Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is...
by tel on Sunday April 16, 2017 @03:38PM
(#14127127)
Different "monad", unfortunately.
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is...
by BucketSort on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:46PM
(#14127416)
Forgive my ignorance!
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is...
by IgorPartola on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:00PM
(#14127213)
If god was all powerful, he could create a rock he himself could not lift.
If god was all knowing, he could create a cryptosystem he himself could not break.
God is a bad measure of physical properties. Some things are just unknown.
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is...
by boulos on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:08PM
(#14127247)
I was expecting you to add: "Could Jesus microwave a burrito so hot that he himself could not eat it?"
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is...
by posterboy on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:24PM
(#14127335)
Chuck Norris could create a rock so heavy he himself could not lift it ... and then he would lift it.
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is...
by yeahGreat on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:44PM
(#14127404)
It's not funny anymore.
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is...
by rexpop on Sunday April 16, 2017 @03:49PM
(#14127175)
This is awesome! I am definitely going to read some Leibniz after this. Would you recommend his Monadology?
To say "only God can understand the future" is an unnecessary personification of our incompleteness. I think the future of declarative functions is pretty clear. Today foo(x) = 2x, tomorrow foo(x) = 2x. Anything we can't say is simply a dearth of information. How useful is it to say we've a dearth of "future information"?
Anyway, we give names to sets of propositions, and that's a neat trick.
Re:A monoid is a category, a category is a monad, a monad is...
by catawbasam on Sunday April 16, 2017 @04:01PM
(#14127216)
"an unnecessary personification of our incompleteness."
Not unnecessary according to Leibniz. See e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monadology
So to Leibniz, in the conception of an entity's identity, he posits that one must include all propositions related to that entity. So when we try to consider a property of an object of our mind, we are basically saying "it is what it is." Saying that Einstein is German is like saying "Einstein is Einstein." Where this conception of including propositions in identities gets weird is that his formulation also includes future propositions. In this respect, only God can truly understand anything fully, because only he can tell the future and can get the full identity of things.
So "x is x" shows up a lot.
Edit: As mentioned, Leibniz Monad != the Monad of category theory. I suppose I'm just looking for any excuse to talk about Leibniz. Also, I did say I didn't even get to that topic yet. Consider this a peep about the duality of that term.