News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @01:20PM (#1417595)
Yes, certain types do. Game programmers come to mind. Not sure everyone else needs them though, but there are likely others who do.

Additionally, less onerous IP terms for employment, standard non-competes and a reduction of the idea of absurd overtime being the norm are all good things.

California can thank their non-compete/IP laws for part of Silicon Valley's success.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by dantheman on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @01:40PM (#1417664)
Game programmers choose their work environment they could easily be paid more and work less hours by using their skills in other industries, but they choose not too.

A lot of them choose that environment just people involved in movies and television work crazy hours. Entertainment seems to require massive amount of work in relatively short bursts. Those who can figure out a way to not need this will quickly get the best talent and destroy their competition.

What would a union do? Take their money? Have them go on strike? Bankrupt the company? Make it harder to fire crappy programmers (as if it isn't hard enough already).

Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @03:56PM (#1418062)
>A lot of them choose that environment just people involved in movies and television work crazy hours.

And almost everyone in the movie industry is union as well. For the same reason (highly desired jobs allowing for crazy abuse of the workers). Actually movie industry programming (Special effects, etc), are actually very tame compared to many other forms of programming as far as hours go, especially compared to video games, which is another place some of those skills they have could be applied.

The point would be to require sane amounts of hours, feature cuts rather than overtime, etc.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by dantheman on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @08:57PM (#1418846)
Anyone can create a company that does that, and if they're successful then that's great.

Creating games in under 40 hours a week: http://archives.igda.org/qol/IGDA_2005_GDC-QOL-Lecture.ppt

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @11:36PM (#1419059)
The point would be to require sane amounts of hours, feature cuts rather than overtime, etc.

The point would be to harm society for the benefit of union members?

Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Thursday June 10, 2010 @11:04AM (#1420303)
As opposed to harming the programmers for the benefit of society?

If that truly was the choice, yes, I'd be all for giving less of a benefit to society over actually harming programmers.

I don't think that is true however. As many people have successfully developed software in general, and games in particular, with 40 hour weeks, I believe the overtime shops are throwing hours at a problem that has other solutions. By forcing game companies to have the same overtime type regulations that almost every other sort of company has, you make those solutions mandatory.

If you think I'm full of it, perhaps you should look at EA: They peeled back from massive overtime, and now "only" do stupid hours 2 months a year (down from 4-8 months a year). Evidently, those stupid overtime hours weren't needed.

Holywood has unionized. Notice movies are still made. Sitcoms are still made. Nothing stopped there. Occasionally there is a strike or something, and we watch reruns.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 10, 2010 @11:32AM (#1420404)
How are the programmers harmed? They are voluntarily choosing to put in long hours in return for salary+fun. If they are willing to out compete you by putting in long hours, who are you to tell them "no, that's unfair competition, you don't have the right to work harder than me?"

I'm sorry, but forcing everyone to work at union levels of laziness is a bad idea. The net result will simply be that we produce lower quality video games, a few more lazy people become game programmers, and a few hardworking people are crowded out of game programming and go work on wall st.

As for Hollywood unions, to show they are not harmful, you must show we would get the same number/quality of movies at the same price. GM makes cars in spite of having a union, they are just crappier/more expensive than Toyota. Many supermarkets still sell food in spite of a union, they are just more expensive than Walmart.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Thursday June 10, 2010 @01:40PM (#1420890)
>They are voluntarily choosing to put in long hours in return for salary+fun.

They are voluntarily are harming themselves. It's still harm. Their marriages don't last/are very strained, their health declines from long amounts of chair time, bad food and long hours. If the collectively bargained for normal working hours, I bet most of them would be ecstatic to get it.

> The net result will simply be that we produce lower quality video games

Perhaps? Perhaps we'll just produce them differently! And even if we do, they're just video games. It's okay if we create less of them in order to produce them without harming everyone involved to do so. I'm sure if we took off all the safety regulations, employee regulations, and negotiated employee agreements we'd have cheaper oil and more of it. Doesn't make that a good either.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 10, 2010 @02:16PM (#1421058)
If the collectively bargained for normal working hours, I bet most of them would be ecstatic to get it.

I'm not a game programmer, but I do work long hours. Why would losing one of my competitive advantages would make me happy?

Perhaps we'll just produce them differently!

If this can be done, there is nothing preventing you from doing so now and gaining a competitive advantage over other companies (better working conditions + equal productivity == better employees). So why aren't you getting rich by doing this right now?

Re:Do programmers need a union? by heresy on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @06:35PM (#1418544)
In 2002, I had 3 friends employed by gaming companies. In 2010, none of them are, and happier for it.

One of them got an 90% pay increase by moving to a company doing kernel level development. They also got normal working hours. Hmmm, tough call.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @01:38PM (#1417655)
Why do game programmers need a union?

As for IP terms/noncompetes/overtime, I'm not sure why you need a union. Why not just negotiate for that yourself?

Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @03:58PM (#1418074)
>As for IP terms/noncompetes/overtime, I'm not sure why you need a union. Why not just negotiate for that yourself?

Because certain portions of our field have jobs that people are willing to be whipped and beaten for if they can get the jobs (entry level game programming, I'm looking at you).

There isn't anything about programming that makes it reasonable to require unpaid overtime exemptions, etc, unlike most other fields have. It's merely poor management demanding it.

Game programming, especially, would be nice, as there is no reason to make games come out faster, they're pure entertainment without just recompense for hours worked. A heavy preponderance of unions would deescalate the field, making everyone do less over a given period of time (or pay people much better than they do for the overtime they demand).

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @05:25PM (#1418342)
Game programmers are presumably compensated with fun.

There is nothing preventing a game programmer from quitting to work at a bank, a rails shop or google. If a game programmer stays, it's because he/she enjoys game programming so much that it's worth the long hours and poor pay.

I'm not sure why you consider unions reducing productivity to be a good thing.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Thursday June 10, 2010 @11:15AM (#1420343)
Are you aware of the fact that if we had 1992's productivity, there would be full employment in the US right now? You know when your boss lays off 1/3 the team, then expects you to do the same work: That's productivity!

Productivity is not god. Productivity does not trump the health of the people who work there. Programming jobs currently do horrible things to the health of IT's practitioners, especially ones with stupidly long hours, including game programming.

Saner hours would employ more people (or the games would do less). No one can say "games are essential enough to damage people's health over" but guess what: their development largely damages their health of their programmers.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 10, 2010 @01:19PM (#1420796)
Are you aware of the fact that if we had 1992's productivity, we would all be 30% poorer (and living 2.8 years less) than we are today?
Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Thursday June 10, 2010 @01:45PM (#1420916)
I don't see your numbers: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:United_States_Income_Distr...

And productivity doesn't drive medical research, so:

>(and living 2.8 years less)

is unlikely

Re:Do programmers need a union? by yummyfajitas on Thursday June 10, 2010 @01:57PM (#1420979)
http://www.google.com/publicdata?ds=wb-wdi&met=ny_gdp_mk...

You can do the inflation calculation yourself. Income is a poor measure since it excludes non-wage compensation (e.g., medical spending) which have gone up significantly relative to income.

I'm not sure why you conclude life expectancy went up due to medical research. Wealth increases life expectancy, but not due to medical spending.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by gte910h on Thursday June 10, 2010 @05:53PM (#1421877)
Your graph doesn't show anything about actual wages, or wages with the excluded non-wage compensation you're speaking of.

GDP growth is not related to income growth of normal people. For the last 20 years, something like 85% of the growth has gone to the very very rich. It was only really in the postwar period did the middle class ever really grow large (in that period of time we had the only factories in the world), and income growth has been pretty stagnant since the 80's.

According to the US Census Bureau, the median is "considerably lower than the average, and provides a more accurate representation."

"While the median household income has increased 30% since 1990, it has increased only slightly when considering inflation. In 1990, the median household income was $30,056 or $44,603 in 2003 dollars. "

Sources: http://www.demographia.com/db-stateinc2000.htm

I bring you to the censuses conclusions about our largely stagnant american wages (which peaked in 1999): http://www.census.gov/prod/2004pubs/p60-226.pdf

Most of that GDP is going to very very rich people.

Re:Do programmers need a union? by Tiktaalik on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @01:46PM (#1417684)
Collective bargaining power is better. A guy with a decade of experience may be able to negotiate a good deal, but for someone just out of university they'll likely be treated like their just lucky to have a job. Certain rules should apply industrywide.

For games industry in general a focus some sort of standardisation for credit would be useful. How long does one have to work on a project to be in the credits for example? People get screwed out of credit all the time.

Royalties is another point of contention. Some sort of standardisation for minimums would be useful. Call of Duty 2 has made well over a billion in revenue, yet there was all sorts of drama regarding royalties and the studio collapsed as a result and likely many walked away with nothing.