Re:Readability Updated: An End To The Yank Of The Hyperlink
by nhebb on Saturday June 05, 2010 @05:57AM
(#1406702)
I think historically footnotes have been of lower value to the reader than links
I must have OCFD (obsessive-compulsive footnote disorder). I feel compelled to read every footnote.
Years ago I read the first ~100 pages of The Sound and the Fury, then stopped. It still bugs me that I never finished it. Unread footnotes are like that.
The distraction in this context is not defined by the presence or absence of text, it's the perceived value of the content there. I think historically footnotes have been of lower value to the reader than links. Take wikipedia as an example: for info that is absolutely necessary to understand the article there is a link, and for further reading or references there is a footnote. Maybe we have been conditioned to think links are necessary reading because of their historical use, and that's why one camp sees them as "more distracting."