News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by rbanffy on Friday April 21, 2017 @07:29PM (#14170246)
I was going to be short. Still, even if large, I won't price this above two cents.

I am saddened to say, but everything that made the Amiga great when it was launched seems meh by today's standards.

Amigas had preemptive multitasking before any other home computer. Today it's the norm. Amigas could switch video modes every scanline. Today, even the concept of a scanline takes a while to explain to someone born in the 90's. The same happens with the careful NTSC timing ("what's NTSC, grandpa?") that, ultimately, doomed the machine to low-resolution graphics until it was too late. Hardware accelerated graphics (their blitter was cool) is also the norm (and many orders of magnitude faster now). We don't even talk about audio quality anymore.

Everything that defined an Amiga is commonplace. To experience a UI that looks like a cross between Gnome 2 and BeOS running on a processor that once replaced 68Ks is not what would define an Amiga today.

So, what I would expect an Amiga for the 2020's to be?

I'd imagine, for starters, a uniform CPU/GPU architecture. Lots of cores accessing a single memory pool (let them have some scratch memory for themselves to save bandwidth) running the same software doing the job of both CPU and GPU. Make this CPU/GPU hybrid monster capable of combining multiple 4K inputs piped into textures and composite them in real time on any display surface available. A radical idea should set the tone.

Maybe, for the GUI, explore the idea of depth to convey information about windows. A simple sensor could locate your head and adjust the screen perspective accordingly. To the programmer, the GUI should be simple. Reminisce about Plan 9 a bit. If the head detection thing is capable of dealing with hand gestures, have a couple gestures to zoom in/out, switch task/workspace and so on. Make the visual language elegant for the 2020's. Let go of the 80's.

Embrace the idea of "the network is the computer". Again, think Plan 9.

Obviously, make the OS developer friendly, not only to develop for it, but for other platforms as well (whoever uses this computer needs to be able to work). Don't bother with the Amiga CLI - we have better stuff now. Ports of Clang/LLVM, OpenJDK, the usual browsers and, of course, Emacs, are the bare essentials. Make it POSIX so it's easy, but favor languages that express concurrency and multiprocessing easily because you'll have a whole lot of cores.

Obviously it should be able to read most common filesystems, even if its native filesystem is something alien. Snapshots, implicit RAID, part of the computer address space... Something new, please. Maybe don't have a disk and treat RAM as cache for a persistent store. It'd need to be radical or it'd be just another cute computer.

Ditch the mouse. Use a trackpad. Just make it right (as good as Apple's).

The system enclosure can't look like a PC. If at all possible, build it with no cables - edge connectors to drives, power, external ports. If it's pretty enough, you get the chance of using transparency to show it off. Again, 2020's, not 80's.

Use the ball as soon as possible at boot, at the highest resolution the display allows. Use the bounce sound to signal successful POST. 2020's, but still Amiga.

Finally, the keyboard. Whatever you do, don't make it a generic (or worse, cheap) PC keyboard. An Amiga should feel different (even if the original was so-so). From layout to switches to keycaps, it'll have to convey uniqueness.

That ended up longer than expected...

Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by nickpsecurity on Friday April 21, 2017 @08:09PM (#14170409)
I thought I read the Amiga's also had dedicated hardware for specific functions. That happens on desktops with graphics, sound, and networking cards. However, a modern Amiga might integrate a FPGA (or several) and standard API somewhat like HPC servers are doing. Then, apps can take advantage of it. Might also justify its cost.

Pico Computing already sells desktops that are similar to what I'm thinking about. They're just non-standard & you customize stuff to them where this would be standard with flagship apps (even FOSS) using accelerators by default.

EDIT: Or even heterogenous processors with varying strengths for great power/performance ratio. Similar to what phones are doing.

Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by jacquesm on Friday April 21, 2017 @10:11PM (#14170772)
I'd buy one, just to motivate the producers. Since SGI died the computers are a bit boring. (And SGI was way too expensive but that was some pretty amazing hardware for the time.)
Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by nickpsecurity on Friday April 21, 2017 @11:13PM (#14170940)
They seemed to stay technologically ahead of their time in various ways. They did NUMA systems with great performance. Did them in desktops, too. Tried stripped OS's for the compute nodes that redirected things like I/O to others. Eliminated most bottlenecks that were in graphics buses. Supported open standards for graphics. The Bill Gates and SGI demo of modifying live video. Dual mobos in the desktops. Threw in RAS, Trusted extensions to Irix, and other things competitors were doing. Let you run Quake, though. FPGA's as a compute node later on with NUMA latency and bandwith. Took forever for competition to do that.

All that said, the cases for the desktops and Origin especially looked cool as hell. There was definitely a wow factor showing off SGI hardware even to laypeople. Then there was one seeing what it could do.

Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by Udik on Saturday April 22, 2017 @05:05AM (#14171698)
That's more or less what I wanted to say (as a former Amiga owner and enthusiast, back in the '90s). These nostalgic operations that keep popping up every few months or years are basically denying the spirit of the original Amiga, which was that of a machine ahead of its time. A completely new machine instead, entirely different and totally incompatible with the old Amiga, based on some radically different architecture from the current desktop computers, would be truer to its original spirit.
Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by dajt on Sunday April 23, 2017 @06:33PM (#14180804)
I thought Be would be the spiritual successor to the Amiga and attractive to the original Amiga user base. Having said that I didn't buy one because I didn't want to spend time and money on a platform that was obviously not going anywhere. Even a Mac would be a reasonable place for an ex-Amiganaut to end up. I didn't go there either because while I thought the original OS-X was a great idea I think it got more fragmented and further from the lauded Apple design brilliance with every release. Plus Apple stuff is stupid expensive for what you get.
Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by rjsw on Saturday April 22, 2017 @07:33AM (#14172020)
> Hardware accelerated graphics (their blitter was cool) is also the norm (and many orders of magnitude faster now).

Not really. Current GPUs don't have 2D hardware, everything is just done in "software".

> I'd imagine, for starters, a uniform CPU/GPU architecture. Lots of cores accessing a single memory pool (let them have some scratch memory for themselves to save bandwidth) running the same software doing the job of both CPU and GPU. Make this CPU/GPU hybrid monster capable of combining multiple 4K inputs piped into textures and composite them in real time on any display surface available.

Sounds rather like Larrabee [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larrabee_(microarchitecture)

Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by rbanffy on Saturday April 22, 2017 @03:42PM (#14174340)
For the blitter, this re-imagining is doing everything in software anyway. We can add a couple instructions for that.

I was thinking about Xeon Phi (which is the child of Larrabee), but with cores able to perform better than x86's as GPU cores. There seems to be a great deal of ground between CPUs and GPUs and a lot of spots one can be to function reasonably as both.

Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by dleslie on Friday April 21, 2017 @10:20PM (#14170797)
Where's a VC when you need one?! Someone get this plan in motion.
Re:AmigaOne X5000 – first impression by rbanffy on Saturday April 22, 2017 @03:15PM (#14174204)
I don't think there is a single VC able to invest enough to see this idea trough. The CPU alone is something Intel attempted and couldn't make perform well as a GPU. The Xeon Phi is (like the SPARC Niagara was before it) very interesting (and I'd love to see a similar part meant for desktops) and a model of what I think future CPUs will be.