This is an instance of it: Uber has shown in the past that they can wield considerable powers, and are prone to misuse it. Therefore, them collecting data about drivers, a population that is vulnerable towards Uber (and a subset of which we know is shared between the two platforms), is dangerous.
If you approach this dichotomy from the other side, can you imagine the NSA being described as doing no-brainer customer research ?
Also the NSA is doing a lot worse things and we know this for certain. I find it distressing how many people seemingly have forgotten about that. If the NSA were only going this far, I'd be pretty happy.
No it isn't. Not according to the article. According to the article a fraction of that information is provided as part of the app but Uber went ahead and exploited the lack of operational security on Lyft's side to crawl _all_ the information by traversing over information intended for other users. Repeatedly.
Pretty sure HN would agree with that.
The ethical line is "what is publically available following all laws and regulations".