated content, limiting tracking and defending privacy.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by blazespin on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:24AM (#14177325)
Oh, I dunno. I thought it was an interesting experiment. I think it still has its uses. Facebook is hardly a monopoly in the sense that google or microsoft was. I know tonnes of people who don't use facebook and the people who do use it, it's usually just to connect with friends.

Facebook / instagram / messenger, from what I can see, are just hard charging innovative platforms trying to create products people like. Their businesses could crater pretty easily and the only reason it doesn't is because they keep trying different things.

It's not like search and microsoft's OS dominance / network effects from their Office products.

You don't need to log onto facebook in order to work, you chose to because it's fun and you can connect with friends. Google / MSFT have far deeper hooks.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by onion2k on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:45AM (#14177389)
I know tonnes of people who don't use facebook and the people who do use it, it's usually just to connect with friends.

Facebook has 1.86 billion monthly active users as of Q4 2016[1]. At that time approximately 3.4 billion people used the internet. So a little over 1/2 the internet-using population, and 1/4 of everyone on Earth, has a Facebook account that they access at least once a month. If you drill down a bit about 80% of American adults use Facebook regularly[2]. You may know tonnes of people who don't use Facebook, but I think that's actually quite unusual. Outside of our HN-reading, privacy-interested, technically-competent bubble the overwhelming majority of people use Facebook, and Facebook does have an effective monopoly.

[1] http://money.cnn.com/2017/02/01/technology/facebook-earnings... [2] http://www.pewinternet.org/2016/11/11/social-media-update-20...

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by insickness on Sunday April 23, 2017 @06:31AM (#14177530)
80% of the country using facebook 'regularly' is not a monopoly. And even if it were, what are they monopolizing, social media in general? Just because 80% of the country visits McDonald's regularly does not make them a monopoly.
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by danieldk on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:30AM (#14177698)
That is a bad analogy. You can start a family diner tomorrow and compete with McDonalds. There is nothing preventing that 80% to eat at your place.

However, you cannot start a social network tomorrow and expect to make a reasonable income. People will not join your network, because their friends are not there. Facebook holds a significant part of the world population hostage, because they cannot 'dine' somewhere else. Contrast this with a situation where social networks are federated. You could opt to go to a competing network because their service is better, without losing contacts to your friends.

I would not know if that qualifies as a monopoly legally, but there is clearly a huge difference between McDonalds and Facebook.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by icebraining on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:54AM (#14177797)
While network effects exist and are worrying, this is a bit too strong - you can have two accounts concurrently, and many people do. Hence why FB had to buy Instagram and Whatsapp, and why Snapshat has more than a hundred million users.
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by danielpatrick on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:22AM (#14177878)
"You can have two accounts concurrently"... on all the sites that Facebook owns.

They tried to buy Snapchat too.

Some interesting reading on how we might measure the unusual cost of Facebook's monopoly to society.

https://stratechery.com/2017/facebook-and-the-cost-of-monopo...

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by H4CK3RM4N on Sunday April 23, 2017 @06:43AM (#14177563)
There's also a scary number of people in developing countries who will report that they use Facebook, but not 'the internet'. Developing countries are the market Facebook could dominate, in the same way Microsoft dominated computers for normal people.
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by scriptkiddy on Sunday April 23, 2017 @11:53AM (#14178642)
This is the scariest thing. Facebook tried to basically monopolize the Internet in India and other developing countries with Internet.org. There's a bunch of info out there on the subject, but this wired article is a good introduction: https://www.wired.com/2015/05/backlash-facebooks-free-intern...
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by danielpatrick on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:23AM (#14177884)
Under normal circumstances 80% would begin to get the Antitrust drums beating.
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by jpttsn on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:54AM (#14177968)
80% of people using something is not the same as 80% market share.
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by blazespin on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:28AM (#14177901)
Lol, try everyone under the age of 20. Facebook's survival is hardly assured. Why do you think zuck is working so hard on VR or why he split off messenger - because he knows facebooks survival is limited. What's app and Instagram is more of a threat than FB.

You people obviously don't use FB< if you did you'd realize that there is huge fatigue on the platform

The reason FB has done well is because they did some smart, viral things, but they can't just iterate like google or msft. They will die very quickly if they do. It's a very tenuous business they have

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by onion2k on Sunday April 23, 2017 @09:33AM (#14178090)
Facebook's survival is hardly assured.

Of course, but it'd take a long series of significant mistakes by Facebook for them to actually die. While another social network could potentially eat their market Facebook aren't just going to sit idly by and let them. They have the resources to tackle pretty much any threat, so the only way for them to fail is by getting things wrong internally. No one is going to invent a new way of communicating that Facebook can't copy.

Why do you think zuck is working so hard on VR or why he split off messenger - because he knows facebooks survival is limited. What's app and Instagram is more of a threat than FB.

I suspect a lot of Facebook's 'side projects' are driven by what Zuck finds interesting rather than what he thinks is important to Facebook's future.

You people obviously don't use FB< if you did you'd realize that there is huge fatigue on the platform

I don't think it's possible to gauge 1.86 billion people's opinions of Facebook by the things you see when you log in to your own account.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by blazespin on Sunday April 23, 2017 @03:51PM (#14180103)
I am not sure people want another social network. It's not like search or computer OS or even Netflix. My feeling is that FB, as is (social news feeds), has no real future. I think the future is messenger, WhatsApp, instagram, vr, etc.

The reason fb is popular is zucks sheer force of Will and not because it's particularly necessary.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by coldtea on Sunday April 23, 2017 @09:00AM (#14177980)
>Lol, try everyone under the age of 20.

LOL, those people will grow up too, and a large percentage of them will join places like FB and even LinkedIn. It's not like what people use in their teens is what they use when they get older, start working, etc.

Besides "What's app and Instagram is more of a threat than FB" is missing the point, as both are owned by FB, the company.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by madeofpalk on Sunday April 23, 2017 @05:38AM (#14177366)
> Facebook [is] just hard charging innovative platforms trying to create products people like

That's a pretty charitable interpretation of Instant Articles.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by lucideer on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:37AM (#14177936)
I think you might be surprised at Facebook's levels of control https://twitter.com/auchenberg/status/834894652775923712?s=0...
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by return0 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @12:05PM (#14178700)
> For too many people, Facebook is the web and this is really sad and wrong.

Those people don't have a need for the web, and, more importantly, the web has no use for them.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by yzmtf2008 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @01:47PM (#14179286)
This kind of dismissive argument is exactly what caused this situation to happen.

If you don't think the web has any use for them, someone else's "web" will. And that web will have a better user experience than yours. Before you know it, people are all using their "web" (see facebook).

The real issue here is how can we enhance the experience of the web we're trying to protect. If someone else has something that's easier to use, people are going to use it.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by return0 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @01:54PM (#14179340)
I m not being dismissive, just realistic. If you want an example of this crowd spilling into the "broader web" , look no further than youtube comments. People who have nothing interesting to add to the web had better stay inside silos.

Facebook is in no way a "better web". I don't use it and I m not missing anything.

I also don't agree that "ease makes it better". The early days of the web were mindbogglingly interesting because it attracted an inquisitive crowd who found ways to make it work (and invented things, if needed). Even today, interesting crowds often flock to low-UX corners of the web (case in point HN).

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by yzmtf2008 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @02:24PM (#14179536)
I don't disagree with you. I too also want the web to continue to be interesting. I also find myself clicking on "Instance Articles" and "AMP" pages a lot, because the experience sometimes is just so much better.

You and I can probably live without Facebook, but for many, that's literally the only way they connect with friends online. And that's important, because the average user will become what defines the web. Just like trump is the president now, both are things I don't personally like, but that's just the people speaking.

In a way, we (hn users) are also uninteresting -- and the Facebook content are kind of interesting to other people as well. People are different, and we just have different objective functions. In that sense, HN itself is also a "silo". We don't want to be living in silos.

Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by barking on Sunday April 23, 2017 @06:10AM (#14177459)
It's up to the Guardian, not up to us. The press didn't arise in the first place because of people feeling it was something they should support. It filled a need.
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by eeeeeeeeeeeee on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:37AM (#14177729)
In the U.S. at least a free and independent press is paramount to our system of government. It's why it's in the Constitution. So, no, it is up to all of us to support journalism and ensure it survives, not only the actual people writing.
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by mb_72 on Sunday April 23, 2017 @09:18AM (#14178036)
I am not American, but when Trump was elected and made attacks on the media it was the 'last straw' and I took out a NYT digital sub, thinking it might help in some small way. The AUD6.40 per month is terrific value, and I often come across articles or reporting I wouldn't have otherwise. Even if I don't agree with what is written, I feel I've come away with an expanded understanding of the topic and a slightly broader world view.
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by barking on Sunday April 23, 2017 @07:50AM (#14177781)
And how are we to decide which journals and journalists to give money to?
Re:The Guardian Pulls Out of Facebook’s Instant Articles and... by danielpatrick on Sunday April 23, 2017 @08:38AM (#14177939)
Those that dig and present quality, fact-supported stories.