Re:The 'Grammar Vigilante' of Bristol [video]
by jdietrich on Monday April 03, 2017 @09:24AM
(#14022549)
>I think it's just simply wrong to do anything to something that belongs to someone else without their permission unless you absolutely have to.
If your neighbour had gone out and left their front door open, would you close it for them? If your front lawn crossed the boundary into their property, would you mow the whole lawn? It's not a clear-cut moral or legal issue.
Re:The 'Grammar Vigilante' of Bristol [video]
by chrisseaton on Monday April 03, 2017 @09:31AM
(#14022589)
I would close their door (if the situation is as simple as you describe) because I think there is a clear need.
I wouldn't mow their property without asking them.
Amusing yourself by making a petty point about grammar doesn't even begin to come close to being as reasonable as either of your two examples.
Re:The 'Grammar Vigilante' of Bristol [video]
by Asooka on Monday April 03, 2017 @08:09AM
(#14022147)
It's on the street and I have no choice in seeing it or not. You're entering my mind without permission, I'm just reclaiming what is mine.
This is the Banksy argument, and it's crazy. When you walk down the street, your face enters the minds of others without permission.
Which is the justification for disallowing overly offensive clothing and behaviour.
Now you might say that displaying a grammar error isn't anywhere near as offensive as nudity, not even if the grammar error is displayed in the most prominent fashion available to the shop, and for years on end. But I don't think that's a given. It is at least discussable.
Re:The 'Grammar Vigilante' of Bristol [video]
by stryk on Monday April 03, 2017 @09:54AM
(#14022744)
"Overly offensive" to whom? Who is the arbiter of what is "offensive" or not? That is far too subjective to be enforced evenly. 'Society' is not an acceptable answer either, every individual has different viewpoints.
Re:The 'Grammar Vigilante' of Bristol [video]
by Arnt on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @04:08AM
(#14030491)
Sounds as if you're proving that widely-accepted laws are impossible, peelian policework, etc. "It cannot be done to the taste of absolutely all, therefore it cannot be done at all."
Re:The 'Grammar Vigilante' of Bristol [video]
by stryk on Tuesday April 04, 2017 @08:18AM
(#14031704)
Oh that's not fair now, come on. My comment was in response to, and concerning, the notion of "overly offensive clothing" and in that narrow instance, your quote is on point -- albeit a tad condescending (not that you were, just that quote itself).
FWIW I think the quote is off, or my translation, so you can blame me. Can't even find the book now, actually.
Re:The 'Grammar Vigilante' of Bristol [video]
by interfixus on Monday April 03, 2017 @10:56AM
(#14023171)
You are not crazy. You are evidently right. The downvotes are shameful.
Everyone here's replying like I'm crazy. I think it's just simply wrong to do anything to something that belongs to someone else without their permission unless you absolutely have to. No matter how trivial or clever it is. It's just wrong.