Re:In Search of Zoroastrian Manuscripts in Iran
by redsummer on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @06:20PM
(#14102265)
In the case of Judaism, Israel makes Orthodox conversion more useful since it doesn't accept you as a real Jew if you are a convert to a more weak tea version of Judaism. People who convert are usually stronger believers, so they would convert to the more undiluted version of the religion anyway.
On the other hand, 'cultural' Jews are more likely to marry non-Jews, and absorb them into Judaism that way. And I suppose this leads to cultural Jews leaving Judaism too. I think I read somewhere that the descendants of all the founders of Reform Judaism ended up outside Judaism.
Re:In Search of Zoroastrian Manuscripts in Iran
by dragonwriter on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @06:32PM
(#14102351)
> People who convert are usually stronger believers, so they would convert to the more undiluted version of the religion anyway.
That doesn't follow; converts are very often quite passionate about the beliefs of the group they convert to, and it's distinction form others, but that doesn't mean that they necessarily prefer the version that is seen as most pure by outsiders.
Re:In Search of Zoroastrian Manuscripts in Iran
by fusiongyro on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @06:28PM
(#14102331)
Israel will accept you for making aliyah with any conversion (or none, if you have even a small amount of Jewish blood). Being a "real Jew" in the eyes of Israel may have some cachet for someone... but I don't know anybody who made a decision about which movement to convert in on that basis. I also doubt seriously that the Orthodox movement experiences more conversion than the other movements. It's smaller than either the Reform or Conservative movements.
Re:In Search of Zoroastrian Manuscripts in Iran
by redsummer on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @06:42PM
(#14102412)
"In Israel, only Orthodox conversions are recognized"
http://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/10/10/445343896/i...
Re:In Search of Zoroastrian Manuscripts in Iran
by fusiongyro on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @06:56PM
(#14102519)
For making aliyah, you do not have to have an Orthodox conversion. This issue really only comes up for marriage. And of course, Israel has (in their typical fashion) chosen the solution guaranteed to annoy the most people.
Re:In Search of Zoroastrian Manuscripts in Iran
by redsummer on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @07:07PM
(#14102581)
That's the theory, but not the practice:
Re:In Search of Zoroastrian Manuscripts in Iran
by yazaddaruvala on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @06:17PM
(#14102251)
FWIW, they way I say this is,
You can convert to Judaism, but you can only be born a Jew.
i.e. The difference between a religion and an association with a culture.
Re:In Search of Zoroastrian Manuscripts in Iran
by fusiongyro on Wednesday April 12, 2017 @06:24PM
(#14102296)
I don't think any practicing Jew would make a distinction there. But Judaism predates distinctions of this sort—a fact that I think has irritated Western thought for thousands of years.
The situation in Iran is complicated. Zoroastrianism is a protected group there, but it's extremely dangerous to be seen as welcoming converts in the Islamic republic. Simultaneously, to convert away is basically to accede a small amount of political power. I've heard (especially in Religion in Iran[2]) that there may be a Zoroastrian movement taking shape; as converts, those folks would certainly be welcoming of converts, but it's likely to make the established group anxious because if it gains too much attention it will lead to persecution of all Zoroastrians in Iran. So you have two overlapping marginal groups each trying to exaggerate the figures in opposite directions—which is sort of thematic for the kind of contradictions you see in Iran generally.
[1]: http://www.huffingtonpost.ca/byblackscom/rachel-dolezal-is-n...
[2]: https://www.amazon.com/Religions-Iran-Prehistory-Richard-Fol...