News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here?

The other day greyman wondered whether AMA threads on HN might be a good idea (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1400815)

Joshu pulled off a very successful AMA here the other week (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1356140) and I believe another one happened in the past too (can't find link at the moment). I've wondered about doing a QA for my field (computer forensics) because it often generates interest/emails when I talk about it.

On the other hand meta threads and "Ask" posting is often discouraged.

AMA's have proven very interesting on Reddit and I figure here we would get:

- even more interesting people

- better/insightful questions (or at least a better signal/noise ratio)

Hence, a brief straw poll.

I divided up Yes into two categories, purely for the fact that people may prefer a limited interest field.

( 12 comments | 14 points | on HN )

Poll

Yes, just startup/entrepeneur 18 votes
Yes, any field (if intellectually curious) 70 votes
No 17 votes
Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by philwelch on Friday June 04, 2010 @08:45PM (#1406073)
Compared to Reddit, I would hope we also get fewer trolls and fakes.
Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by justlearning on Friday June 04, 2010 @06:53PM (#1405882)
Intellectually curious? Wouldn't every profession/work have some level of advice for startups/entrepreneurs based on experiences? I believe stories from a full time fisherman will be as helpful as a stock-trader's - to anyone who wants to learn. Same may hold true for a drug dealer. (imho)

Why filter it with "intellectually curious"? How do we define 'intellectually curious'?

Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by ErrantX on Friday June 04, 2010 @06:57PM (#1405893)
Same way we filter normal submissions (I used the same terminology as the guidelines).

Your examples (stock trader / fisherman / drug dealer) strike me as pretty interesting careers, outliers if you will - they would flag my intellectual curiosity :)

Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by wanderr on Saturday June 05, 2010 @04:36AM (#1406645)
I did an AMA on Reddit and have to admit it was pretty fun. As a programmer, I was a bit disappointed that the questions were not very technical or in depth for the most part. I'd bet that the AMA questions would be a lot more relevant here.
Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by michael_nielsen on Friday June 04, 2010 @06:15PM (#1405816)
I enjoyed joshu's AMA, and I expect I'd get lots out of other AMAs. But I wouldn't want them to dominate the front page. I think no more than one or two a day. I'm not sure how to ensure that.
Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by Sirocco on Friday June 04, 2010 @09:11PM (#1406105)
I, too, fall into the "possibly one or two a week max" category. Over at Reddit, they seem more like a vehicle for narcissism than anything else. Once in a great while a person with a genuinely interesting profession comes along, but the signal to noise ratio over there is nowhere near where I'd like it to be.
Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by ErrantX on Friday June 04, 2010 @06:20PM (#1405825)
> I think no more than one or two a day

I was thinking that number a week, max, myself actually :)

(in realistic terms I suspect the community is generally much smaller/niche here than on HN so there are just not the diverse numbers to have so many AMA's)

Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by s810 on Friday June 04, 2010 @10:58PM (#1406254)
Allowing AMAs is a slippery slope toward TILs and YSKs.
Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by jimmyswimmy on Friday June 04, 2010 @10:06PM (#1406185)
Please no! I come here to learn. I go to reddit for AMA and jokes and other ways to waste time. This is Hacker News not chitchat time.
Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by 0ffworlder on Friday June 04, 2010 @06:45PM (#1405862)
No
Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by ErrantX on Friday June 04, 2010 @06:58PM (#1405896)
Any reasoning (genuine curiosity)?
Re:Poll HN: Should we encourage "AMA" threads here? by 0ffworlder on Thursday June 10, 2010 @03:36PM (#1421344)
I fear HN would turn into reddit.