Re:Analysis of the United Airlines passenger removal incident
by hammock on Thursday April 20, 2017 @09:54AM
(#14156601)
>to claim trespass you first need to have the right to exclude the person. "I don't feel like performing my part of my contract with this person" doesn't get you there.
It doesn't? Trespass is criminal while a contract is civil. The police don't enforce contracts do they?
Further, I should be able to break a contract at will (how could that ability even be taken away?) and accept the consequences.
Re:Analysis of the United Airlines passenger removal incident
by ubernostrum on Thursday April 20, 2017 @12:28PM
(#14158161)
What you're arguing for is the ability to manufacture a crime on someone else's part, at will. I don't think you would enjoy living in a society which allows that.
And since the instruction to leave his seat may not have been a lawful/reasonable one, the other prong of the usual argument ("federal law requires compliance with crew member instructions") might not get there either.