News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by Animats on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:31PM (#14068257)
This seems to be the old homunculus argument in another form.[1]

As knowledge of how brains work increases, this will probably become a non-issue. A big question for millenia was "what is life?" This question continued through the discovery of bacteria, and later, DNA. As the lower level mechanisms of biology were understood, it stopped being a question. Bacteria are alive, and are reasonably well understood. The components of bacteria are not quite alive, but are also understood. (There's still some argument over whether viruses are alive, but that's now just an argument over the definition.) "What is life" is now a "go look it up" question, not a mystery.

"What is consciousness" will probably go the same way in time.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homunculus_argument

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by Razengan on Saturday April 08, 2017 @05:11PM (#14069066)
Suppose we build some robots with AI and send them to space, and they land on some planet.

Those robots can mine raw materials and build other robots like themselves.

They can learn, and teach, and improve their designs and invent new things.

Fast forward a few hundred years. The planet now hosts a civilization of robots, with their own culture, planning their own excursions into space.

To someone searching for Life™ and Intelligence™ in the cosmos, what would make our robot civilization fail to be qualified as such?

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by visarga on Sunday April 09, 2017 @12:34AM (#14070482)
An external observer should realize that robots are self replicators (like people) that fend for themselves in the environment (like people, again), by a complex process of adaptation to external situations, moment by moment (yep, like us).
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by Razengan on Sunday April 09, 2017 @04:29AM (#14071143)
And yet, when we make them here, everyone will consider them to be only "artificially" intelligent, and they certainly won't be "alive" because, well, no cells and no DNA and stuff.

So the GP's comment about life being a "go look it up" question is debatable at best. Expect the definition to change over the centuries.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by Razengan on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:35PM (#14068276)
> "What is life" is now a "go look it up" question, not a mystery.

Is Earth – the planet itself – alive?

> "What is consciousness" will probably go the same way in time.

But what about free will?

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by abiox on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:53PM (#14068355)
> Is Earth – the planet itself – alive?

not according to the definition i just looked up. depending on what you mean, the earth is 'simply' a ball of mud hurtling through space, or it's something more akin to a label for the complex emergent system composed of many individual instances of LivingObject.

> But what about free will?

how are we defining "free will"?

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by Koshkin on Saturday April 08, 2017 @04:34PM (#14068863)
> ball of mud

I am afraid, geologists (and many other people) might disagree with this characterization. They find the composition of our planet an extremely fascinating subject.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by abiox on Saturday April 08, 2017 @05:23PM (#14069113)
oh, certainly. i once took a geology class without much expectations, and found it tremendously fascinating. very interesting stuff!
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by sametmax on Saturday April 08, 2017 @03:08PM (#14068444)
I'm a bit dumb. If it's not a mystery anymore, can you tell me in a sentence what life is, in a way everybody scientifically agree ?
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by Koshkin on Saturday April 08, 2017 @04:22PM (#14068803)
Obviously, the word 'life' has multiple meanings; at the most fundamental - and I'd say, the least interesting - level it is the now pretty well-understood mode of collective behavior as well as the variety of processes and mechanisms that have naturally evolved to ensure the perpetual existence of a mass of large molecules of a certain kind (viz. proteins).
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by visarga on Sunday April 09, 2017 @12:36AM (#14070487)
In short, self replication in a complex environment where the replicators have to find resources (energy and nutrients), cooperate and compete against other agents.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by sametmax on Sunday April 09, 2017 @05:46AM (#14071389)
That's a very mechanical definition. Do you mean that if we create a robot with a decent IA enough to do that we would have created life ?