News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by buhrmi on Saturday April 08, 2017 @01:38PM (#14068000)
no
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by lutusp on Saturday April 08, 2017 @01:45PM (#14068028)
a. You're conscious.

b. You're composed of matter.

c. Therefore some matter is conscious.

d. What's true for some matter might be true for all matter --- or not. That's the "hard problem" of consciousness.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by bitL on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:10PM (#14068151)
For all we know, our brain can be just an interface to something else we don't know yet. Like when nobody knew what radioactivity was, miners thought some monsters resided deep inside Earth, illuminating caves and mines in green, and anybody that got nearby died soon afterwards. Quantum theory spawned a lot of scientism at the beginning of 20th Century, attributing consciousness properties down to atomic level, and this seems to be the case with each new generation, falling into the same though a bit more refined scientistic trap.

Just for fun:

If we play with the idea of Platonic Theory of Forms as a super-set of what we can perceive with our sens-es(-ors), under assumption philosophy/math is above reality, we can simply be plugged into some kind of a virtual machine with some API of sorts (of course undocumented) that is called by our brains when we think. Those who figured out some rare API calls on their own or by a secret tradition we call magicians, conjurers, gurus, Neo etc. Maybe words/thoughts could invoke some of those API functions, hence magic Harry-Potter-esque words and generally prayers in many religions. Similarly, what we call angels could be simply API services with highly intelligent behavior, preferably operating outside time, providing verifiable and expected outcome. Demons then are some intelligent services gone completely wrong, messing up with the rest of intelligent services that depend upon them, playing eternal asynchronous byzantine generals (by e.g. trying to upgrade all services to Windows 10 or flat interfaces with telemetry /s).

I think I should write a dystopian cyberpunk sci-fi "Services and Daemons" about this ;-)

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by Eerie on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:40PM (#14068299)
>For all we know, our brain can be just an interface to something else we don't know yet.

This is a very old, but unproven hypothesis. You might have heard of it, it's called "soul". :-)

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by qb45 on Saturday April 08, 2017 @03:13PM (#14068474)
No, it's a novel idea called SaaS - soul as a service. The OP probably is already making money on it while you sit here posting dismissive comments.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by bitL on Saturday April 08, 2017 @03:42PM (#14068606)
Yes, indeed. We need to assume "soul" resides in the cloud. What we don't know is the soul ID - a very secret API exists only a few soul-hackers were able to find but soon demons causing madness were unleashed on them after each intrusion was detected. So only a few chosen services know IDs, allowing them a direct access to souls in the Great Hash Map of Souls, hence why knowing a name means having a power over a soul. Of course, soul ID is innately incorporated in each individual brain itself, but encryption is too strong even for bad services to break into, unless soul allows voluntarily to be possessed by calling a secret black magic APIs. The rest of services need to perform long and tiring searches in the Great Array of Souls (GAS) and match with secondary characteristics of the soul like virtues and vices, instead of ID.

Of course, we found a novel meta-parallel way to access souls in the GAS reducing the search complexity to O(Sqrt(n)), hence we make a lot of money exposing this API externally for a fee. Do you want to make somebody lucky? Arrange a life situation that looks like magic? Any enemies that should taste fear of damnation? Please visit www.soul-as-a-service.com to know more!

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by visarga on Sunday April 09, 2017 @01:06AM (#14070587)
What's the role of the brain if decisions are handed down from the API? Couldn't we have made due with just the spine and a few extra parts of the brain. How does it communicate to the API? Is the API vulnerable to physical effects, being linked to the brain? All these considerations have been explored thoroughly since Descartes and dualism.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by bitL on Sunday April 09, 2017 @03:26PM (#14073913)
Obviously there is a lot of verified intelligent behavior on neural level we know about, like image processing, 3D reconstruction & mapping, motion planning, sound recognition, voice synthesis etc. And we more-less have some simplified models like that in the form of deep learning. So imagine brain as a sensor processing engine for inputs happening in the vicinity of a person inside "Simuverse". Even computing possible actions to take and attaching some utility value of each of them or starting upon acting on the best solution found so far already. Now for the decision process to be complete, brain passes results of this computation to the API that then invokes consciousness in the "soulspace" which is of another yet unknown quality, making the decision ;-) There is some interface latency of course, so some default actions are needed by brain, but consciousness can override them within 0.5s. Brain could be seen as an equivalent of cyberspace, consciousness might be coming from another principle we aren't aware of or don't have proper scientific devices to measure yet (if that is even possible).

Remember, each age views humans differently. Previous civilizations viewed humans first as based on magic, then hydraulics, then mechanics, then electricity, now we view them via lens of information processing, as our Zeitgeist dictates. It's likely people in 100 years will be laughing at us and our stupidity (hopefully they will be more advanced and not in a dark age), after they crack more things about Universe.

Obviously, this doesn't explain phenomena like brain exhibiting multiple different persons inside for patients with schizophrenia or when connection between left and right hemisphere is broken - some experiments shown people behave like as if there were multiple persons inside fighting with each other. Perhaps a bug in the nexus when there is a hash collision somewhere? 8-)

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by visarga on Saturday April 08, 2017 @01:58PM (#14068102)
Yes, but many people still think there is magic fairy dust sprinkled into our brains that make them special. It's hard to comprehend that we are not magical, just the same matter as in all the physical world.

A failure of vision or imagination on their part. They don't realize that the universe, plain and physical as it is, is capable of consciousness and thus "sacred". For them the world is just dust. I believe the world is plenty mysterious and special without imaginary friends in the sky.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by qb45 on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:52PM (#14068351)
Sure you can reject religion. Then it all boils down to whose model of the not-yet-really-understood is more accurate and who will eat whom on the top of the food chain ;)

Take this: N years ago, for some value of N, nobody talked about friends in the sky. Now they do.

Atheism: myth busted :)

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by abiox on Saturday April 08, 2017 @03:06PM (#14068436)
> Sure you can reject religion. Then it all boils down to whose model of the not-yet-really-understood is more accurate and who will eat whom on the top of the food chain ;)

this seems to be the case regardless of religion.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by lutusp on Saturday April 08, 2017 @04:05PM (#14068725)
> Atheism: myth busted :)

If we find "friends in the sky," i.e. alien intelligences, that would be as likely to argue against religion as for it. Consider the dilemma posed for Christians by the idea of another planet with another intelligent species. That would challenge their core belief that we were shaped in a deity's image -- a deity imagined to rule the entire universe.

Re:Is Matter Conscious? by abiox on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:39PM (#14068296)
this seems like a potential composition fallacy.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by lutusp on Saturday April 08, 2017 @04:01PM (#14068699)
Yes, had I positively asserted the claim about all matter on the basis of some of it. But I won't do that. Rocks might just be rocks. And compared to some hypothetical beings far more advanced than we are, we might be rocks.
Re:Is Matter Conscious? by pixie_ on Saturday April 08, 2017 @02:00PM (#14068108)
It's great taking the time to read a large insightful article, and then coming to the comments to see an insightful post like this.