News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @01:38PM (#1417655)
Why do game programmers need a union?

As for IP terms/noncompetes/overtime, I'm not sure why you need a union. Why not just negotiate for that yourself?

Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @03:58PM (#1418074)
>As for IP terms/noncompetes/overtime, I'm not sure why you need a union. Why not just negotiate for that yourself?

Because certain portions of our field have jobs that people are willing to be whipped and beaten for if they can get the jobs (entry level game programming, I'm looking at you).

There isn't anything about programming that makes it reasonable to require unpaid overtime exemptions, etc, unlike most other fields have. It's merely poor management demanding it.

Game programming, especially, would be nice, as there is no reason to make games come out faster, they're pure entertainment without just recompense for hours worked. A heavy preponderance of unions would deescalate the field, making everyone do less over a given period of time (or pay people much better than they do for the overtime they demand).

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @05:25PM (#1418342)
Game programmers are presumably compensated with fun.

There is nothing preventing a game programmer from quitting to work at a bank, a rails shop or google. If a game programmer stays, it's because he/she enjoys game programming so much that it's worth the long hours and poor pay.

I'm not sure why you consider unions reducing productivity to be a good thing.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Thursday June 10, 2010 @11:15AM (#1420343)
Are you aware of the fact that if we had 1992's productivity, there would be full employment in the US right now? You know when your boss lays off 1/3 the team, then expects you to do the same work: That's productivity!

Productivity is not god. Productivity does not trump the health of the people who work there. Programming jobs currently do horrible things to the health of IT's practitioners, especially ones with stupidly long hours, including game programming.

Saner hours would employ more people (or the games would do less). No one can say "games are essential enough to damage people's health over" but guess what: their development largely damages their health of their programmers.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 10, 2010 @01:19PM (#1420796)
Are you aware of the fact that if we had 1992's productivity, we would all be 30% poorer (and living 2.8 years less) than we are today?
Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Thursday June 10, 2010 @01:45PM (#1420916)
I don't see your numbers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:United_States_Income_Distr...

And productivity doesn't drive medical research, so:

>(and living 2.8 years less)

is unlikely

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 10, 2010 @01:57PM (#1420979)
http://www.google.com/publicdata?ds=wb-wdi&met=ny_gdp_mk...

You can do the inflation calculation yourself. Income is a poor measure since it excludes non-wage compensation (e.g., medical spending) which have gone up significantly relative to income.

I'm not sure why you conclude life expectancy went up due to medical research. Wealth increases life expectancy, but not due to medical spending.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Thursday June 10, 2010 @05:53PM (#1421877)
Your graph doesn't show anything about actual wages, or wages with the excluded non-wage compensation you're speaking of.

GDP growth is not related to income growth of normal people. For the last 20 years, something like 85% of the growth has gone to the very very rich. It was only really in the postwar period did the middle class ever really grow large (in that period of time we had the only factories in the world), and income growth has been pretty stagnant since the 80's.

According to the US Census Bureau, the median is "considerably lower than the average, and provides a more accurate representation."

"While the median household income has increased 30% since 1990, it has increased only slightly when considering inflation. In 1990, the median household income was $30,056 or $44,603 in 2003 dollars. "

Sources: http://www.demographia.com/db-stateinc2000.htm

I bring you to the censuses conclusions about our largely stagnant american wages (which peaked in 1999): http://www.census.gov/prod/2004pubs/p60-226.pdf

Most of that GDP is going to very very rich people.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by Tiktaalik on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @01:46PM (#1417684)
Collective bargaining power is better. A guy with a decade of experience may be able to negotiate a good deal, but for someone just out of university they'll likely be treated like their just lucky to have a job. Certain rules should apply industrywide.

For games industry in general a focus some sort of standardisation for credit would be useful. How long does one have to work on a project to be in the credits for example? People get screwed out of credit all the time.

Royalties is another point of contention. Some sort of standardisation for minimums would be useful. Call of Duty 2 has made well over a billion in revenue, yet there was all sorts of drama regarding royalties and the studio collapsed as a result and likely many walked away with nothing.