News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by Animats on Sunday April 09, 2017 @05:50PM (#14074543)
Pratt has to say that because Toyota is so far behind. He was hired to build up a self-driving group within Toyota.
Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by xfs on Sunday April 09, 2017 @07:29PM (#14074897)
TRI's association with UMich and MIT makes them more biased towards issues about the difficulty of running self-driving cars in adverse weather conditions because that's the problem that all the researchers at UMich and MIT have had all the time and it's a problem that Google/Stanford have never had in always sunny California.

I have personally heard of the complaints of John Leonard (MIT) and Edwin Olson (UMich) about the severe lack of research of self-driving car robustness in weather conditions. The issue is real.

Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by abalone on Sunday April 09, 2017 @11:33PM (#14075802)
Ok then, how about Waymo's ex-lead Chris Urmson. "If you read the papers, you see maybe it's three years, maybe it's thirty years. And I am here to tell you that honestly, it's a bit of both."[1]

He goes on to explain that easier domains may come sooner (so maybe level 4), but his comments certainly pour some cold water on level 5.

[1] http://spectrum.ieee.org/cars-that-think/transportation/self...

Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by dkarapetyan on Sunday April 09, 2017 @06:52PM (#14074759)
How is Toyota behind? Don't they have an entire robotics division? Google, Uber, and all the other guys had to cobble together something that looks like a robotics division but Toyota has all of that already figured out.

I think if anyone pulls this off it is Toyota.

Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday April 09, 2017 @07:02PM (#14074792)
Robotics has little to do with self-driving cars at this point, which is heavily ML dependent while the former hasn't been so far (yet, that's changing).
Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by dkarapetyan on Sunday April 09, 2017 @07:09PM (#14074824)
So if you were a betting man what would you go with. A bunch of software folks that don't really understand robotics. Or a bunch of robotics folks that learn some ML.

I think the ML is the easy part. The real engineering in making these things truly production ready is the hard part. Only few places in the world have that kind of production expertise. Toyota being one such place.

Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday April 09, 2017 @07:19PM (#14074854)
You keep assuming a self driving car strongly resembles a traditional industrial robotics at all.

The actual actuating part of a self-driving car is fairly easy (just turn the wheel, apply the breaks), it is the control system and sensing that is key to success, the former being software, and the latter (LIDAR) that Google is heavily invested in while Toyota is very late to that game.

Right now, if I was a betting man, Google will beat Toyota. Of course, Toyota could always flip the table and take some risks, but that isn't what Toyota is known for. If it happens great! But I don't think any smart money sees Toyota having a clear advantage ATM.

Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by dkarapetyan on Sunday April 09, 2017 @07:22PM (#14074868)
I think you're downplaying the actual engineering required. Robotics is more than just actuators. Robotics folks have been doing sensor fusion, control, and learning for much longer than software ML folks have been doing those same things.

I'm saying a software company is not gonna crack the market. Software companies neither have the expertise nor the engineering discipline. Boston Robotics and Google have been famously not getting along and their self-driving division seems to have been horribly mismanaged for a long time and we are now seeing the fallout in the form of lawsuits.

Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday April 09, 2017 @07:48PM (#14074975)
http://www.toyota-global.com/innovation/partner_robot/histor...

Industrial robots, and humanoid robots for entertainment purposes. Whereas Google has many of the founders of ML, not to mention its experts. Is Toyota, who already seriously undervalue software, willing to pay top dollar for those people when their average SDE makes < $60K/year (not just a problem with Toyota, but Japan in general)?

You also seriously misunderstanding the amount of engineering discipline needed to build modern software systems.

Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by dkarapetyan on Sunday April 09, 2017 @08:18PM (#14075075)
Misunderstanding? Given that my day job is to literally build tools and infrastructure for "modern software systems" I don't think I'm misunderstanding things at all.

But whatever I can say on "modern software" has already been said much better by Alan Kay so I'm going to defer to him for the rest of this conversation.

I'll buy Toyota stock. You buy Google stock. We'll compare notes in a decade and see who managed to make self-driving cars commercially viable.

Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday April 09, 2017 @08:50PM (#14075210)
I guess you'll find Toyota stock to be incredibly undervalued with a P/E of just 9.5 vs. GOOG's 30.26. The market isn't treating Toyota like a tech company. The market has already spoken, they've placed their bet on Google, which means that boat has already sailed. If you believe TM will make a tremendous comeback, then you could make bank, but that is a risky bet vs. a safe one (given today's information).
Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by flamedoge on Monday April 10, 2017 @04:12AM (#14076825)
I'll just twiddle my thumb and look bullish on Tesla
Re:Unreasonable Ineffectiveness of Machine Learning in Compu... by bryanrasmussen on Sunday April 09, 2017 @09:33PM (#14075395)
I'm betting it also has to accelerate and decelerate at appropriate times.