News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by holtalanm on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @10:41AM (#14139177)
Shows how far we have come as a nation when it comes to equal rights. When she ran the first time, there was blatant discrimination against her because of her gender. Nowadays, it ain't no thang.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by kevinmannix on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:29AM (#14139643)
While the most galvanizing image was the one where Jock Semple attempted to pull her off the course, another thing that disturbed me was Boston Athletic Association director Will Cloney's quote afterward: "If that girl were my daughter, I would spank her."
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by js2 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:30PM (#14141514)
I don't think he was trying to knock her from the course; I think his goal was to grab her bib.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by draw_down on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:12PM (#14140016)
Well, we're certainly not so blatant about it these days, that's for sure.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by jbmorgado on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @10:53AM (#14139279)
I'm not sure how the Boston marathon works, but in other marathons there is also a blatant gender discrimination, after all, you have separate start and ending and prizes for men and women.

If we aim for total indiscrimination, shouldn't we just have a single category, let anyone run as long as they don't have any unfair external advantage and just give prizes and recognition to the first places?

EDIT: I find it funny that some people got worked out for me writing it "out loud" the truth that positive gender discrimination in favour of one gender is also actually gender discrimination against other gender.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by Fezzik on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:13AM (#14139483)
I wouldn't say it is gender discrimination (today) so much as acknowledging the undeniable difference in physical capabilities of the sexes. The fastest female marathoners do not even remotely compete with the top men - top men run just a smidge over 2 hours, with the top women running 2:15:00+. Maybe someday there will be an equalizing of physical abilities, but that end does not seem to be in sight.

In fact, I don't think there is a single professional sport where women would even finish in the top 10 when competing against male opponents.

In the same vein, most sports have recreational, amateur, professional, and masters (older people) competitions, because there are undeniable physical differences between the old and the young. It doesn't have anything to do with ageism or discrimination. I mean, I can off-the-couch trounce any octogenarian in (probably?) any sport - pitting the two of us against one another is not really a competition, or fun, for either one of us.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by sndean on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:07PM (#14139982)
> The fastest female marathoners do not even remotely compete with the top men - top men run just a smidge over 2 hours, with the top women running 2:15:00+

Random side note: Interestingly, the shortest and longest races (at least out of Olympic events) are where men and women are most competitive [0]. And, when Paula Radcliffe ran 2:15 in 2003, the marathon world records for men and women were only separated by ~8%.

Compared to weightlifting, where male and female world records are separated by >25%, running is pretty close. Swimming, too. Perhaps that's intuitive.

[0] https://zigapskraba.com/2016/09/15/womens-world-records-comp...

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by nradov on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:37PM (#14140278)
How about target shooting? There's no physical reason that women and men couldn't compete on an equal basis in an Olympic event like 10m Air Rifle. Size and strength don't help.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by freehunter on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:47PM (#14142234)
I know absolutely nothing about air rifle shooting but your comment made me curious as to if there would actually be a difference. It looks like there is a massive difference in qualification shooting but not in the final score, not sure what the difference between qualification and final is and why it would have such an impact from the final scores.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/10_meter_air_rifle#Post_1_Janu...

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by nradov on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @06:23PM (#14143559)
It's right there in the article. Men are allowed more shots in the qualification round, hence their higher scores.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by jbmorgado on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:29AM (#14139654)
I see, aren't we denying people that are better at the job to compete this way just because of their gender? Clearly this must be gender discrimination.

Let me explain: If I divide a competition between 100 men and 100 women instead of the 200 best humans and then give prizes to the 3 best men and 3 best women instead of the 6 best humans, I'm actually denying place to 100 men and denying 3 men a prize just because of their gender (assuming as true your predicate that men timings are clearly superior to woman).

Isn't it funny how this is not gender based discrimination?

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by whafro on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @01:49PM (#14141091)
In the Boston marathon, only the elite runners (a few dozen) are segmented by gender/sex, and elite women are the first to leave, followed by the elite men, followed by the top qualifying times of either gender.

From watching the race along the road yesterday, there were no elite men who caught the main pack of women (though a few straggling women did fall back into the elite male pack). Following that, while it was mostly a male non-elite pack at the beginning, there were a few women scattered throughout, and then it was fairly blended about 15 minutes later.

So while they stagger men and women to prevent interference in the race at the very highest levels (and a woman crosses the finish line first), women below that tier have a ton of opportunity to push themselves against men.

Edit: Also, they do track overall finishers, time-wise, regardless of gender. So a woman might see that she was the 4th finisher in her division (young women), and 16th overall.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by js2 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:26PM (#14141464)
Thank you for cheering yesterday. This was my third Boston. The Boston Marathon is an experience that in my mind is unique in sport.

The analogy I make is this. It's like getting to play on the field after the Super Bowl or World Series or World Cup just after the pros leave the field with a bunch of other amateurs while the crowd is still there cheering for you.

I can't think of another sport where you get to participate on the same field of play right after the pros and the fans are still there for you.

In Boston especially the entire city treats the runners like royalty the whole weekend and Marathon Monday. Everyone asks how you did. It's truly amazing and I'm honored and thankful I can participate.

I've run other big city marathons including New York and Chicago and while they are great races too, there's really nothing like Boston.

So again, thank you. And if you're a runner of any sort and the marathon is at all appealing to you, do the work you have to do to get to Boston. Making that left turn on Boylston and running to that finish ... I just have no words to describe the thrill.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by stygiansonic on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:58PM (#14141795)
Great way to sum up the experience of the Boston Marathon; glad to hear from another HNer who also did Boston yesterday.

I agree that if you're at all interested in marathons, the effort to qualify for and run in Boston is well worth it. I've done it a few times and the experience is never short of magical.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by tspiteri on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @05:21PM (#14143039)
IIRC women have to start before men for their records to hold, as otherwise women could gain from the faster men's slip stream. Of course, there are still pace makers so even men can take advantage of that, and men can run behind each other and their records would still hold. I think the reasoning is that at least they're running behind/ahead of racers who are competing with them, whereas if women and men started together, the front runners of the women's race would be able to run behind men with whom they are not really competing, and who would thus be less careful about giving them a lift.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by burkaman on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:47PM (#14140395)
Discrimination has multiple definitions. You're using the general definition, which is just "recognizing the difference between two things". Gender discrimination uses the other definition, "the unjust or prejudicial treatment of different categories of people or things". Gender discrimination in sports is usually not unjust or prejudicial, because it's based on real insurmountable biological differences between the sexes.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by anigbrowl on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @04:42PM (#14142725)
No, it's not funny to most people because most people have a more nuanced and thoughtful understanding of the subject than you do.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by pg314 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:03AM (#14139377)
Barring one gender from participating is not the same thing as having different categories per gender. There are also different categories for different age groups. That is just a reflection of the difference in athletic abilities.

No reasonable person is claiming that men and women have the same athletic abilities. That doesn't mean women shouldn't be allowed to run.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by nradov on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @09:44PM (#14144810)
The lower age group categories are kind of silly. The oldest Boston Marathon winner was 41 so I think it's only fair to group everyone at or below that age compete in a single category.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by jbmorgado on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:11AM (#14139457)
I never defended that women shouldn't be allowed to run, quite on the contrary. I just find it odd that people keep pushing for equal access and opportunities but then gladly accept complete gender discrimination in some occasions like these ones.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by stanmancan on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:33AM (#14139693)
Understanding and recognizing the physical differences between men and women is in fact discrimination, but not in the way you're using it.

Events have different age groups as we recognize children, teens, adults, and mature adults have different physical capabilities. Should we get rid of age groups?

Many sports have weight classes as we recognize that a 150LB fighter is most likely at a disadvantage compared to a 260LB fighter. Should we get rid of weight classes?

There are plenty more examples available and are no different than having different events for men vs women.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by croon on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @01:01PM (#14140527)
By your definition weight classes in fighting is discrimination. That is clearly not usable for the discussion.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by sethev on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:28AM (#14139638)
Do you feel the same way about age range based prizes or golf handicaps?
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by jbmorgado on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:34AM (#14139706)
Handicap is not used in professional golf neither is age range, it's the best against the best.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by SamReidHughes on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @01:01PM (#14140530)
It is in a few tournaments. The Wendy's 3-tour Challenge and the JCPenney Classic were two with mixed gender, players teeing off from different tees. (Seniors in the 3-tour Challenge had a closer tee, women even closer.)
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by c0de9 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @01:11PM (#14140645)
The PGA champions tour is restricted to ages 50+
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by sethev on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:01PM (#14139933)
You're mixing meanings of discrimination. Barring women from participating in an event is completely separate from how prizes are handed out. Mixing these two senses of the word 'discrimination' like your doing is equivocation. "Isn't it odd how people argue for equal rights but are perfectly willing to only turn left in some cases." No - it's not odd at all. Words can have multiple senses.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by jbmorgado on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:20PM (#14140096)
You clearly (either willingly because it suits your narrative or because you didn't actually read anything) are accusing me of something I not only clearly didn't do but something that I actually spoke against.

Again: I'm all for opening doors for everyone that "doesn't have any unfair external advantage" (i.e. doping) to compete. What I'm questioning is barring the fastest runners from competition and from the prizes just because of their gender.

In no way I was asking for barring anyone from anything, so stop mixing everything up just to suit your narrative.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by vidarh on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:48PM (#14140407)
They're not barred from competing. They're split into different subsets to more closely match them with people with similar potential exactly to make the races more competitive.

I would have some sympathy for your argument if you argue against womens only races or men only races, but most sports do not arbitrarily deny access to a given group, but split people into groups and try to counter effects beyond competitors control, such as gender, age, so that training plays a bigger role in the results distribution.

The point is that we are seeking to give prices to those who have gotten closest to their maximum potential, not for their genetic starting point or circumstances. Yes, we can not counter everything without splitting things up too much, but we can aim to equalise the playing field somewhat.

This is not discrimination. This is seeking to reduce "unfair external advantage". It's the opposite of discrimination.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by sethev on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:01PM (#14141224)
You're the one who's muddying the water by using a second sense of the word discrimination when everybody else is talking about the first.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by songshu on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:01AM (#14139362)
That would work if we didn't tend to organize events which favor men. As it is, athletic and sporting events have mostly been constructed around male affinities so your supposed indiscrimination would result in women being sidelined on the whole.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by adrianN on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:13AM (#14139476)
Men are better at sports. That's no social construct. Having men and women compete on equal footing would result in women always losing.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by songshu on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:25AM (#14139596)
To be clear I'm claiming that the individual sports themselves are socially constructed, not that "betterness" is. Women's bodies have advantages in flexibility and stamina. Had women been socially dominant for centuries I would expect us to have come up with sports which demonstrate their strengths.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by Karunamon on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:27AM (#14139610)
Marathons aren't a stamina sport?
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by jrkatz on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:19PM (#14141392)
A lot of people underestimate the speed of marathon running, probably because the distance alone is so intimidating. However, winning times hover around 5 minutes per mile, a speed I'd wager most able-bodied people cannot hit at all, let alone sustain. Marathons are a stamina sport and a speed sport.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by adrianN on Wednesday April 19, 2017 @02:51AM (#14145989)
There is no distance where women beat men, even for longer races that are most definitely endurance events:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultramarathon#IAU_World_Best_P...

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by slavik81 on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @02:50PM (#14141713)
It blew my mind when I realized that top marathon runners did 42k at a faster pace than my 5k.
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by outragejunkie on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @12:55PM (#14140471)
Who is "us" in this circumstance? Is someone preventing women from inventing this mystical sport where they will excel?

Also; sports are constructed by individuals, not society. Society has no agency and no cognition. It is a leaky abstraction mainly used by poor thinkers to make incorrect rhetorical points. It doesn't actually "do" anything absent individual human action.

Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by ythn on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @11:04AM (#14139386)
Seems like that is starting to go away though, what with trans women being able to unfairly compete with cis women
[dead]
Re:The first woman to finish the Boston Marathon in 1967 has... by jbmorgado on Tuesday April 18, 2017 @03:04PM (#14141850)
Lovely to see ad hominen attacks are fine as long as it's against someone that doesn't share the extreme prejudiced views of the few that control the voting system in HN about social matters.