News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by w1ntermute on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @02:35PM (#1414791)
This was invented and tested by the British over 150 years ago: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slip_coach

They stopped using them 50 years ago.

Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by Semiapies on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @02:46PM (#1414822)
Slip coaches manage the drop-off, but not the pick-up.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by w1ntermute on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @02:51PM (#1414843)
To reverse the journey, the passengers would board the slip coach at the intermediate station, which would then form part of a local train to the next station on the line where the express was scheduled to stop, and coupled to the express train there to be taken to its destination.

The concepts behind the drop-offs and the pick-ups are basically the same.

Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by Semiapies on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @04:24PM (#1415106)
You might watch the video. The train in this concept does not stop, unlike the case you describe above. It is certainly not "basically the same" unless you think this, slip-cars, car ferries, and modular cargo containers coming off a ship are all equivalent.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by electromagnetic on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @08:53PM (#1415762)
Yes, but this is not a dramatic new concept, it's a minor improvement in implementation because of decreased engineering costs and simply time.

This is nothing more than an elevated rail system and using a linear braking system to accelerate the stationary vehicle. Beyond that, we're talking simply precision and as the concept has yet to be implemented, the Chinese are no way more advanced with the concept than 50 years ago.

For all intent this is a worse design than having a tandem acceleration system in the trains and allowing the slip-car to simply accelerate itself to rejoin the express. You wouldn't even have to redesign your fleet, you'd only have to implement it in the slip-cars initially for the concept to work.

Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by Semiapies on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @12:48PM (#1417494)
Whether it's a good concept, I don't much care. It is simply and obviously wrong to say it's the same as a slip car, just as it's simply and obviously wrong to say a motorcycle is the same as a draisienne. Whether it's "dramatic" enough a new concept for someone is not my concern.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by seanos on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @04:29PM (#1415119)
The slip coach concept involves simply decoupling the last coach of the train so that it coasts into the station, therefore there is no equivalent for pick-ups - you can't just couple a coach to a fast moving train.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by VMG on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @10:01PM (#1415895)
Why not?
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by whimsy on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @03:23AM (#1416432)
Physics.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by srgseg on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @02:57PM (#1414862)
"In an era when the railway companies were highly competitive, they strove to keep journey times as short as possible, avoiding intermediate stops wherever possible".

Anyone know what made the railway companies less competitive? I had always assumed that since they each had a monopoly over the tracks in each region, they had no real incentives to innovate.

Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by coin on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @03:03PM (#1414882)
In the US, air travel made rail obsolete. For long distances (>500 miles) rail just can't compete with air. The was one of the main points in the book "Turbulent Skies: The History of Commercial Aviation" by T. A. Heppenheimer.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by ashbrahma on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @04:52PM (#1415196)
Another reason is that the freight companies own a vast majority of the rail tracks in the US which means freight trains get priority over passenger trains..
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by evgen on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @07:27PM (#1415582)
This only happened after the airlines stole most of the passenger traffic. By the 70s the rail vs flight curves had crossed and most passengers were on planes, after deregulation of the airlines the market for long-haul passenger carriage was owned by the airlines; the only thing left for railroads was freight and short-haul passenger traffic in populated corridors. When passengers were the bulk of the rail revenue stream the system was optimized in their favor, and when fright took over the conditions were inverted.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by ams6110 on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @08:37PM (#1415739)
The airlines did not "steal" the passenger traffic... they offered something people wanted... a journey lasting hours instead of days.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by evgen on Wednesday June 09, 2010 @12:23AM (#1416164)
I did not mean to imply that rail had any "right" to the passengers, just being a bit informal in the description. Faster transit was definitely the initial draw, but the implied status and luxury that early air travel provided was also important. The speed difference at the time was significant, but not as large as it is today -- NYC to Chicago was an overnight trip and you arrived blocks from the loop and in much better shape than you do today after enduring a similar trip.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by icefox on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @08:43PM (#1415748)
Not any more. These days it is easier and faster for me to drive 500 miles from Boston to Toronto then to fly. Wonder if I could take a train...
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by jrockway on Tuesday June 08, 2010 @09:29PM (#1415832)
You might have a case for Boston to NYC, but even with the 15 minute security check and the requirement to arrive 30 minutes before your flight leaves, you are still probably better off flying. In terms of time, that is.
Re:Clever Chinese trains without stops at stations (concept) by icefox on Thursday June 10, 2010 @12:36AM (#1419141)
The Boston to NYC trains are fantastic! I wouldn't fly between those two if I had the choice. Arrive in the city. Power plug on the train, tons of room. Real food. Cheap to do last minute. Not sure why anyone would want to fly between Boston any NYC these days.

As for Boston to Toronto I have done it many times the past two years before giving driving a try so I know how much time it actually takes. Door to door it was within a half hour of total traveling time, ton cheaper, real food, and the security at the boarder was not stupid. Driving I can go there whenever I want without needing to plans weeks in advance, adding another last minute person isn't a $2000 plane ticket, and I can change my return home plans on a whim. And as a bonus when I rent a cars I have been able to try out different models which I personally very much enjoy.