The issue is that, in a union shop--and this varies state by state--you might have to pay union dues whether or not you're a member.
That issue of being compelled to pay union dues whether or not you're a member is the crux of the "right to work" debate (a bullshit term, because everyone always has the right to work, these laws are just about weakening unions and setting laws in favor of the owners).
But being compelled to join a union? In the U.S.? Nope, never.
On the other hand, if you _still_ think that's somehow unfair, you can go to one of those "right to work" states....
But, unions don't seem to want that, because they benefit greatly both from the power dynamic in closed shops and from this very argument (that anti-union workers are free-riders at best or scabs out for themselves at worst).
Off the top of my head, I could see entrenched businesses that already have union workers (ie. big auto manufacturers, ISP's, etc) want to make sure their competitors have to work with the union, too.
If I run a workplace where the union has marginal support, I might see an underfunded, unpopular union as more vulnerable than a smaller union with stronger support.
If the union has strong support, I'm probably better off with it representing everyone. A union that represents 80% of my workers would have almost as much leverage but less flexibility to make concessions.
I don't know if that kind of thing happens a lot in practice, but can you see how their interests aren't always going to be yours?