> Is Earth – the planet itself – alive?
not according to the definition i just looked up. depending on what you mean, the earth is 'simply' a ball of mud hurtling through space, or it's something more akin to a label for the complex emergent system composed of many individual instances of LivingObject.
> But what about free will?
how are we defining "free will"?
> ball of mud
I am afraid, geologists (and many other people) might disagree with this characterization. They find the composition of our planet an extremely fascinating subject.
Is Earth – the planet itself – alive?
> "What is consciousness" will probably go the same way in time.
But what about free will?